• GTA VI: The Cuckening

    From BTR1701@3:633/10 to All on Friday, November 20, 2026 03:15:15
    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you
    just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment industry.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From shawn@3:633/10 to All on Thursday, November 19, 2026 22:21:08
    On Fri, 20 Nov 2026 03:15:15 +0000, BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid>
    wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you
    just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down >in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as >you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are >stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >industry.

    Hmm, I watched a bit of a stream today and saw a good looking game
    with similar game play as in the past. Didn't see enough to say if
    what you are reporting was in the stream I saw. I'm surprised they
    went that far but I guess they decided to play it safe.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Adam H. Kerman@3:633/10 to All on Friday, November 20, 2026 03:25:23
    BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid> wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together,

    Are the instructions in Japanese?

    re-roofing her
    house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you
    just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down >in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as >you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are >stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >industry.

    I had no idea this game was ever supposed to be PC.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Ubiquitous@3:633/10 to All on Friday, November 20, 2026 18:12:04
    nanoflower@gmail.com wrote:
    BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid> wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after >>a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will >>no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >>quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >>significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >>random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down >>in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >>suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as >>you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >>death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in >>a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are >>stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>industry.

    Hmm, I watched a bit of a stream today and saw a good looking game
    with similar game play as in the past. Didn't see enough to say if
    what you are reporting was in the stream I saw. I'm surprised they
    went that far but I guess they decided to play it safe.

    Try harder. I saw several on YouTube with the main char painting a room, putting
    shingles on their house, unplugging the toilet, and helping his bitch girlfriend
    assemble an endtable (yes, he was actually screwing and unscrewing the screws!).

    --
    Democrats and the liberal media hate President Trump more than they
    love this country.


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From BTR1701@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 03:58:19
    Ubiquitous <weberm@polaris.net> wrote:
    nanoflower@gmail.com wrote:
    BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid> wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after >>> a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will >>> no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >>> quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend
    significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>> house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >>> random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay
    nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down >>> in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >>> suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as >>> you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >>> death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in >>> a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are >>> stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment
    industry.

    Hmm, I watched a bit of a stream today and saw a good looking game
    with similar game play as in the past. Didn't see enough to say if
    what you are reporting was in the stream I saw. I'm surprised they
    went that far but I guess they decided to play it safe.

    Try harder. I saw several on YouTube with the main char painting a room, putting
    shingles on their house, unplugging the toilet, and helping his bitch girlfriend
    assemble an endtable (yes, he was actually screwing and unscrewing the screws!).

    One representative tweet I saw from the woke brigade today:

    "So weird that players are mad that in GTA 6 you can't commit hate crimes
    or terrorism and you have to treat your girlfriend with respect and make
    her happy." --@AshleyDCan

    This is what you sound like Ashley: "People are mad that they went to a
    Chinese restaurant and found out they can't have Chinese food there."

    As for all the side quests where you have to make the girlfriend character happy, it's been noted that at no point in the game does *she* do anything
    to make *him* happy. She doesn't even have sex with him.

    Apparently before a game is released, it's tradition for the entire
    production team to take a big group picture to commemorate it. Someone
    posted the 2013 picture (GTA V) side-by-side with the 2026 picture and the reason a blood-drenched high-octane crime game franchise has turned into a girlfriend simp simulator is obvious.

    In 2013, the entire team was male, save one. In 2026, it's 100% female. At least I assume so. You never know who has a dick and who doesn't these
    days. So they were all at least female presenting. And a not insignificant number of them had purple, pink, green, or blue hair and I have no doubt
    that if the pic had higher resolution, you'd see dozens of booger swings in their noses, too. And of course, the group was replete with Pride and
    rainbow apparel as well.

    This is why the game basically punishes its male players and forces them to play the role of a cuck. Unlike every previous iteration of the game, this
    one is written by a bunch of man-hating lesbians.(E.g., while the male character can no longer bang a stripper, he *can* hire a male dancer to
    swing his junk for the girlfriend and sit by and watch the dancer feel her
    up. The game literally puts you in the cuck chair.)

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From moviePig@3:633/10 to All on Friday, November 20, 2026 23:29:49
    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:
    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you
    just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether
    we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.



