I had no idea the Supreme Court was hearing this case. It's absolutely egregious. This is excessive fines, not takings.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Qs_0Vr2qbQ
On 2026-11-18 5:42 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
I had no idea the Supreme Court was hearing this case. It's absolutely >>egregious. This is excessive fines, not takings.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Qs_0Vr2qbQ
I wish him a resounding victory in court. Taking his plane just seems >grievously wrong. The fine and 3 days in jail seems more than adequate.
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-18 5:42 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
I had no idea the Supreme Court was hearing this case. It's absolutely
egregious. This is excessive fines, not takings.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Qs_0Vr2qbQ
I wish him a resounding victory in court. Taking his plane just seems
grievously wrong. The fine and 3 days in jail seems more than adequate.
The huge deal is he wasn't the one who put the contraband on board.
There was no mens rea.
This is a huge problem with crime in which probable cause and proof
beyond a reasonable doubt is due to possession. Stolen property? The
state need not prove you had anything to do with any aspect of the theft
for specific charges.
Say your luggage is inspected and contraband is discovered. They've got probable cause despite your denial that you never saw it.
On 2026-11-19 12:07 a.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-18 5:42 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
I had no idea the Supreme Court was hearing this case. It's absolutely >>>>egregious. This is excessive fines, not takings.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Qs_0Vr2qbQ
I wish him a resounding victory in court. Taking his plane just seems >>>grievously wrong. The fine and 3 days in jail seems more than adequate.
The huge deal is he wasn't the one who put the contraband on board.
There was no mens rea.
He said he disagreed with the law about bringing alcohol into that
community which seems like a pretty strong hint that even if he knew the >passenger was loading beer, he wouldn't have refused to carry it.
The
lesser courts essentially agreed that he could not have been unaware of
the beer being there based on the photographs. He may even have been
well known to the people in those communities as being the guy that
would turn a blind eye to a bit of booze importation. It seems like the >state decided to punish him by seizing the plane to discourage him from >flaunting the law.
Given that the community itself voted against allowing the importation
of booze, the Supremes will need to weigh that against the pilot's
actions in transporting the beer.
I don't know about Alaska but lots of
indigenous communities in other jurisdictions have serious problems with >booze and drugs and I've heard of them enacting such laws to reduce the >problems.
This is a huge problem with crime in which probable cause and proof
beyond a reasonable doubt is due to possession. Stolen property? The
state need not prove you had anything to do with any aspect of the theft >>for specific charges.
Say your luggage is inspected and contraband is discovered. They've got >>probable cause despite your denial that you never saw it.
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-19 12:07 a.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-18 5:42 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
I had no idea the Supreme Court was hearing this case. It's absolutely >>>>> egregious. This is excessive fines, not takings.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Qs_0Vr2qbQ
I wish him a resounding victory in court. Taking his plane just seems
grievously wrong. The fine and 3 days in jail seems more than adequate.
The huge deal is he wasn't the one who put the contraband on board.
There was no mens rea.
He said he disagreed with the law about bringing alcohol into that
community which seems like a pretty strong hint that even if he knew the
passenger was loading beer, he wouldn't have refused to carry it.
I didn't hear him say that. He didn't violate his passenger's privacy
and didn't inspect her cargo.
If I believe him that he saw no beer, then my mens rea argument stands.
The
lesser courts essentially agreed that he could not have been unaware of
the beer being there based on the photographs. He may even have been
well known to the people in those communities as being the guy that
would turn a blind eye to a bit of booze importation. It seems like the
state decided to punish him by seizing the plane to discourage him from
flaunting the law.
Sure, because there is no shortage of bush pilots. He talked about two emergency medical calls he made on one flight.
Given that the community itself voted against allowing the importation
of booze, the Supremes will need to weigh that against the pilot's
actions in transporting the beer.
No. He isn't appealing the criminal conviction. This is an excessive
fines case, just the second case to come to the Court.
I don't know about Alaska but lots of
indigenous communities in other jurisdictions have serious problems with
booze and drugs and I've heard of them enacting such laws to reduce the
problems.
America has the experience of the Volstead Act. The unintended
consequences of Prohibition were hideous.
