Both incidents highlight the vulnerability of refrigeration systemsBut, to answer the question I posed in the subject line...
connected to remote monitoring and control software, although no
connection between the two has been established.
On 11/6/2026 4:58 PM, Nicolas Paul Colin de Glocester wrote:
Both incidents highlight the vulnerability of refrigeration systemsBut, to answer the question I posed in the subject line...
connected to remote monitoring and control software, although no
connection between the two has been established.
I suspect freezers are more noticeable.ÿ Would anyone notice
a "warming tray" that suddenly had been turned off, allowing
the warmed items to "cool"?
I suspect the perpetrators want to be *seen* and not just prove
(to themselves -- which would be immediately apparent once they'd
access <whatever>) that they could do these things.
If you hacked the electric grid, you'd likely evoke an
aggressive response.ÿ Ditto telecom or any media distribution
system.
Freezers are noticeable events without getting everyone
riled up about the breach.ÿ So, you can "practice" for the
time when you want to have more devastating results and
still put fear in the populace.
But, again, what is the strategic point? To "strike terror" inFreezers are noticeable events without getting everyone
riled up about the breach.ÿ So, you can "practice" for the
time when you want to have more devastating results and
still put fear in the populace.
As of this afternoon the French Foreign Ministry is directly accusing Iran of
being behind the cyber attacks on their fridges.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmg474vk6dyqo
On 11/9/2026 12:18 PM, Martin Brown wrote:
But, again, what is the strategic point?ÿ To "strike terror" inFreezers are noticeable events without getting everyone
riled up about the breach.ÿ So, you can "practice" for the
time when you want to have more devastating results and
still put fear in the populace.
As of this afternoon the French Foreign Ministry is directly accusing
Iran of being behind the cyber attacks on their fridges.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmg474vk6dyqo
the hearts of people who can no longer buy chocolate ice cream?
Is it just "practice" (you don't want to squander any successes on a
REAL target alerting them to your abilities and their vulnerabilities)?
Is it a manifestation of the LIMITS of their abilities?ÿ Or, an insinuation of what MORE they might be able to do?
Carlos E. R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:
[...]
I have driven cars with almost no
electronics besides the radio.
That makes me feel old - when I learned to drive there were NO
electronics in most cars. A few luxury models had a radio (valve, of
course) but 'ordinary' cars didn't.
The first electonic device I fitted to my car was a windscreen wiper
delay circuit using a BC108 and a thyristor.
On 07/11/2026 16:45, Don Y wrote:
On 11/6/2026 4:58 PM, Nicolas Paul Colin de Glocester wrote:
Freezers are noticeable events without getting everyone
riled up about the breach.ÿ So, you can "practice" for the
time when you want to have more devastating results and
still put fear in the populace.
As of this afternoon the French Foreign Ministry is directly accusing
Iran of being behind the cyber attacks on their fridges.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmg474vk6dyqo
On 2026-11-09 20:18, Martin Brown wrote:
On 07/11/2026 16:45, Don Y wrote:
On 11/6/2026 4:58 PM, Nicolas Paul Colin de Glocester wrote:
Freezers are noticeable events without getting everyone
riled up about the breach.? So, you can "practice" for the
time when you want to have more devastating results and
still put fear in the populace.
As of this afternoon the French Foreign Ministry is directly accusing
Iran of being behind the cyber attacks on their fridges.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmg474vk6dyqo
Does not ring me as believable.
Is it a manifestation of the LIMITS of their abilities?ÿ Or, an insinuation >> of what MORE they might be able to do?
I wouldn't underestimate their capabilities. After Stuxnet the Iranians will be
looking to inflict equivalent damage on the West at some point.
On 11/10/2026 2:50 AM, Martin Brown wrote:
Is it a manifestation of the LIMITS of their abilities?ÿ Or, an
insinuation
of what MORE they might be able to do?
I wouldn't underestimate their capabilities. After Stuxnet the
Iranians will be looking to inflict equivalent damage on the West at
some point.
Yes, but why do *anything* publicly?ÿ What is the expected gain?
Surely, citizens aren't going to cringe in fear at the prospect
of not being able to purchase ice cream.
And, the "response" doesn't likely involve many government resources.
So, there doesn't seem to be any meaningful message (unless they
thought their adversaries didn't expect them to have ANY cyber
capabilities)
I wouldn't underestimate their capabilities. After Stuxnet the Iranians will
be looking to inflict equivalent damage on the West at some point.
Yes, but why do *anything* publicly?ÿ What is the expected gain?
Surely, citizens aren't going to cringe in fear at the prospect
of not being able to purchase ice cream.
Publicity for their cause assuming it was them...odd that they haven't so far
claimed responsibility.
It could equally well just be some modern script kiddies aided and abetted by
an AI agent capable of mounting such an attack en masse.
Don't underestimate the number of people who rely on immediate delivery of food
when they need it. Amazon Prime etc has created an expectation in the populous
that you can have anything anytime you want it.
And, the "response" doesn't likely involve many government resources.
So, there doesn't seem to be any meaningful message (unless they
thought their adversaries didn't expect them to have ANY cyber
capabilities)
I expect a more serious one against the UK National Grid (or the US equivalent)
at some stage. Generation I "smart" meters were always a disaster waiting to happen - insecure as hell. Their only redeeming feature was that they turned into dumb meters by changing supplier and now the discontinuation of 2G/œG signal scuppers them completely.
It is a real tale of woe - you couldn't make it up!!
https://www.theregister.com/networks/2026/11/10/smart-meters-to-cost-the-uk- billions-2g-switch-off-means-replacing-12-13-million/5308728
On 11/12/2026 11:14 AM, Martin Brown wrote:
I wouldn't underestimate their capabilities. After Stuxnet the
Iranians will be looking to inflict equivalent damage on the West at
some point.
Yes, but why do *anything* publicly?ÿ What is the expected gain?
Surely, citizens aren't going to cringe in fear at the prospect
of not being able to purchase ice cream.
Publicity for their cause assuming it was them...odd that they haven't
so far claimed responsibility.
So, "kicking someone in the knee" is their way of getting sympathy???
I could understand it from a terror standpoint -- get people thinking about how vulnerable they are.ÿ But, I would think the bar would be a bit higher
to get people to REALLY notice.
Crashing their corporate server(s) likely would have been far more consequential (had it actually been an adversarial action)
It could equally well just be some modern script kiddies aided and
abetted by an AI agent capable of mounting such an attack en masse.
But, again, why freezers?ÿ Why not petrol pumps?ÿ Or, baby monitors?
Or electronic doorbells?
Is it just the lowest hanging fruit?ÿ Or, the first of a series of
"waves" of vulnerability exploits?
I expect a more serious one against the UK National Grid (or the US
equivalent) at some stage. Generation I "smart" meters were always a
disaster waiting to happen - insecure as hell. Their only redeeming
feature was that they turned into dumb meters by changing supplier and
now the discontinuation of 2G/œG signal scuppers them completely.
It is a real tale of woe - you couldn't make it up!!
https://www.theregister.com/networks/2026/11/10/smart-meters-to-cost-the-uk- billions-2g-switch-off-means-replacing-12-13-million/5308728
The article doesn't make clear what loss of connectivity would mean
*beyond*
"being able to manage your own energy consumption".ÿ Would the meters disconnect subscriber loads if communication was lost?ÿ Or, would it just complicate billing?
Obviously, if everyone was suddenly disconnected from the grid, there would be panic.ÿ OTOH, if the provider had to dispatch an old fashioned "meter reader" I suspect customers would be far less concerned.
[I worked on the design of a meter in the late 80's and we avoided the remote
telemetry due to costs and the lack of an existing tariff that could be leveraged.ÿ At the time, reading a meter was worth "50p" so not a big
driver
of the design]
On 11/12/2026 11:14 AM, Martin Brown wrote:
I wouldn't underestimate their capabilities. After Stuxnet the
Iranians will be looking to inflict equivalent damage on the West at
some point.
Yes, but why do *anything* publicly?ÿ What is the expected gain?
Surely, citizens aren't going to cringe in fear at the prospect
of not being able to purchase ice cream.
Publicity for their cause assuming it was them...odd that they haven't
so far claimed responsibility.
So, "kicking someone in the knee" is their way of getting sympathy???
I could understand it from a terror standpoint -- get people thinking about how vulnerable they are.ÿ But, I would think the bar would be a bit higher
to get people to REALLY notice.
E.g., our local Costco (a large "warehouse club" store) suffered a power failure (some on-site equipment) and was out of service for a day or so.
But, it was just an annoyance to most folks as they were open for business the next day.
Crashing their corporate server(s) likely would have been far more consequential (had it actually been an adversarial action)
It could equally well just be some modern script kiddies aided and
abetted by an AI agent capable of mounting such an attack en masse.