    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From BTR1701@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 05:30:28
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after >> a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will >> no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >> quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend
    significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her
    house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you
    just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >> random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay
    nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down >> in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >> suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as >> you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >> death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in >> a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are >> stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment
    industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether
    we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision?

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From shawn@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 06:56:40
    On Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:30:28 +0000, BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid>
    wrote:

    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after >>> a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will >>> no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >>> quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend
    significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>> house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >>> random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay
    nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down >>> in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >>> suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as >>> you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >>> death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in >>> a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are >>> stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment
    industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether
    we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision?

    In a game like this people would normally expect no restrictions. As
    I've said I haven't seen any of these limitations in my limited
    viewing. The most I saw was the main character getting some flowers.
    The game seemed to mostly be a series of fetch quests. If there are
    all the restrictions that you speak of it's too bad Volition is no
    more as a new Saints Row game would likely do well in comparison.
    Never sell as well as the mega game that GTA is but it would still do
    well.

    LOL, did see one guy try to hijack another guys car. It was driven by
    a White guy that fought back. He just would not let the protagonist
    take his car as he kept trying to put a beat down on the 'hero'. It
    ended up that he had to shoot the guy multiple times and kill him
    before he could take the car. So at least the violence levels are
    still in the game.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From moviePig@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 11:33:33
    On 11/21/2026 12:30 AM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after >>> a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will >>> no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >>> quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend
    significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>> house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie.

    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >>> random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay
    nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down >>> in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >>> suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as >>> you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >>> death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly
    won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in >>> a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are >>> stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment
    industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether
    we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision?

    E.g., I think we might not like a portrayal of happy underage hookers.



    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Rhino@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 11:53:37
    On 2026-11-21 6:56 a.m., shawn wrote:
    On Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:30:28 +0000, BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid>
    wrote:

    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will >>>> no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >>>> quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend
    significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>>> house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie. >>>>
    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >>>> random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>>> nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >>>> suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >>>> death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>>> won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in >>>> a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are
    stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>>> industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether
    we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision?

    In a game like this people would normally expect no restrictions. As
    I've said I haven't seen any of these limitations in my limited
    viewing. The most I saw was the main character getting some flowers.
    The game seemed to mostly be a series of fetch quests. If there are
    all the restrictions that you speak of it's too bad Volition is no
    more as a new Saints Row game would likely do well in comparison.
    Never sell as well as the mega game that GTA is but it would still do
    well.

    LOL, did see one guy try to hijack another guys car. It was driven by
    a White guy that fought back. He just would not let the protagonist
    take his car as he kept trying to put a beat down on the 'hero'. It
    ended up that he had to shoot the guy multiple times and kill him
    before he could take the car. So at least the violence levels are
    still in the game.

    That's not remotely surprising. The whole notion of wokery is a Leftist construct and the hard Left is not an enemy of violence: in fact it *cherishes* violence. Much of their rhetoric is about how glorious it is
    to destroy: old customs, old ideas, old institutions and, of course, the
    people who oppose destruction and champion anything old. I'm just
    rereading a biography of Chairman Mao and his "Cultural Revolution" was
    all about destroying Chinese culture and purging his party of everyone
    who'd been insufficiently enthusiastic about his ideas, including the
    ideas that brought about mass famines that saw tens of MILLIONS of his
    fellow Chinese starve, all while he and a handful of his closest
    supporters lived in tremendous luxury and never missed a meal. His
    regime destroyed the vast majority of China's cultural heritage,
    including many thousands of statues and monuments, some dating back many hundreds of years, and the vast majority of the artists, writers, and
    actors who were producing new art. Then, with that done, an immense
    purge took place as virtually every official with any experience or
    competence was replaced by someone from the Army. The displaced
    officials, as were the artists before them, were horribly tortured and sometimes executed while photographs and films were made of the torture
    and executions for Mao's personal enjoyment. He sometimes imitated the
    torture in meetings, laughing at his enemies torment.