This is a huge problem with crime in which probable cause and proof
beyond a reasonable doubt is due to possession. Stolen property? The
state need not prove you had anything to do with any aspect of the theft >>> for specific charges.
Say your luggage is inspected and contraband is discovered. They've got
probable cause despite your denial that you never saw it.
Now that I think about it, this wasn't a crime of possession but intent.
That stuff was inapplicabke.
On 2026-11-19 11:56 a.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-19 12:07 a.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-18 5:42 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Given that the community itself voted against allowing the importation
of booze, the Supremes will need to weigh that against the pilot's >>>actions in transporting the beer.
No. He isn't appealing the criminal conviction. This is an excessive
fines case, just the second case to come to the Court.
I realize that but I assume they're going to consider the entire context
of the arrest so they may factor in the intent of the law that he
violated into their deliberations.
I don't know about Alaska but lots of
indigenous communities in other jurisdictions have serious problems with >>>booze and drugs and I've heard of them enacting such laws to reduce the >>>problems.
America has the experience of the Volstead Act. The unintended
consequences of Prohibition were hideous.
There's no doubt that Prohibition was *not* a success and was bad enough
to be repealed. But it's one thing for the state to forbid the
manufacturing and sale of alcohol and something slightly different >individual communities to voluntarily ban importation of booze due to
the problems caused by it.
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-19 11:56 a.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-19 12:07 a.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Rhino <no_offline_contact@example.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-18 5:42 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Given that the community itself voted against allowing the importation >>>> of booze, the Supremes will need to weigh that against the pilot's
actions in transporting the beer.
No. He isn't appealing the criminal conviction. This is an excessive
fines case, just the second case to come to the Court.
I realize that but I assume they're going to consider the entire context
of the arrest so they may factor in the intent of the law that he
violated into their deliberations.
Most appeals aren't expansive well beyond the issue at hand like Bruen *2022). They consider the narrowest possible issue. In Lawrence (2003),
they wanted the law found unconstitutional, so Lawrence himself could
not challenge probable cause in his arrest as it's unlikely the police officer truly witnessed the act addressed by the statute, just assumed
it was violated.
In order to address rhe excessive fine, the pilot cannot challenge
whether he coommitted the crime or there was probable cause or why prohibition was in place. He has to be guilty to get a pure appeal to challenge constitutionality of the excessive fine.
There has to be a narrow strategy to make new law and have a landmark
case.
When CBS was subject to FCC censorship, the Supreme Court never ruled on whether it was constitutional that FCC had a broadcast censorship
regime, so no new law was made.
I don't know about Alaska but lots of
indigenous communities in other jurisdictions have serious problems with >>>> booze and drugs and I've heard of them enacting such laws to reduce the >>>> problems.
America has the experience of the Volstead Act. The unintended
consequences of Prohibition were hideous.
There's no doubt that Prohibition was *not* a success and was bad enough
to be repealed. But it's one thing for the state to forbid the
manufacturing and sale of alcohol and something slightly different
individual communities to voluntarily ban importation of booze due to
the problems caused by it.
Turning ordinary activity that's victimless inot criminal activity is a
very serious consequence without addressing medical aspects of addictive behavior. I don't agree with you.
I am not saying the choice by the village to prohibit importation of
booze is *completely* different to Prohibition but it does feel a little >different. Mind you, maybe it's really the same thing at a different
scale. Was the Vollstead Act the prevailing party's attempt to honour a >campaign pledge that they believed got them a great many votes? If so,
it was democratically demanded by the electorate just as the village
level ban on importation was in Alaska. And just as Prohibition was
repealed when they saw the consequences, the liquor ban in Alaska might
also be repealed by individual villages if they didn't like the results.
| Sysop: | Jacob Catayoc |
|---|---|
| Location: | Pasay City, Metro Manila, Philippines |
| Users: | 5 |
| Nodes: | 4 (0 / 4) |
| Uptime: | 498678:40:05 |
| Calls: | 212 |
| Calls today: | 3 |
| Files: | 912 |
| D/L today: |
31 files (22,593K bytes) |
| Messages: | 69,880 |