But, again, why freezers?ÿ Why not petrol pumps?ÿ Or, baby monitors?
Or electronic doorbells?
Is it just the lowest hanging fruit?ÿ Or, the first of a series of
"waves" of vulnerability exploits?
Don't underestimate the number of people who rely on immediate
delivery of food when they need it. Amazon Prime etc has created an
expectation in the populous that you can have anything anytime you
want it.
I suspect "need" is an overstatement; maybe "want" (I doubt anyone will go hungry if they don't get their FROZEN food delivery, today)
And, the "response" doesn't likely involve many government resources.
So, there doesn't seem to be any meaningful message (unless they
thought their adversaries didn't expect them to have ANY cyber
capabilities)
I expect a more serious one against the UK National Grid (or the US
equivalent) at some stage. Generation I "smart" meters were always a
disaster waiting to happen - insecure as hell. Their only redeeming
feature was that they turned into dumb meters by changing supplier and
now the discontinuation of 2G/œG signal scuppers them completely.
It is a real tale of woe - you couldn't make it up!!
https://www.theregister.com/networks/2026/11/10/smart-meters-to-cost-
the-uk- billions-2g-switch-off-means-replacing-12-13-million/5308728
The article doesn't make clear what loss of connectivity would mean
*beyond*
"being able to manage your own energy consumption".ÿ Would the meters disconnect subscriber loads if communication was lost?ÿ Or, would it just complicate billing?
Obviously, if everyone was suddenly disconnected from the grid, there would be panic.ÿ OTOH, if the provider had to dispatch an old fashioned "meter reader" I suspect customers would be far less concerned.
[I worked on the design of a meter in the late 80's and we avoided the remote
telemetry due to costs and the lack of an existing tariff that could be leveraged.ÿ At the time, reading a meter was worth "50p" so not a big
driver
of the design]
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it
allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for
non payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> wrote:An adversary likely doesn't abide by those rules. So, unless the meters
[...]
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it
allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for
non payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
I don't think that is seen by the suppliers as a problem, I think it was
the main reason for installing them. There was huge pressure in the UK
to install them but it suddenly stopped when the Government made remote disconnection without due process illegal.
Crashing their corporate server(s) likely would have been far more
consequential (had it actually been an adversarial action)
It could equally well just be some modern script kiddies aided and abetted >>> by an AI agent capable of mounting such an attack en masse.
But, again, why freezers?ÿ Why not petrol pumps?ÿ Or, baby monitors?
Or electronic doorbells?
Because they (bad enough guys) found how to do it.
Is it just the lowest hanging fruit?ÿ Or, the first of a series of
"waves" of vulnerability exploits?
Don't underestimate the number of people who rely on immediate delivery of >>> food when they need it. Amazon Prime etc has created an expectation in the >>> populous that you can have anything anytime you want it.
I suspect "need" is an overstatement; maybe "want" (I doubt anyone will go >> hungry if they don't get their FROZEN food delivery, today)
There are flats with no kitchen. Maybe a microwave to reheat packaged portions,
or have the food ready to eat delivered from many restaurants just in time.
It is a real tale of woe - you couldn't make it up!!
https://www.theregister.com/networks/2026/11/10/smart-meters-to-cost- the- >>> uk- billions-2g-switch-off-means-replacing-12-13-million/5308728
The article doesn't make clear what loss of connectivity would mean *beyond* >> "being able to manage your own energy consumption".ÿ Would the meters
disconnect subscriber loads if communication was lost?ÿ Or, would it just
complicate billing?
Billing would be impossible.
Maybe, they can send a meter-man to read them manually, going home by home.
®"Smart meters are already helping millions of consumers manage their energy and save money on bills," they told The Reg. "The transition to 4G is a planned
upgrade that will continue to deliver the benefits that smart meters already provide to households and industry."¯
This is bollocks. It doesn't help me an iota (I'm in Spain, so not the same system). The only improvement I get is I get the invoice monthly instead of bimonthly.
Yes, I can get detailed info, so what? Not actually useful.
We can get billed for different prices at different hours. This is what they actually mean: you can shift your heavy usage to the hours when it is cheaper.
If you ignore this, maybe you end paying a lot more, so not beneficial.
Obviously, if everyone was suddenly disconnected from the grid, there would >> be panic.ÿ OTOH, if the provider had to dispatch an old fashioned "meter
reader" I suspect customers would be far less concerned.
[I worked on the design of a meter in the late 80's and we avoided the remote
telemetry due to costs and the lack of an existing tariff that could be
leveraged.ÿ At the time, reading a meter was worth "50p" so not a big driver >> of the design]
In Spain, I think all electricity meters can be remotely read (and possibly programmed). But they don't use phones, they use a signal transported on the AC
lines.
My water meter was improved recently so that it can be read by a meter-man withIsn't it interesting how THEY save labor costs and YOU pay more?
a handheld reader, so probably using low power BT. It was also moved to be under the street public pavement, not inside my garden.
Now they ordered that all gas meters be updated as well. They have some years,
maybe a decade, to do it. And the monthly invoice will go up half an euro.
On 11/13/2026 10:57 AM, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> wrote:
[...]
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it
allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for
non payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
I don't think that is seen by the suppliers as a problem, I think it was the main reason for installing them. There was huge pressure in the UKAn adversary likely doesn't abide by those rules. So, unless the meters
to install them but it suddenly stopped when the Government made remote disconnection without due process illegal.
have had that ability permanently disabled, it is still a rich attack surface.
On 11/13/2026 4:13 AM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
Crashing their corporate server(s) likely would have been far more
consequential (had it actually been an adversarial action)
It could equally well just be some modern script kiddies aided and
abetted by an AI agent capable of mounting such an attack en masse.
But, again, why freezers?ÿ Why not petrol pumps?ÿ Or, baby monitors?
Or electronic doorbells?
Because they (bad enough guys) found how to do it.
That suggests their toolkits aren't very deep; as if they "settled"
for something instead of *targeted* something.
Is it just the lowest hanging fruit?ÿ Or, the first of a series of
"waves" of vulnerability exploits?
Don't underestimate the number of people who rely on immediate
delivery of food when they need it. Amazon Prime etc has created an
expectation in the populous that you can have anything anytime you
want it.
I suspect "need" is an overstatement; maybe "want" (I doubt anyone
will go
hungry if they don't get their FROZEN food delivery, today)
There are flats with no kitchen. Maybe a microwave to reheat packaged
portions, or have the food ready to eat delivered from many
restaurants just in time.
I don't think that is the case, here -- except in dorm rooms or hotels.
Most homes have a kitchen or kitchenette.ÿ (Most dorms likely have a
hot plate, even if it is prohibited!).
For the most part, frozen (here) tends to be convenience -- having access
to something that is perishable or out-of-season or "quick" to prepare (having been pre-prepared prior to freezing)
It is a real tale of woe - you couldn't make it up!!
https://www.theregister.com/networks/2026/11/10/smart-meters-to-
cost- the- uk- billions-2g-switch-off-means-replacing-12-13-
million/5308728
The article doesn't make clear what loss of connectivity would mean
*beyond*
"being able to manage your own energy consumption".ÿ Would the meters
disconnect subscriber loads if communication was lost?ÿ Or, would it
just
complicate billing?
Billing would be impossible.
But, that's a temporary glitch.ÿ Push comes to shove, an army of
"meter readers" do it the old fashioned way.ÿ And/or, the subscribers
are charged with doing it under fear that misreporting will just make
the NEXT reading that much larger (more costly).
Maybe, they can send a meter-man to read them manually, going home by
home.
Until a few years ago, someone walked the neighborhood monthly,
glancing at the meter (mounted by the load center on the side of the house) and typed the reading into their datalogger.ÿ No doubt it had been
preloaded with names and addresses in the order in which those residences would be encountered (so, the effort is little more than *walking*
the area).
I htink the newer meters are now remotely read.
Water meters likelwise went through an upgrade; instead of lifting the
(cast iron) curbside meter cover and noting the reading, an electronic transducer has been fitted (along with new metering technology to
reduce error rates).ÿ But, I think those are read by a vehicle
driving through the neighborhood.
That may also be the case for the electric meters.
®"Smart meters are already helping millions of consumers manage their
energy and save money on bills," they told The Reg. "The transition to
4G is a planned upgrade that will continue to deliver the benefits
that smart meters already provide to households and industry."¯
This is bollocks. It doesn't help me an iota (I'm in Spain, so not the
same system). The only improvement I get is I get the invoice monthly
instead of bimonthly.
Yes, I can get detailed info, so what? Not actually useful.
I think it would depend on your tariff structure.ÿ E.g., ToU tariffs encourage the subscriber to "manually" shift their loads to off-peak hours. In reality, there isn't much of a savings in doing so -- but, there is a
big penalty for NOT doing so!