    I'm sure I sound like I'm going way overboard in comparing a video game
    to Mao but fundamental values are just that: fundamental. They inform *everything*, not just the political party you support. There is very
    little evidence that most Germans expected Hitler to go nearly as far as
    he did but he got enough votes to be elected Chancellor democratically. Communist leaders like Mao and Lenin didn't win elections, they seized
    power by force when they had enough loyal followers to do so, although
    it was either followed by a bloody civil war in Lenin's case or DURING a bloody civil war (and a war with Japan) in Mao's case. I doubt that most
    of their followers were much satisfied with the Soviet Union or Maoist
    China once those regimes came to power. When the DSA says it wants to do
    away with police and prisons, don't mistake that for something they hope
    to evolve to in a few centuries. The Bernie Bros were actually
    advocating for "re-education" for the people that didn't go along with
    their ideas and were even trying to make these re-education camps sound comfortable. Anyone knowing anything about Stalin's GULAG or the
    equivalents in other Communist regimes knows that they were never
    comfortable: in fact, they were the exact opposite.

    There is something truly radical and rotten in the generation that is
    coming of age now and you ignore it or soft-pedal it at your own peril.
    I'm sure there are plenty of wonderful young people but there's a real undercurrent of nastiness afflicting many of them. I wouldn't be
    remotely surprised if the current developers of GTA are down with a lot
    of the DSA rhetoric.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Adam H. Kerman@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 18:12:25
    Subject: Chinese Cultural Revolution, Russia civil war (was: GTA VI: The Cuckening)

    Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:

    That's not remotely surprising. The whole notion of wokery is a Leftist >construct and the hard Left is not an enemy of violence: in fact it >*cherishes* violence. Much of their rhetoric is about how glorious it is
    to destroy: old customs, old ideas, old institutions and, of course, the
    people who oppose destruction and champion anything old. I'm just
    rereading a biography of Chairman Mao and his "Cultural Revolution" was
    all about destroying Chinese culture and purging his party of everyone
    who'd been insufficiently enthusiastic about his ideas, including the
    ideas that brought about mass famines that saw tens of MILLIONS of his >fellow Chinese starve, all while he and a handful of his closest
    supporters lived in tremendous luxury and never missed a meal. His
    regime destroyed the vast majority of China's cultural heritage,
    including many thousands of statues and monuments, some dating back many >hundreds of years, and the vast majority of the artists, writers, and
    actors who were producing new art. Then, with that done, an immense
    purge took place as virtually every official with any experience or >competence was replaced by someone from the Army. The displaced
    officials, as were the artists before them, were horribly tortured and >sometimes executed while photographs and films were made of the torture
    and executions for Mao's personal enjoyment. He sometimes imitated the >torture in meetings, laughing at his enemies torment.

    Mao might have made a video game of his purges.

    I'm sure I sound like I'm going way overboard in comparing a video game
    to Mao but fundamental values are just that: fundamental. They inform >*everything*, not just the political party you support. There is very
    little evidence that most Germans expected Hitler to go nearly as far as
    he did but he got enough votes to be elected Chancellor democratically. >Communist leaders like Mao and Lenin didn't win elections, they seized
    power by force when they had enough loyal followers to do so, although
    it was either followed by a bloody civil war in Lenin's case

    One of the Sarah Paine videos commented that the top Communist leaders
    were out of the country when the civil war started. It's more like they
    seized power by taking advantage of the chaos. I haven't read a lot
    about it, but it seemed to me that multiple factions fought each other.

    or DURING a
    bloody civil war (and a war with Japan) in Mao's case. I doubt that most
    of their followers were much satisfied with the Soviet Union or Maoist
    China once those regimes came to power. When the DSA says it wants to do >away with police and prisons, don't mistake that for something they hope
    to evolve to in a few centuries. The Bernie Bros were actually
    advocating for "re-education" for the people that didn't go along with
    their ideas and were even trying to make these re-education camps sound >comfortable. Anyone knowing anything about Stalin's GULAG or the
    equivalents in other Communist regimes knows that they were never >comfortable: in fact, they were the exact opposite.

    There is something truly radical and rotten in the generation that is
    coming of age now and you ignore it or soft-pedal it at your own peril.

    Aren't they just poorly educated? It's hard to say past generations were
    free of STOOPID. Look at the anti-vaxers. That's their parents. The
    "believe women" (without taking a hard look without bias at evidence)
    was also their parents. P.C. was the 1990s, also their parents.

    I'm sure there are plenty of wonderful young people but there's a real >undercurrent of nastiness afflicting many of them. I wouldn't be
    remotely surprised if the current developers of GTA are down with a lot
    of the DSA rhetoric.