[One of the dirty little secrets about solar, here, is you end up
on a ToU tariff.ÿ Particularly damaging if your array can't keep up
with your demand during peak hours!]
We can get billed for different prices at different hours. This is
what they actually mean: you can shift your heavy usage to the hours
when it is cheaper. If you ignore this, maybe you end paying a lot
more, so not beneficial.
Many appliances include hooks for this, now.ÿ Some regions of the
country had tariffs where the provider could "control" those
loads (in times of peak demand) in exchange for some "con$ideration".
Obviously, if everyone was suddenly disconnected from the grid, there
would
be panic.ÿ OTOH, if the provider had to dispatch an old fashioned "meter >>> reader" I suspect customers would be far less concerned.
[I worked on the design of a meter in the late 80's and we avoided
the remote
telemetry due to costs and the lack of an existing tariff that could be
leveraged.ÿ At the time, reading a meter was worth "50p" so not a big
driver
of the design]
In Spain, I think all electricity meters can be remotely read (and
possibly programmed). But they don't use phones, they use a signal
transported on the AC lines.
Interfering with reading would just annoy the providers.ÿ To make a
real impact, you would need to annoy the *subscribers* -- disconnect their service!
My water meter was improved recently so that it can be read by aIsn't it interesting how THEY save labor costs and YOU pay more?
meter-man with a handheld reader, so probably using low power BT. It
was also moved to be under the street public pavement, not inside my
garden.
Now they ordered that all gas meters be updated as well. They have
some years, maybe a decade, to do it. And the monthly invoice will go
up half an euro.
On 12/11/2026 20:45, Don Y wrote:
On 11/12/2026 11:14 AM, Martin Brown wrote:
I wouldn't underestimate their capabilities. After Stuxnet the Iranians >>>>> will be looking to inflict equivalent damage on the West at some point. >>>>Yes, but why do *anything* publicly?ÿ What is the expected gain?
Surely, citizens aren't going to cringe in fear at the prospect
of not being able to purchase ice cream.
Publicity for their cause assuming it was them...odd that they haven't so >>> far claimed responsibility.
So, "kicking someone in the knee" is their way of getting sympathy???
I could understand it from a terror standpoint -- get people thinking about >> how vulnerable they are.ÿ But, I would think the bar would be a bit higher >> to get people to REALLY notice.
My instinct is that it is low hanging fruit/proof of concept and attacks will
scale up in severity and damage done. Today's Friday 13th Microsoft outage might even be the next example in the sequence.
Crashing their corporate server(s) likely would have been far more
consequential (had it actually been an adversarial action)
Malware locking of corporate servers took out UK retail giant Marks & Spencer
last year - their IT folk were on the ball and pulled the plug quickly to limit
damage but they still lost ~œ300M in the ensuing mess.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0el31nqnpvo https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c93x16zkl9do
Ransomeware is becoming big business in the blackhat community.
It could equally well just be some modern script kiddies aided and abetted >>> by an AI agent capable of mounting such an attack en masse.
But, again, why freezers?ÿ Why not petrol pumps?ÿ Or, baby monitors?
Or electronic doorbells?
Is it just the lowest hanging fruit?ÿ Or, the first of a series of
"waves" of vulnerability exploits?
I think both of them at once. Freezers were so trivial that pretty much anyone
could have done it even the old school script kiddies...
The article doesn't make clear what loss of connectivity would mean *beyond* >> "being able to manage your own energy consumption".ÿ Would the meters
disconnect subscriber loads if communication was lost?ÿ Or, would it just
complicate billing?
The loss of comms makes them passive dumb meters that have to be read from time
to time. They don't send meter readers any more unless they suspect you are ripping them off. The customer is expected to read their own meter. Mine is about 12' up in the air where mains enters the house and can only be read from
a stepladder. It is Gen2 smartmeter so probably secure enough (although it is
hard to be confident of that).
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it allows
the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for non payment of
bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
Imagine what would happen if a peak evening domestic premises load was thrashed
on and off synchronously at say once per second...
The security on generation 1 units was risible!
[I worked on the design of a meter in the late 80's and we avoided the remote
telemetry due to costs and the lack of an existing tariff that could be
leveraged.ÿ At the time, reading a meter was worth "50p" so not a big driver >> of the design]
The latest generation of smart meters have two modules the mains hot high current side for measurement and then the comms link module which talks to the
reporting network.
Unfortunately it still doesn't work properly in the north of England and Scotland due to inadequate investment. They use two different methods of communications mobile phone network in the south and RF elsewhere.
The latter does not work due to the north being hilly in parts!
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq52382zd1no
It really is a national embarrassment.
I suspect "need" is an overstatement; maybe "want" (I doubt anyone will go >>>> hungry if they don't get their FROZEN food delivery, today)
There are flats with no kitchen. Maybe a microwave to reheat packaged
portions, or have the food ready to eat delivered from many restaurants just
in time.
I don't think that is the case, here -- except in dorm rooms or hotels.
Most homes have a kitchen or kitchenette.ÿ (Most dorms likely have a
hot plate, even if it is prohibited!).
Google says they are common in Thailand. It also says they exist in Spain and USA.
Sources:
<https://agnetwest.com/no-kitchens-future-homes/>
No Kitchens in Future Homes?
December 11, 2023This Land of Ours
Will our future homes be built without kitchens? That?s coming up on This Land
of Ours.
<https://metropolismag.com/projects/anna-puigjaner-kitchenless-home/>
This Spanish Architect Wants to Revolutionize the Home?by Getting Rid of Kitchens
Few spaces of the home are as coveted as the kitchen. But Anna Puigjaner is showing the way out of these wasteful private cooking boxes toward more efficient ?shared? alternatives.
<https://www.treehugger.com/alice-constance-austin-houses-without- kitchens-5201804>
Alice Constance Austin Designed Houses Without Kitchens in 1917
An underground electric railway delivered food from central kitchens to each house.
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-kitchen_home>I think there would be a lot of resistance to that, here. Kitchens
Single-kitchen home
The single-kitchen home was a reform model of urban residential development in
which a centrally managed canteen kitchen within a multi-party house replaced
the kitchens of the individual apartments. The concept was based on the ideas
of the women's rights activist and social democrat Lily Braun. With the basic
idea of liberating women from housework, at the beginning of the 20th century
it was an explicit counter-design to the establishment of the isolated nuclear
family in mass housing. Single-kitchen houses, sometimes also called central kitchen houses, were implemented in various European large cities in isolated
and different ways until the 1950s. As key works of an idea of modern living,
some of these buildings were nominated for the European Heritage Label in 2009,
expressly as a network of common European architecture spread across various countries.
On 11/13/2026 3:47 AM, Martin Brown wrote:
On 12/11/2026 20:45, Don Y wrote:
On 11/12/2026 11:14 AM, Martin Brown wrote:
I wouldn't underestimate their capabilities. After Stuxnet the
Iranians will be looking to inflict equivalent damage on the West >>>>>> at some point.
Yes, but why do *anything* publicly?ÿ What is the expected gain?
Surely, citizens aren't going to cringe in fear at the prospect
of not being able to purchase ice cream.
Publicity for their cause assuming it was them...odd that they
haven't so far claimed responsibility.
So, "kicking someone in the knee" is their way of getting sympathy???
I could understand it from a terror standpoint -- get people thinking
about
how vulnerable they are.ÿ But, I would think the bar would be a bit
higher
to get people to REALLY notice.
My instinct is that it is low hanging fruit/proof of concept and
attacks will scale up in severity and damage done. Today's Friday 13th
Microsoft outage might even be the next example in the sequence.
Maybe air traffic control systems?
Crashing their corporate server(s) likely would have been far more
consequential (had it actually been an adversarial action)
Malware locking of corporate servers took out UK retail giant Marks &
Spencer last year - their IT folk were on the ball and pulled the plug
quickly to limit damage but they still lost ~œ300M in the ensuing mess.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c0el31nqnpvo
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c93x16zkl9do
Ransomeware is becoming big business in the blackhat community.
Yes, but that has to target individual entities.ÿ And, has an
easily understood motive (money).
No one demanded a ransom for freezer-gate.ÿ It's like the early days
of malware where the goal was just to poke you in the eye.
It could equally well just be some modern script kiddies aided and
abetted by an AI agent capable of mounting such an attack en masse.
But, again, why freezers?ÿ Why not petrol pumps?ÿ Or, baby monitors?
Or electronic doorbells?
Is it just the lowest hanging fruit?ÿ Or, the first of a series of
"waves" of vulnerability exploits?
I think both of them at once. Freezers were so trivial that pretty
much anyone could have done it even the old school script kiddies...
We'll see.ÿ It has value in that it makes it clear to "people in charge"
(and "people with stakes") that they are vulnerable.ÿ But, in most cases, people seem to think it will never be "them".