    You are giving them way too much power. It's merely a symptom.

    The big disaster is how social media was used. Politics took advantage
    of it but monetizing free speech was the underlying motive. Facebook
    brought down third world societies that had no access to unbiased news.

    You know what else was the previous generation? That today's young
    people weren't allowed to just be children, walking to school or playing
    by themselves.

    I'm going to ask you to have some sympathy.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From BTR1701@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 19:53:09
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 12:30 AM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will >>>> no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side >>>> quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend
    significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>>> house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie. >>>>
    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down >>>> random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>>> nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs >>>> suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to >>>> death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>>> won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in >>>> a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are
    stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>>> industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether
    we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision?

    E.g., I think we might not like a portrayal of happy underage hookers.

    The chasm between "might not like" and "restrictions" is vast.

    "Might not like" means you decide the game isn't for you and you buy
    something else.

    "Restrictions" means the government is prohibiting you as a matter of law
    from even creating such a game in the first place.

    (And, FYI, I don't believe any iteration of GTA has portrayed the hookers
    as either underage or happy.)

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Rhino@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 14:57:07
    On 2026-11-21 1:12 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
    Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:

    That's not remotely surprising. The whole notion of wokery is a Leftist
    construct and the hard Left is not an enemy of violence: in fact it
    *cherishes* violence. Much of their rhetoric is about how glorious it is
    to destroy: old customs, old ideas, old institutions and, of course, the
    people who oppose destruction and champion anything old. I'm just
    rereading a biography of Chairman Mao and his "Cultural Revolution" was
    all about destroying Chinese culture and purging his party of everyone
    who'd been insufficiently enthusiastic about his ideas, including the
    ideas that brought about mass famines that saw tens of MILLIONS of his
    fellow Chinese starve, all while he and a handful of his closest
    supporters lived in tremendous luxury and never missed a meal. His
    regime destroyed the vast majority of China's cultural heritage,
    including many thousands of statues and monuments, some dating back many
    hundreds of years, and the vast majority of the artists, writers, and
    actors who were producing new art. Then, with that done, an immense
    purge took place as virtually every official with any experience or
    competence was replaced by someone from the Army. The displaced
    officials, as were the artists before them, were horribly tortured and
    sometimes executed while photographs and films were made of the torture
    and executions for Mao's personal enjoyment. He sometimes imitated the
    torture in meetings, laughing at his enemies torment.

    Mao might have made a video game of his purges.

    It would have been for his own private use for the most part, though he
    would probably love playing it for his closest sycophants.

    I'm sure I sound like I'm going way overboard in comparing a video game
    to Mao but fundamental values are just that: fundamental. They inform
    *everything*, not just the political party you support. There is very
    little evidence that most Germans expected Hitler to go nearly as far as
    he did but he got enough votes to be elected Chancellor democratically.
    Communist leaders like Mao and Lenin didn't win elections, they seized
    power by force when they had enough loyal followers to do so, although
    it was either followed by a bloody civil war in Lenin's case

    One of the Sarah Paine videos commented that the top Communist leaders
    were out of the country when the civil war started. It's more like they seized power by taking advantage of the chaos. I haven't read a lot
    about it, but it seemed to me that multiple factions fought each other.
    Mao himself never set foot out of China until very close to the end of
    the Civil War, i.e. just before he seized power in 1949, and the only
    place he went was the Soviet Union. Most of the rest of the CCP
    leadership only had contact with the Soviet Union if they'd been abroad
    at all until they were finally in power and able to attend foreign conferences.

    There was definitely factionalism in the years of the Civil War and Mao overcame one obstacle after the other by scheming and backstabbing the
    people opposed to him - and there were a LOT of them.
    or DURING a
    bloody civil war (and a war with Japan) in Mao's case. I doubt that most
    of their followers were much satisfied with the Soviet Union or Maoist
    China once those regimes came to power. When the DSA says it wants to do
    away with police and prisons, don't mistake that for something they hope
    to evolve to in a few centuries. The Bernie Bros were actually
    advocating for "re-education" for the people that didn't go along with
    their ideas and were even trying to make these re-education camps sound
    comfortable. Anyone knowing anything about Stalin's GULAG or the
    equivalents in other Communist regimes knows that they were never
    comfortable: in fact, they were the exact opposite.

    There is something truly radical and rotten in the generation that is
    coming of age now and you ignore it or soft-pedal it at your own peril.

    Aren't they just poorly educated? It's hard to say past generations were
    free of STOOPID. Look at the anti-vaxers. That's their parents. The
    "believe women" (without taking a hard look without bias at evidence)
    was also their parents. P.C. was the 1990s, also their parents.

    I blame the teachers colleges: the rot started there. An entire
    generation (or two) of teachers were indoctrinated there first, then
    they indoctrinated their students.

    I'm sure there are plenty of wonderful young people but there's a real
    undercurrent of nastiness afflicting many of them. I wouldn't be
    remotely surprised if the current developers of GTA are down with a lot
    of the DSA rhetoric.

    You are giving them way too much power. It's merely a symptom.

    I don't mean that the GTA developers are leaders in the far left, just
    that they are loyal to it and its values. Somebody HIRED those people
    though and I am curious how the profile of the developers changed that radically. I'm familiar with the IT world and it is still overwhelmingly
    male. I go to two meetups of IT people every month and while there are a
    few women, men FAR outnumber women at these things and I haven't seen a
    tranny yet, at least one that obviously was a tranny. Where did the
    company FIND so many females? Why did the males that were there for
    previous releases all get let go?

    The big disaster is how social media was used. Politics took advantage
    of it but monetizing free speech was the underlying motive. Facebook
    brought down third world societies that had no access to unbiased news.

    You know what else was the previous generation? That today's young
    people weren't allowed to just be children, walking to school or playing
    by themselves.

    That was certainly a disgrace. Bubble-wrapping kids did them a huge disservice.

    I'm going to ask you to have some sympathy.

    Don't get me wrong: I'm NOT blaming the emerging generation for its foolishness. We have a saying in the IT world: Garbage In, Garbage Out.
    Bad information leads to a bad result and the emerging generation was
    fed a LOT of garbage. But now all of society is starting to pay the
    price for that.

    I will NOT be surprised if things get really REALLY bad in the next few
    years as "activists" persuade the younger generation(s) to do really
    vile stuff that rivals Mao's Cultural Revolution and purge.


    --
    Rhino

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Rhino@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 15:00:32
    On 2026-11-21 2:53 p.m., BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 12:30 AM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side
    quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >>>>> significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>>>> house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>>>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie. >>>>>
    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down
    random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>>>> nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs
    suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to
    death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>>>> won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are
    stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>>>> industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether >>>> we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision? >>
    E.g., I think we might not like a portrayal of happy underage hookers.

    The chasm between "might not like" and "restrictions" is vast.

    "Might not like" means you decide the game isn't for you and you buy something else.

    "Restrictions" means the government is prohibiting you as a matter of law from even creating such a game in the first place.

    (And, FYI, I don't believe any iteration of GTA has portrayed the hookers
    as either underage or happy.)

    The chasm been "might not like" and "restrictions" is moviePig's happy
    place. He will happily sell "restrictions" as if they were "might not
    likes", just a little firmer to "prevent abuse".

    --
    Rhino

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Adam H. Kerman@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 21:08:29
    Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
    On 2026-11-21 1:12 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:

    I'm sure I sound like I'm going way overboard in comparing a video game >>>to Mao but fundamental values are just that: fundamental. They inform >>>*everything*, not just the political party you support. There is very >>>little evidence that most Germans expected Hitler to go nearly as far as >>>he did but he got enough votes to be elected Chancellor democratically. >>>Communist leaders like Mao and Lenin didn't win elections, they seized >>>power by force when they had enough loyal followers to do so, although
    it was either followed by a bloody civil war in Lenin's case

    One of the Sarah Paine videos commented that the top Communist leaders
    were out of the country when the civil war started. It's more like they >>seized power by taking advantage of the chaos. I haven't read a lot
    about it, but it seemed to me that multiple factions fought each other.

    Mao himself never set foot out of China until very close to the end of
    the Civil War, i.e. just before he seized power in 1949, and the only
    place he went was the Soviet Union. Most of the rest of the CCP
    leadership only had contact with the Soviet Union if they'd been abroad
    at all until they were finally in power and able to attend foreign >conferences.