I had a laughable discussion with my MD about the security of their IT systems:
"Oh, we have a really GOOD staff!"ÿ (Wow, are you THAT naive to think
the BEST
folks are working for you and not banks, tech companies, etc.?)
This, despite one of the imaging companies, here, repeatedly being hacked.
(I guess they must not hire "really GOOD staff"?)
The article doesn't make clear what loss of connectivity would mean
*beyond*
"being able to manage your own energy consumption".ÿ Would the meters
disconnect subscriber loads if communication was lost?ÿ Or, would it
just
complicate billing?
The loss of comms makes them passive dumb meters that have to be read
from time to time. They don't send meter readers any more unless they
suspect you are ripping them off. The customer is expected to read
their own meter. Mine is about 12' up in the air where mains enters
the house and can only be read from a stepladder. It is Gen2
smartmeter so probably secure enough (although it is hard to be
confident of that).
In the past, ours were read semiregularly.ÿ "Estimated" if not read.
And, from time to time, WE were asked to read it (just draw the
positions of the indicators on the dials and THEY would interpret).
I think there is some legislative requirement that they have to
actually read them periodically to ensure fairness in billing.
Meters (gas, electric, water) tend to be in varying locations and
some folks have theirs in "secured" areas.ÿ So, reading can be
costly for a human reader (who has to gain entry to those areas)
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it
allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for
non payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
When I was designing meter, the disconnect feature was too costly
to implement (100A+ on two conductors).ÿ The meter itself is the
"fuse" so it is removed when service is disconnected.ÿ A locking
ring holds the meter to the mating socket and the meter is replaced by
a blank cover (to protect from the bare line contacts) when it
is removed -- still secured by said ring)
Imagine what would happen if a peak evening domestic premises load was
thrashed on and off synchronously at say once per second...
I would question whether or not they could affect such control
over that many loads at that rate.ÿ It would seem an overprovisioned communication channel if such a "rare" event could be signalled
that often.
The security on generation 1 units was risible!
But that's true of most electronic devices.ÿ Security is most often
an afterthought.
Connectivity, decades ago, was largely point-to-point (serial ports,
HDLC, etc.)ÿ So, getting physical access to the "conductor" was
often a high enough hurdle.
Now, people put NICs in damn near everything, never thinking that
THEIR device would ever be hacked ("Who would want to hack a
'scope?"ÿ Ans:ÿ someone who wants to hack something ELSE in
that lab!)
[I worked on the design of a meter in the late 80's and we avoided
the remote
telemetry due to costs and the lack of an existing tariff that could be
leveraged.ÿ At the time, reading a meter was worth "50p" so not a big
driver
of the design]
The latest generation of smart meters have two modules the mains hot
high current side for measurement and then the comms link module which
talks to the reporting network.
Unfortunately it still doesn't work properly in the north of England
and Scotland due to inadequate investment. They use two different
methods of communications mobile phone network in the south and RF
elsewhere.
The latter does not work due to the north being hilly in parts!
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq52382zd1no
It really is a national embarrassment.
Shoot the engineer?ÿ Or, the clown who specified the system??
I could understand it from a terror standpoint -- get people thinking about
how vulnerable they are.ÿ But, I would think the bar would be a bit higher >>>> to get people to REALLY notice.
My instinct is that it is low hanging fruit/proof of concept and attacks >>> will scale up in severity and damage done. Today's Friday 13th Microsoft >>> outage might even be the next example in the sequence.
Maybe air traffic control systems?
That appears to be a coincidence and a manifestation of the pay peanuts get monkeys problem.
Yes, but that has to target individual entities.ÿ And, has an
easily understood motive (money).
No one demanded a ransom for freezer-gate.ÿ It's like the early days
of malware where the goal was just to poke you in the eye.
Indeed. It effectively launched the third party AV industry.
We'll see.ÿ It has value in that it makes it clear to "people in charge"
(and "people with stakes") that they are vulnerable.ÿ But, in most cases,
people seem to think it will never be "them".
I had a laughable discussion with my MD about the security of their IT systems:
"Oh, we have a really GOOD staff!"ÿ (Wow, are you THAT naive to think the BEST
folks are working for you and not banks, tech companies, etc.?)
Have you seen the North Korean "FaceStealer" one that uses an AI fake zoom meeting with someone senior and known to you to get enough video to fake you to
someone else? It is making the news in Japan at the moment and several fairly
high profile cyber experts have fallen for it.
https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/news/20261113de75641/
About $400M stolen so far and its still running.
This, despite one of the imaging companies, here, repeatedly being hacked. >> (I guess they must not hire "really GOOD staff"?)
It is remarkably easy to get hacked if the workplace culture isn't right. I allowed a whole day for delousing our Korean office every trip.
In the past, ours were read semiregularly.ÿ "Estimated" if not read.
And, from time to time, WE were asked to read it (just draw the
positions of the indicators on the dials and THEY would interpret).
I think there is some legislative requirement that they have to
actually read them periodically to ensure fairness in billing.
You still have dials on the meters? Electromechanical ones have been long gone
here. Mine even wrapped around before it was replaced.
Meters (gas, electric, water) tend to be in varying locations and
some folks have theirs in "secured" areas.ÿ So, reading can be
costly for a human reader (who has to gain entry to those areas)
We have somewhat insane water and sewerage arrangements where I live being on
the cusp of a watershed. Water comes to us from Northumbria (essentially limitless supply) but sewage goes to Yorkshire.
The upshot is the Yorkshire Water can never find the incoming water meter which
belongs to Northumbria and so do crazy estimates!
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it
allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for non >>> payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
When I was designing meter, the disconnect feature was too costly
to implement (100A+ on two conductors).ÿ The meter itself is the
"fuse" so it is removed when service is disconnected.ÿ A locking
ring holds the meter to the mating socket and the meter is replaced by
a blank cover (to protect from the bare line contacts) when it
is removed -- still secured by said ring)
There is a separate 100/80/60A fuse on live of a UK domestic 240v installation.
Most towns and cities are three phase, my village is only two opposite phases
and neutral which isn't common any more. >
Imagine what would happen if a peak evening domestic premises load was
thrashed on and off synchronously at say once per second...
I would question whether or not they could affect such control
over that many loads at that rate.ÿ It would seem an overprovisioned
communication channel if such a "rare" event could be signalled
that often.
I don't know what it is capable of - the specification is unclear.
The security on generation 1 units was risible!
But that's true of most electronic devices.ÿ Security is most often
an afterthought.
Connectivity, decades ago, was largely point-to-point (serial ports,
HDLC, etc.)ÿ So, getting physical access to the "conductor" was
often a high enough hurdle.
They were rolled out late enough that it should have been obvious that they needed to be secure (but weren't). Doing something to roll them out immediately
was seen as far more important than doing the right thing.
Now, people put NICs in damn near everything, never thinking that
THEIR device would ever be hacked ("Who would want to hack a
'scope?"ÿ Ans:ÿ someone who wants to hack something ELSE in
that lab!)
I was amusing to find a Wifi chipset in my microwave oven when the service engineer had it in bits.
My limited experience with british culture suggests the higher upsUnfortunately it still doesn't work properly in the north of England and >>> Scotland due to inadequate investment. They use two different methods of >>> communications mobile phone network in the south and RF elsewhere.
The latter does not work due to the north being hilly in parts!
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq52382zd1no
It really is a national embarrassment.
Shoot the engineer?ÿ Or, the clown who specified the system??
I expect the engineers knew perfectly well that it wouldn't work but were overruled by the bean counters and the management suits.
On 11/13/2026 1:47 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
I think there would be a lot of resistance to that, here.ÿ KitchensI suspect "need" is an overstatement; maybe "want" (I doubt anyone
will go
hungry if they don't get their FROZEN food delivery, today)
There are flats with no kitchen. Maybe a microwave to reheat
packaged portions, or have the food ready to eat delivered from many
restaurants just in time.
I don't think that is the case, here -- except in dorm rooms or hotels.
Most homes have a kitchen or kitchenette.ÿ (Most dorms likely have a
hot plate, even if it is prohibited!).
Google says they are common in Thailand. It also says they exist in
Spain and USA.
Sources:
<https://agnetwest.com/no-kitchens-future-homes/>
No Kitchens in Future Homes?
December 11, 2023This Land of Ours
Will our future homes be built without kitchens? That?s coming up on
This Land of Ours.
<https://metropolismag.com/projects/anna-puigjaner-kitchenless-home/>
This Spanish Architect Wants to Revolutionize the Home?by Getting Rid
of Kitchens
Few spaces of the home are as coveted as the kitchen. But Anna
Puigjaner is showing the way out of these wasteful private cooking
boxes toward more efficient ?shared? alternatives.