    You said "and Lenin". Russia, not China. Paine commented that Lenin and
    Trotsky were out of the country when the civil war began. I've heard
    that before that their supporters didn't instigate the civil war.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From moviePig@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 16:36:20
    On 11/21/2026 2:53 PM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 12:30 AM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side
    quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >>>>> significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her >>>>> house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>>>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie. >>>>>
    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down
    random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>>>> nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs
    suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to
    death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>>>> won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are
    stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>>>> industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether >>>> we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision? >>
    E.g., I think we might not like a portrayal of happy underage hookers.

    The chasm between "might not like" and "restrictions" is vast.

    "Might not like" means you decide the game isn't for you and you buy something else.

    "Restrictions" means the government is prohibiting you as a matter of law from even creating such a game in the first place.

    (And, FYI, I don't believe any iteration of GTA has portrayed the hookers
    as either underage or happy.)

    My distant impression of the game is that the protagonists are scofflaw
    heroes ...which a sociologist might declare a piss-poor role-model to
    visit upon our impressionable under-30s. The question I'm trying to ask
    is whether, *in principle*, the 1st Amendment protects even extreme --
    i.e., clearly harmful -- examples. (Use your imagination.)



    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From BTR1701@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 22:02:49
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 2:53 PM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 12:30 AM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side
    quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >>>>>> significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her
    house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you >>>>>> just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie. >>>>>>
    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down
    random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>>>>> nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs
    suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to
    death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>>>>> won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are
    stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>>>>> industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether >>>>> we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision? >>>
    E.g., I think we might not like a portrayal of happy underage hookers.

    The chasm between "might not like" and "restrictions" is vast.

    "Might not like" means you decide the game isn't for you and you buy
    something else.

    "Restrictions" means the government is prohibiting you as a matter of law
    from even creating such a game in the first place.

    (And, FYI, I don't believe any iteration of GTA has portrayed the hookers
    as either underage or happy.)

    My distant impression of the game is that the protagonists are scofflaw heroes ...which a sociologist might declare a piss-poor role-model to
    visit upon our impressionable under-30s. The question I'm trying to ask
    is whether, *in principle*, the 1st Amendment protects even extreme --
    i.e., clearly harmful -- examples. (Use your imagination.)

    Yes, it does.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From moviePig@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 17:10:36
    On 11/21/2026 5:02 PM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 2:53 PM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 12:30 AM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side
    quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >>>>>>> significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her
    house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you
    just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie. >>>>>>>
    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down
    random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>>>>>> nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs
    suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to
    death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>>>>>> won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are
    stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>>>>>> industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether >>>>>> we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision? >>>>
    E.g., I think we might not like a portrayal of happy underage hookers.

    The chasm between "might not like" and "restrictions" is vast.

    "Might not like" means you decide the game isn't for you and you buy
    something else.

    "Restrictions" means the government is prohibiting you as a matter of law >>> from even creating such a game in the first place.

    (And, FYI, I don't believe any iteration of GTA has portrayed the hookers >>> as either underage or happy.)

    My distant impression of the game is that the protagonists are scofflaw
    heroes ...which a sociologist might declare a piss-poor role-model to
    visit upon our impressionable under-30s. The question I'm trying to ask
    is whether, *in principle*, the 1st Amendment protects even extreme --
    i.e., clearly harmful -- examples. (Use your imagination.)

    Yes, it does.

    As a matter of law? How is it, then, that we have obscenity laws?



    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Rhino@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 17:43:39
    On 2026-11-21 5:02 p.m., BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 2:53 PM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 11/21/2026 12:30 AM, BTR1701 wrote:
    moviePig <nobody@nowhere.com> wrote:

    On 11/19/2026 10:15 PM, BTR1701 wrote:

    So if you haven't heard, a new Grand Theft Auto game was released and after
    a 13-year wait, gamers who have played it are reporting that the game will
    no longer let you pick up a hooker, but there are several unskippable side
    quests where you have to simp for your girlfriend-- you have to spend >>>>>>> significant game time putting her IKEA furniture together, re-roofing her
    house, painting her bedroom walls, and one 10-minute 'mission' where you
    just sit on the couch with her and rub her feet while watching a movie. >>>>>>>
    Other things you can no longer do-- while you can still shoot and run down
    random civilians, your gun suddenly stops working when you enter a gay >>>>>>> nightclub and your car will swerve and crash if you try and run anyone down
    in the Pride Parade scene.