<https://www.treehugger.com/alice-constance-austin-houses-without-
kitchens-5201804>
Alice Constance Austin Designed Houses Without Kitchens in 1917
An underground electric railway delivered food from central kitchens
to each house.
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-kitchen_home>
Single-kitchen home
The single-kitchen home was a reform model of urban residential
development in which a centrally managed canteen kitchen within a
multi-party house replaced the kitchens of the individual apartments.
The concept was based on the ideas of the women's rights activist and
social democrat Lily Braun. With the basic idea of liberating women
from housework, at the beginning of the 20th century it was an
explicit counter-design to the establishment of the isolated nuclear
family in mass housing. Single-kitchen houses, sometimes also called
central kitchen houses, were implemented in various European large
cities in isolated and different ways until the 1950s. As key works of
an idea of modern living, some of these buildings were nominated for
the European Heritage Label in 2009, expressly as a network of common
European architecture spread across various countries.
are one of the most "gifted" rooms in a home -- appliances, gadgets,
etc.
You will still end up with some sort of place to store foodstuffs and
the means to eat them (and some limited means of preparing them).
Hard to imagine refrigerators, freezers, ice makers, etc. going away.
And, with young people struggling to *afford* a home, it's hard
to believe they would "dine out" at a higher price vs. prepping
their own meals.ÿ E.g., a purchased $15 burger is a bit
excessive if you can't make your mortgage payment!
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it
allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for
non payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
When I was designing meter, the disconnect feature was too costly
to implement (100A+ on two conductors).ÿ The meter itself is the
"fuse" so it is removed when service is disconnected.ÿ A locking
ring holds the meter to the mating socket and the meter is replaced by
a blank cover (to protect from the bare line contacts) when it
is removed -- still secured by said ring)
On 2026-11-14 09:18, Don Y wrote:
On 11/13/2026 1:47 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
I think there would be a lot of resistance to that, here.ÿ KitchensI suspect "need" is an overstatement; maybe "want" (I doubt anyone will go
hungry if they don't get their FROZEN food delivery, today)
There are flats with no kitchen. Maybe a microwave to reheat packaged >>>>> portions, or have the food ready to eat delivered from many restaurants >>>>> just in time.
I don't think that is the case, here -- except in dorm rooms or hotels. >>>> Most homes have a kitchen or kitchenette.ÿ (Most dorms likely have a
hot plate, even if it is prohibited!).
Google says they are common in Thailand. It also says they exist in Spain >>> and USA.
Sources:
<https://agnetwest.com/no-kitchens-future-homes/>
No Kitchens in Future Homes?
December 11, 2023This Land of Ours
Will our future homes be built without kitchens? That?s coming up on This >>> Land of Ours.
<https://metropolismag.com/projects/anna-puigjaner-kitchenless-home/>
This Spanish Architect Wants to Revolutionize the Home?by Getting Rid of >>> Kitchens
Few spaces of the home are as coveted as the kitchen. But Anna Puigjaner is
showing the way out of these wasteful private cooking boxes toward more >>> efficient ?shared? alternatives.
<https://www.treehugger.com/alice-constance-austin-houses-without-
kitchens-5201804>
Alice Constance Austin Designed Houses Without Kitchens in 1917
An underground electric railway delivered food from central kitchens to each
house.
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-kitchen_home>
Single-kitchen home
The single-kitchen home was a reform model of urban residential development
in which a centrally managed canteen kitchen within a multi-party house >>> replaced the kitchens of the individual apartments. The concept was based on
the ideas of the women's rights activist and social democrat Lily Braun. >>> With the basic idea of liberating women from housework, at the beginning of
the 20th century it was an explicit counter-design to the establishment of >>> the isolated nuclear family in mass housing. Single-kitchen houses,
sometimes also called central kitchen houses, were implemented in various >>> European large cities in isolated and different ways until the 1950s. As key
works of an idea of modern living, some of these buildings were nominated >>> for the European Heritage Label in 2009, expressly as a network of common >>> European architecture spread across various countries.
are one of the most "gifted" rooms in a home -- appliances, gadgets,
etc.
You will still end up with some sort of place to store foodstuffs and
the means to eat them (and some limited means of preparing them).
Hard to imagine refrigerators, freezers, ice makers, etc. going away.
And, with young people struggling to *afford* a home, it's hard
to believe they would "dine out" at a higher price vs. prepping
their own meals.ÿ E.g., a purchased $15 burger is a bit
excessive if you can't make your mortgage payment!
A comunal kitchen that prepares the same dinner for everybody, is cheaper than
20 kitchens with their food stores.
Frozen food or ready to eat packages are not that expensive.
On 2026-11-14 04:56, Don Y wrote:
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that it
allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer (eg for non >>> payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull the fuse.
When I was designing meter, the disconnect feature was too costly
to implement (100A+ on two conductors).ÿ The meter itself is the
"fuse" so it is removed when service is disconnected.ÿ A locking
ring holds the meter to the mating socket and the meter is replaced by
a blank cover (to protect from the bare line contacts) when it
is removed -- still secured by said ring)
In the case of Spain, the meter has the ability to limit the Amps. It can switch off.
This is because the contract with the utility says how many Amps the client contracts, in steps of 5A, but written in Watts. And the monthly receipt charges an amount that is proportional to the number of days and the Watts. Thus we try to contract the minimum we can live with. I have 10A total because
it is a very old contract, but typical would be 20A.
The meter can be programmed remotely to a number or amps. If the limit is 15 and you draw more, it triggers and powers off the house for some time.
(I have a 10A contract, but the limiter seems to have a lower limit of 15, not
10).
Thus, they also have the ability to remotely switch off a client. Some clients
would then remove the meter and put a jumper, if they can access it.
On 11/14/2026 1:59 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
On 2026-11-14 04:56, Don Y wrote:
The big problem with smart meters when they are fully smart is that
it allows the supplier to do remote disconnection of the customer
(eg for non payment of bill) without visiting the premises to pull
the fuse.
When I was designing meter, the disconnect feature was too costly
to implement (100A+ on two conductors).ÿ The meter itself is the
"fuse" so it is removed when service is disconnected.ÿ A locking
ring holds the meter to the mating socket and the meter is replaced by
a blank cover (to protect from the bare line contacts) when it
is removed -- still secured by said ring)
In the case of Spain, the meter has the ability to limit the Amps. It
can switch off.
This is because the contract with the utility says how many Amps the
client contracts, in steps of 5A, but written in Watts. And the
monthly receipt charges an amount that is proportional to the number
of days and the Watts. Thus we try to contract the minimum we can live
with. I have 10A total because it is a very old contract, but typical
would be 20A.
The meter can be programmed remotely to a number or amps. If the limit
is 15 and you draw more, it triggers and powers off the house for some
time.
(I have a 10A contract, but the limiter seems to have a lower limit of
15, not 10).
A typical home, here, will have a 100A or 200A service.
Our "quiescent load" is probably close to 1000W (the house is
always active so there is no time when everything is "off";
there are usually 3 or 4 computers running, TV, etc.)
The air conditioner draws 15A @ 220VAC -- plus another kilowatt
for the blower motor.
The electric range/oven draws up to 3KW per stovetop burner;
probably comparable for the elements inside the ovens.
A hand-held hair dryer, 1000W.ÿ Ditto for a toaster.ÿ Or electric
frying pan.
[Each of my workstations has an 1100W power supply -- though that
isn't taxed significantly in any of them]
Thus, they also have the ability to remotely switch off a client. Some
clients would then remove the meter and put a jumper, if they can
access it.
A typical home, here, will have a 100A or 200A service.
Our "quiescent load" is probably close to 1000W (the house is
always active so there is no time when everything is "off";
there are usually 3 or 4 computers running, TV, etc.)
The air conditioner draws 15A @ 220VAC -- plus another kilowatt
for the blower motor.
Mine draws 200..300 watts to maintain the temperature. Cools 3 rooms. Can draw
up to 1200 W when the temp difference is "big".
Computers draw little. The biggest may be 100..200 watts normally, but I haven't measured it recently.
Standby things, maybe 50.
The electric range/oven draws up to 3KW per stovetop burner;
probably comparable for the elements inside the ovens.
I have to use one at a time, so 1 KW.
A hand-held hair dryer, 1000W.ÿ Ditto for a toaster.ÿ Or electric
frying pan.
Wait for your turn. :-)
My house is a special case. Typical house can have 15..25A. It is your choice,
but you pay for it. So, you choose as little as you can make with.
[Each of my workstations has an 1100W power supply -- though that
isn't taxed significantly in any of them]
Thus, they also have the ability to remotely switch off a client. Some
clients would then remove the meter and put a jumper, if they can access it.
A typical home, here, will have a 100A or 200A service.
Our "quiescent load" is probably close to 1000W (the house is
always active so there is no time when everything is "off";
there are usually 3 or 4 computers running, TV, etc.)
The air conditioner draws 15A @ 220VAC -- plus another kilowatt
for the blower motor.
Mine draws 200..300 watts to maintain the temperature. Cools 3 rooms.
Can draw up to 1200 W when the temp difference is "big".
It takes a lot of refrigeration to cool a few thousand square feet
when the outdoor temperature is 110F.
etc.
Electricity is relatively cheap (~15c/KWHr) and unplugging things
that don't have real power switches is a real hassle!
Wait for your turn. :-)
We rarely dry our hair as it's easier to just crack a window in the
car and it dries in just a couple of minutes (low humidity).ÿ No need
to dry it if you're staying home!
My house is a special case. Typical house can have 15..25A. It is your
choice, but you pay for it. So, you choose as little as you can make
with.
In general, americans are pretty wasteful of energy.ÿ (acknowledging that SWMBO & I are gluttonous; OTOH, we probably use less than 200 gallons of petrol annually for our *combined* needs).ÿ But, energy is relatively cheap and plentiful so convenience trumps cost.
On 2026-11-16 01:09, Don Y wrote:
A typical home, here, will have a 100A or 200A service.
Our "quiescent load" is probably close to 1000W (the house is
always active so there is no time when everything is "off";
there are usually 3 or 4 computers running, TV, etc.)
The air conditioner draws 15A @ 220VAC -- plus another kilowatt
for the blower motor.
Mine draws 200..300 watts to maintain the temperature. Cools 3 rooms. Can >>> draw up to 1200 W when the temp difference is "big".
It takes a lot of refrigeration to cool a few thousand square feet
when the outdoor temperature is 110F.
Maybe, but:
ÿ I don't cool the entire house, just a part.
ÿ I just cool down to 27øC (80.6F).
I live in a city by the Mediterranean, so temps rarely go above 35øC. It
usually sits below 31 in August, but with high humidity. Just go inland by 50
Km, and temps of 40 happen too much.
Electricity is relatively cheap (~15c/KWHr) and unplugging things
that don't have real power switches is a real hassle!
True. I have my bunch of stdby things, but you win :-p
Wait for your turn. :-)
I just don't have the power (old house with no certified installation), so I just don't turn hungry things at the same time. I have to calculate when to power up what. New houses or simply houses with a certified installation have
more power, but as in Spain we have to pay for each Watt our installation can
draw simultaneously, unless you are rich we do have a care to reduce simultaneous load. We have to.
For example, my electric hot water tank (I can also use gas heated water) draws
just 1KW, and has a timer to run from 3AM to 9AM. Plus, I inserted a diode in
series so in fact only uses 500W. It works fine :-D
Spain is peculiar in this. Google says France, Italy and Portugal do similar,If devices could sleep AND WAKE quickly and efficiently, there is a
but not Germany, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and most of northern and
central Europe.
We rarely dry our hair as it's easier to just crack a window in the
car and it dries in just a couple of minutes (low humidity).ÿ No need
to dry it if you're staying home!
My house is a special case. Typical house can have 15..25A. It is yourIn general, americans are pretty wasteful of energy.ÿ (acknowledging that
choice, but you pay for it. So, you choose as little as you can make with. >>
SWMBO & I are gluttonous; OTOH, we probably use less than 200 gallons of
petrol annually for our *combined* needs).ÿ But, energy is relatively cheap >> and plentiful so convenience trumps cost.
Yes, I know that :-)
For example, my electric hot water tank (I can also use gas heated
water) draws just 1KW, and has a timer to run from 3AM to 9AM. Plus, I
inserted a diode in series so in fact only uses 500W. It works fine ?
The timer wouldn't work well, here, owing to the "never down" aspect of
our living style.ÿ Our water heater is gas-fired; we are equally gluttonous with our use of hot water (nothing finer than a nice LONG, hot shower!)
On 2026-11-17 16:02, Don Y wrote:
...
For example, my electric hot water tank (I can also use gas heated water) >>> draws just 1KW, and has a timer to run from 3AM to 9AM. Plus, I inserted a >>> diode in series so in fact only uses 500W. It works fine ?
The timer wouldn't work well, here, owing to the "never down" aspect of
our living style.ÿ Our water heater is gas-fired; we are equally gluttonous >> with our use of hot water (nothing finer than a nice LONG, hot shower!)
It is a tank. It stores hot water for use anytime, but may be active just a few
hours, like when electricity is cheaper.
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can enable any of the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot water too much resulting in
too hot water for showers, there is not enough cold water (and not cold enough)
to cool down that flow during the summer showers. So during the summer I decided to use the electric tank and use much less water.
In winter (not yet here!) I'll reverse and use the gas fired water heater.
On 11/17/2026 2:53 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
On 2026-11-17 16:02, Don Y wrote:
...
For example, my electric hot water tank (I can also use gas heated
water) draws just 1KW, and has a timer to run from 3AM to 9AM. Plus,
I inserted a diode in series so in fact only uses 500W. It works
fine ?
The timer wouldn't work well, here, owing to the "never down" aspect of
our living style.ÿ Our water heater is gas-fired; we are equally
gluttonous
with our use of hot water (nothing finer than a nice LONG, hot shower!)
It is a tank. It stores hot water for use anytime, but may be active
just a few hours, like when electricity is cheaper.
Yes, most water heaters, here, are tanks with a gas or electric heating element.ÿ "Tankless" units are less common.
The size (volume) of the tank determines how long that hot shower will
be...
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can enable
any of the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot water too
much resulting in
Ah! I had not considered that! The tank has a thermostat. I
never considered how they would (could?) set the temperature of
water in a tankless unit, esp a gas-fired unit.
too hot water for showers, there is not enough cold water (and not
cold enough) to cool down that flow during the summer showers. So
during the summer I decided to use the electric tank and use much less
water.
In winter (not yet here!) I'll reverse and use the gas fired water
heater.
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can enable any of
the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot water too much resulting in
Ah!ÿ I had not considered that!ÿ The tank has a thermostat.ÿ I
never considered how they would (could?) set the temperature of
water in a tankless unit, esp a gas-fired unit.
My gas flash heater is a simple one. It uses a fixed gas rate, so the more you
open the tap, the colder the water runs. The gas flow can be adjusted manually,
same as in a gas ring, with a knob.
ÿÿ It has a security thermostat that switchs off the gas
ÿÿ if the output water goes over some very high temperature.
ÿÿ I don't know what T.
In summer, it runs too hot, even with a a full tap. I need to mix with cold water, also at full tap. Not enough cold water, though.
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gas dynamically, so thatIt seems it would be easier to adjust temperature by controlling a mixing valve. Especially in cases where sudden drops in water pressure can
the water keeps a constant temperature, independent of entry temp and water flow rate. So it needs electrical power to run the adjustments. Summer, winter,
one tap, two, half tap, full tap... no matter, the temperature is constant.
On 2026-11-18 00:29, Don Y wrote:
On 11/17/2026 2:53 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
On 2026-11-17 16:02, Don Y wrote:
...
It is a tank. It stores hot water for use anytime, but may be activeFor example, my electric hot water tank (I can also use gas heated
water) draws just 1KW, and has a timer to run from 3AM to 9AM. Plus, >>>>> I inserted a diode in series so in fact only uses 500W. It works
fine ?
The timer wouldn't work well, here, owing to the "never down" aspect of >>>> our living style.? Our water heater is gas-fired; we are equally
gluttonous
with our use of hot water (nothing finer than a nice LONG, hot shower!) >>>
just a few hours, like when electricity is cheaper.
Yes, most water heaters, here, are tanks with a gas or electric heating
element.? "Tankless" units are less common.
The size (volume) of the tank determines how long that hot shower will
be...
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can enable
any of the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot water too
much resulting in
Ah! I had not considered that! The tank has a thermostat. I
never considered how they would (could?) set the temperature of
water in a tankless unit, esp a gas-fired unit.
My gas flash heater is a simple one. It uses a fixed gas rate, so the
more you open the tap, the colder the water runs. The gas flow can be >adjusted manually, same as in a gas ring, with a knob.
It has a security thermostat that switchs off the gas
if the output water goes over some very high temperature.
I don't know what T.
In summer, it runs too hot, even with a a full tap. I need to mix with
cold water, also at full tap. Not enough cold water, though.
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gas dynamically,
so that the water keeps a constant temperature, independent of entry
temp and water flow rate. So it needs electrical power to run the >adjustments. Summer, winter, one tap, two, half tap, full tap... no
matter, the temperature is constant.
<https://apnews.com/article/europe-supermarkets-freezers-cyberattacks- a8ea5b30d67da47957769f29101fe686>
"...its fridges and freezers had been hacked and set to 50 degrees Celsius"
And, why would a temperature controller for a FREEZER ever allow
such a high temperature?ÿ In case you wanted to convert them to
walk-in ovens???