    In another scene involving a left-wing march in the city streets, the NPCs
    suddenly become invincible. You can shoot the purple-hairs as many times as
    you want and they won't die. You can, however, beat a guy in a MAGA hat to
    death with no problem.

    And most absurd of all: in a game called Grand Theft Auto, they mostly >>>>>>> won't let you steal cars anymore. You can only steal them if you aren't in
    a "marginalized neighborhood". In other words, only white people's cars are
    stealable.

    So it sounds like exactly what you'd expect from today's entertainment >>>>>>> industry.

    I don't play these (or any) games, but the question seems to be whether >>>>>> we want restrictions against glorifying anti-social behavior.

    What restrictions, consistent with the 1st Amendment, would you envision? >>>>
    E.g., I think we might not like a portrayal of happy underage hookers.

    The chasm between "might not like" and "restrictions" is vast.

    "Might not like" means you decide the game isn't for you and you buy
    something else.

    "Restrictions" means the government is prohibiting you as a matter of law >>> from even creating such a game in the first place.

    (And, FYI, I don't believe any iteration of GTA has portrayed the hookers >>> as either underage or happy.)

    My distant impression of the game is that the protagonists are scofflaw
    heroes ...which a sociologist might declare a piss-poor role-model to
    visit upon our impressionable under-30s. The question I'm trying to ask
    is whether, *in principle*, the 1st Amendment protects even extreme --
    i.e., clearly harmful -- examples. (Use your imagination.)

    Yes, it does.

    By contrast, the Soviet Union and the People's Republic of China, held
    up Lenin, Stalin and Mao as being so amazing that they were next to
    gods. This was passed off as being inspirational to everyone. Woe betide anyone who called any of this into even the slightest doubt; that was a
    one way ticket to severe condemnations, torture, and even execution. I
    *like* - no CHERISH would be a better word - where I can criticize
    others, just as they can criticize me. I am not counting on that state
    of affairs continuing much longer....

    --
    Rhino

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Rhino@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 18:29:55
    On 2026-11-21 4:08 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
    Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
    On 2026-11-21 1:12 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:

    I'm sure I sound like I'm going way overboard in comparing a video game >>>> to Mao but fundamental values are just that: fundamental. They inform
    *everything*, not just the political party you support. There is very
    little evidence that most Germans expected Hitler to go nearly as far as >>>> he did but he got enough votes to be elected Chancellor democratically. >>>> Communist leaders like Mao and Lenin didn't win elections, they seized >>>> power by force when they had enough loyal followers to do so, although >>>> it was either followed by a bloody civil war in Lenin's case

    One of the Sarah Paine videos commented that the top Communist leaders
    were out of the country when the civil war started. It's more like they
    seized power by taking advantage of the chaos. I haven't read a lot
    about it, but it seemed to me that multiple factions fought each other.

    Mao himself never set foot out of China until very close to the end of
    the Civil War, i.e. just before he seized power in 1949, and the only
    place he went was the Soviet Union. Most of the rest of the CCP
    leadership only had contact with the Soviet Union if they'd been abroad
    at all until they were finally in power and able to attend foreign
    conferences.

    You said "and Lenin". Russia, not China. Paine commented that Lenin and Trotsky were out of the country when the civil war began. I've heard
    that before that their supporters didn't instigate the civil war.

    My apologies. Since you'd previously mentioned Sarah Paine in the
    context of China and Mao, I assumed you were still referring to China.

    Russia is a completely different story. Yes, several of the leading
    Bolsheviks were living in foreign exile at the time the Tsar abdicated, including Lenin. Lenin was in Zurich. Trotsky was actually living in
    NYC; he'd given up on the Revolution ever happening. (FYI, Trotsky
    wasn't a Bolshevik at the time, he was a Menshevik, which was the more moderate faction of the party that contained the Bolsheviks and
    Mensheviks. But Lenin persuaded him to join the Bolsheviks over the
    summer of 1917 once both were back in Russia.)

    In fact, Lenin and his closest followers in the Russian exile community,
    were brought back to Russia by none other than the Germans, who felt
    that introducing the top Bolsheviks back into Russia during WWI would
    only help their own cause by sowing confusion and discontent among the
    already dispirited Russian troops who'd had few victories in WWI.

    --
    Rhino

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)