Who *specifies* such systems and who naively implements those specifications?
[The last batch of targets used "older technology"... so, nothing
was learned in the revisions that followed?]
On 11/17/2026 6:34 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can
enable any of the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot
water too much resulting in
Ah!ÿ I had not considered that!ÿ The tank has a thermostat.ÿ I
never considered how they would (could?) set the temperature of
water in a tankless unit, esp a gas-fired unit.
My gas flash heater is a simple one. It uses a fixed gas rate, so the
more you open the tap, the colder the water runs. The gas flow can be
adjusted manually, same as in a gas ring, with a knob.
Our water heaters monitor the temperature of the water in the tank
and gate the heating element on/off.ÿ I don't think there is
proportional control (the tank's volume is used against duty cycle
to achieve that).
ÿÿÿ It has a security thermostat that switchs off the gas
ÿÿÿ if the output water goes over some very high temperature.
ÿÿÿ I don't know what T.
Ours have an overpressure relief that vents the tank.ÿ Most homes fail
to install expansion tanks on the water heater so it is possible for
water pressure to increase as the water is heated (and expands).
Homes with pressure reducing valves often rely on the valve's design
to open when "inside" pressure exceeds that of the water main.ÿ But,
that defeats the purpose of having a pressure reducing valve.
In summer, it runs too hot, even with a a full tap. I need to mix with
cold water, also at full tap. Not enough cold water, though.
We have a similar problem with our cold water supply -- you need to
rely on chilled water if you like a "cold drink" in summer.
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gasIt seems it would be easier to adjust temperature by controlling a mixing valve.ÿ Especially in cases where sudden drops in water pressure can
dynamically, so that the water keeps a constant temperature,
independent of entry temp and water flow rate. So it needs electrical
power to run the adjustments. Summer, winter, one tap, two, half tap,
full tap... no matter, the temperature is constant.
affect the output.
On 2026-11-18 04:58, Don Y wrote:
On 11/17/2026 6:34 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can enable any
of the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot water too much >>>>> resulting in
Ah!ÿ I had not considered that!ÿ The tank has a thermostat.ÿ I
never considered how they would (could?) set the temperature of
water in a tankless unit, esp a gas-fired unit.
My gas flash heater is a simple one. It uses a fixed gas rate, so the more >>> you open the tap, the colder the water runs. The gas flow can be adjusted >>> manually, same as in a gas ring, with a knob.
Our water heaters monitor the temperature of the water in the tank
and gate the heating element on/off.ÿ I don't think there is
proportional control (the tank's volume is used against duty cycle
to achieve that).
I suppose you know that flash heaters do not have a tank: they just heat the water in a heat exchanger with a big flame.
The type of flash heater with proportional adjustment may have a small tank, less than 10 litres. Hot water is instant, on demand. Normal flash heaters have
a delay, from a pair of seconds up to half a minute.
ÿÿÿ It has a security thermostat that switchs off the gas
ÿÿÿ if the output water goes over some very high temperature.
ÿÿÿ I don't know what T.
Ours have an overpressure relief that vents the tank.ÿ Most homes fail
to install expansion tanks on the water heater so it is possible for
water pressure to increase as the water is heated (and expands).
Homes with pressure reducing valves often rely on the valve's design
to open when "inside" pressure exceeds that of the water main.ÿ But,
that defeats the purpose of having a pressure reducing valve.
In summer, it runs too hot, even with a a full tap. I need to mix with cold
water, also at full tap. Not enough cold water, though.
We have a similar problem with our cold water supply -- you need to
rely on chilled water if you like a "cold drink" in summer.
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gas dynamically, so >>> that the water keeps a constant temperature, independent of entry temp and >>> water flow rate. So it needs electrical power to run the adjustments.It seems it would be easier to adjust temperature by controlling a mixing
Summer, winter, one tap, two, half tap, full tap... no matter, the
temperature is constant.
valve.ÿ Especially in cases where sudden drops in water pressure can
affect the output.
Controlling the gas flow saves water and gas.
But they do exist, of course, just that they are implemented in the tap: a knobMany "valve sets", here, are implemented as mix+volume.
sets the desired temperature, and another the total water flow you want.
<https://www.amazon.es/-/en/Thermostatic-Thermostat-Chrome-plated-Temperature-
Comfortable/dp/B0FH6XG7LF>
On 11/19/2026 4:28 AM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
On 2026-11-18 04:58, Don Y wrote:
On 11/17/2026 6:34 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can
enable any of the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot
water too much resulting in
Ah!ÿ I had not considered that!ÿ The tank has a thermostat.ÿ I
never considered how they would (could?) set the temperature of
water in a tankless unit, esp a gas-fired unit.
My gas flash heater is a simple one. It uses a fixed gas rate, so
the more you open the tap, the colder the water runs. The gas flow
can be adjusted manually, same as in a gas ring, with a knob.
Our water heaters monitor the temperature of the water in the tank
and gate the heating element on/off.ÿ I don't think there is
proportional control (the tank's volume is used against duty cycle
to achieve that).
I suppose you know that flash heaters do not have a tank: they just
heat the water in a heat exchanger with a big flame.
Yes.
The type of flash heater with proportional adjustment may have a small
tank, less than 10 litres. Hot water is instant, on demand. Normal
flash heaters have a delay, from a pair of seconds up to half a minute.
I would have assumed that getting fast response from direct control of the heating element would be more difficult than altering the blend of heated
and unheated water.
ÿÿÿ It has a security thermostat that switchs off the gas
ÿÿÿ if the output water goes over some very high temperature.
ÿÿÿ I don't know what T.
Ours have an overpressure relief that vents the tank.ÿ Most homes fail
to install expansion tanks on the water heater so it is possible for
water pressure to increase as the water is heated (and expands).
Homes with pressure reducing valves often rely on the valve's design
to open when "inside" pressure exceeds that of the water main.ÿ But,
that defeats the purpose of having a pressure reducing valve.
In summer, it runs too hot, even with a a full tap. I need to mix
with cold water, also at full tap. Not enough cold water, though.
We have a similar problem with our cold water supply -- you need to
rely on chilled water if you like a "cold drink" in summer.
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gasIt seems it would be easier to adjust temperature by controlling a
dynamically, so that the water keeps a constant temperature,
independent of entry temp and water flow rate. So it needs
electrical power to run the adjustments. Summer, winter, one tap,
two, half tap, full tap... no matter, the temperature is constant.
mixing
valve.ÿ Especially in cases where sudden drops in water pressure can
affect the output.
Controlling the gas flow saves water and gas.
The *tap* determines the amount of water used, regardless of what the water heater is doing.
But they do exist, of course, just that they are implemented in theMany "valve sets", here, are implemented as mix+volume.
tap: a knob sets the desired temperature, and another the total water
flow you want.
<https://www.amazon.es/-/en/Thermostatic-Thermostat-Chrome-plated-
Temperature- Comfortable/dp/B0FH6XG7LF>
But, you still have the transport delay from heating unit to tap.
In some sites (esp commercial), a small water heater is located *at*
the site of consumption so there is less transport delay.
But, you need a source of energy *at* that location (so electricity
is most often used)
On Wed, 18 Nov 2026 02:34:47 +0100, "Carlos E.R."
<robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:
On 2026-11-18 00:29, Don Y wrote:Whan I was a kid, we had a tankless water heater that had a temperature-operated gas valve, a bimetal thing. No electricity
On 11/17/2026 2:53 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
On 2026-11-17 16:02, Don Y wrote:
...
It is a tank. It stores hot water for use anytime, but may be activeFor example, my electric hot water tank (I can also use gas heated >>>>>> water) draws just 1KW, and has a timer to run from 3AM to 9AM. Plus, >>>>>> I inserted a diode in series so in fact only uses 500W. It works
fine ?
The timer wouldn't work well, here, owing to the "never down" aspect of >>>>> our living style.ÿ Our water heater is gas-fired; we are equally
gluttonous
with our use of hot water (nothing finer than a nice LONG, hot shower!) >>>>
just a few hours, like when electricity is cheaper.
Yes, most water heaters, here, are tanks with a gas or electric heating
element.ÿ "Tankless" units are less common.
The size (volume) of the tank determines how long that hot shower will
be...
I also have a gas fired (butane) flash water heater, and I can enable
any of the two; unfortunately, this heater heats the hot water too
much resulting in
Ah! I had not considered that! The tank has a thermostat. I
never considered how they would (could?) set the temperature of
water in a tankless unit, esp a gas-fired unit.
My gas flash heater is a simple one. It uses a fixed gas rate, so the
more you open the tap, the colder the water runs. The gas flow can be
adjusted manually, same as in a gas ring, with a knob.
It has a security thermostat that switchs off the gas
if the output water goes over some very high temperature.
I don't know what T.
In summer, it runs too hot, even with a a full tap. I need to mix with
cold water, also at full tap. Not enough cold water, though.
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gas dynamically,
so that the water keeps a constant temperature, independent of entry
temp and water flow rate. So it needs electrical power to run the
adjustments. Summer, winter, one tap, two, half tap, full tap... no
matter, the temperature is constant.
involved.
The type of flash heater with proportional adjustment may have a small tank,
less than 10 litres. Hot water is instant, on demand. Normal flash heaters >>> have a delay, from a pair of seconds up to half a minute.
I would have assumed that getting fast response from direct control of the >> heating element would be more difficult than altering the blend of heated
and unheated water.
From experience (I sometimes go to another flat that has this system, in a colder city), once I adjust the temperature at the tap, I don't have to touch
it during the shower, even if other person opens a tap at the house.
ÿÿ Heck, after I saw a rocket stage landing back somewhere
ÿÿ instead of crashing into the ocean, I stopped being surprised
ÿÿ at what we can do.
So the output temperature of the water is 45øC. You just further adjust at the
tap blending some cold water.
This particular heater main usage is to provide hot water to room radiators distributed around the flat to heat it up in winter, so it already has the gas
regulation system. When you open a tap, it changes function instantly to heat
the hot water tap. It is probably the most common house heating system employed
in Spain.
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gas dynamically, soIt seems it would be easier to adjust temperature by controlling a mixing >>>> valve.ÿ Especially in cases where sudden drops in water pressure can
that the water keeps a constant temperature, independent of entry temp and
water flow rate. So it needs electrical power to run the adjustments. >>>>> Summer, winter, one tap, two, half tap, full tap... no matter, the
temperature is constant.
affect the output.
Controlling the gas flow saves water and gas.
The *tap* determines the amount of water used, regardless of what the water >> heater is doing.
Yes and no...
At my house, with a constant gas flow, if I open the tap more, I get colder
water. Less water, it is hotter. So the hot water tap must not be moved. From
experience, it is best to put it at max flow, and adjust only with the cold
water. In summer, there is not enough water to cool it down. Even if I contract
more water from the municipal water service, the shower head has a limit.
If I try opening the hot water at half, to use less water, the hot water temperature doubles, so I have to double the cold water flow to compensate. The
result is that I end using the same total water flow, I can not regulate it.
Then, if the washing machine starts drawing water, or somebody opens a tap, the
temperature at my shower changes dramatically. First I freeze, then I burn, when that tap is closed.
Thus, if I can regulate the actual hot water temperature out at the heater, I
can open the hot water tap on any position and the temperature will be the
same. Then I adjust with the cold water tap, or both, and I can have a shower
with a lot of water or with little (as long as the heater has sufficient water
flow to be detected).
But they do exist, of course, just that they are implemented in the tap: a >>> knob sets the desired temperature, and another the total water flow you want.Many "valve sets", here, are implemented as mix+volume.
<https://www.amazon.es/-/en/Thermostatic-Thermostat-Chrome-plated-
Temperature- Comfortable/dp/B0FH6XG7LF>
But, you still have the transport delay from heating unit to tap.
Certainly.
In some sites (esp commercial), a small water heater is located *at*
the site of consumption so there is less transport delay.
But, you need a source of energy *at* that location (so electricity
is most often used)
Yep. With a fair amount of electricity available. As in Spain (and France and
Italy) they charge for how much simultaneous current we use, we tend to minimize that usage, and flash electric heater do not have much of a market.
What I have seen in some hotels is have a hot water tank per room. Less instant
current. Big houses could do the same thing.
On 11/19/2026 1:12 PM, Carlos E.R. wrote:
The type of flash heater with proportional adjustment may have a
small tank, less than 10 litres. Hot water is instant, on demand.
Normal flash heaters have a delay, from a pair of seconds up to half
a minute.
I would have assumed that getting fast response from direct control
of the
heating element would be more difficult than altering the blend of
heated
and unheated water.
ÿFrom experience (I sometimes go to another flat that has this system,
in a colder city), once I adjust the temperature at the tap, I don't
have to touch it during the shower, even if other person opens a tap
at the house.
Likely over-provisioned.
ÿÿÿ Heck, after I saw a rocket stage landing back somewhere
ÿÿÿ instead of crashing into the ocean, I stopped being surprised
ÿÿÿ at what we can do.
So the output temperature of the water is 45øC. You just further
adjust at the tap blending some cold water.
This particular heater main usage is to provide hot water to room
radiators distributed around the flat to heat it up in winter, so it
already has the gas regulation system. When you open a tap, it changes
function instantly to heat the hot water tap. It is probably the most
common house heating system employed in Spain.
Growing up, we had an oil-fired furnace.ÿ The water jacket provided the circulating water for the baseboard heaters.
Sadly, a heat exchanger that poked *into* the water jacket acted as
our domestic hot water source.ÿ As a result, we had very little
hot water.
In every place I've lived in the intervening time, I have goosed
the thermostat on the water heater to ensure I had "infinite"
hot water (gradually decreasing the amount of unheated water
mixed in to prolong the intensity of the shower)
There are more expensive units that adjust the flow of gasIt seems it would be easier to adjust temperature by controlling a
dynamically, so that the water keeps a constant temperature,
independent of entry temp and water flow rate. So it needs
electrical power to run the adjustments. Summer, winter, one tap, >>>>>> two, half tap, full tap... no matter, the temperature is constant.
mixing
valve.ÿ Especially in cases where sudden drops in water pressure can >>>>> affect the output.
Controlling the gas flow saves water and gas.
The *tap* determines the amount of water used, regardless of what the
water
heater is doing.
Yes and no...
At my house, with a constant gas flow, if I open the tap more, I get
colder
Yes, but the AMOUNT of water consumed is governed by the tap.ÿ Control of
the gas flow doesn't impact the amount of water consumed (except to the extent that the water dispensed isn't as desirable as you'd like)
water. Less water, it is hotter. So the hot water tap must not be
moved. From experience, it is best to put it at max flow, and adjust
only with the cold
That is what a mixing valve would do -- control the proportions of heated
and unheated water being passed through.
water. In summer, there is not enough water to cool it down. Even if I
contract
As our fixtures route heated and unheated water to each site, it is
possible
to have an entirely cold shower (where the value of "cold" is largely determined by the season as water flowing through buried pipes tends to be considerably warmer at end of Summer than at end of Winter)
water. Less water, it is hotter. So the hot water tap must not be moved. >>> From experience, it is best to put it at max flow, and adjust only with the
cold
That is what a mixing valve would do -- control the proportions of heated
and unheated water being passed through.
Think it over.
If the water is too hot, with a mixing valve I decrease the hot water a bit, and increase the cold water a bit. But what happens at the flash heater, is that as there is less water flowing and the gas is constant, thus the hot water
increases temperature proportionally. The result at the shower is that the temperature does not change. If first obeys you, and after half a minute it goes hot again.
Trust me, I know. I have this system.That is the limiting case for a mixing valve control system. As closing off the *unheated* water is for my scenario, above.
I would buy a temperature continuously controlled flash heater, but I'm going
to move to another house soon, so not my problem anymore. They are double or triple the cost for a reason...
water. In summer, there is not enough water to cool it down. Even if I contract
As our fixtures route heated and unheated water to each site, it is possible >> to have an entirely cold shower (where the value of "cold" is largely
determined by the season as water flowing through buried pipes tends to be >> considerably warmer at end of Summer than at end of Winter)
Yes, of course. I can close the hot water totally and use only cold water, no
problem.
water. Less water, it is hotter. So the hot water tap must not be
moved. From experience, it is best to put it at max flow, and adjust
only with the cold
That is what a mixing valve would do -- control the proportions of
heated
and unheated water being passed through.
Think it over.
If the water is too hot, with a mixing valve I decrease the hot water
a bit, and increase the cold water a bit. But what happens at the
flash heater, is that as there is less water flowing and the gas is
constant, thus the hot water increases temperature proportionally. The
result at the shower is that the temperature does not change. If first
obeys you, and after half a minute it goes hot again.
But, a controller driving the valve would see this and react accordingly. Eventually, there is very little (or NONE!) SUPER HOT water flowing through the valve but a lot of COLD water working against it.
Shoot the engineer?ÿ Or, the clown who specified the system??|| |
| Sysop: | Jacob Catayoc |
|---|---|
| Location: | Pasay City, Metro Manila, Philippines |
| Users: | 5 |
| Nodes: | 4 (0 / 4) |
| Uptime: | 498678:38:58 |
| Calls: | 212 |
| Calls today: | 3 |
| Files: | 912 |
| D/L today: |
31 files (22,593K bytes) |
| Messages: | 69,880 |