Subject: Re: For those of you who don't understand why health care without free markets is a disaster
On 2026-11-15 7:22 p.m., Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Is fully-socialized medicine better than a free market? 20,000 Canadians
who died on wait lists may not agree.
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/qiRxat_Xiv4
I'd love to see some proof for that statistic. I have to assume *some* Canadians die waiting for appointments but where is he getting that
number? StatsCan (Statistics Canada) would be the traditional source of
such information but there are doubtless many other possible sources of
such statistics like the CMA (Canadian Medical Association i.e. the
doctor's union) and advocacy groups of various political stripes.
And then there's the tens of thousands (?) of people who've taken
advantage of MAID (Medical Assistance In Dying). Where do they get
*that* number?
I just asked claude.ai and it has some interesting answers to both
questions:
===================================================================
Short answer: Canada has fairly solid official MAID numbers, but no one
tracks how many people died because of waiting for care.
MAID
One small correction: the federal law took effect in June 2016, not
2015. Quebec?s own law began in December 2015, and court orders allowed
some cases earlier in 2016.
Health Canada?s figures show 76,475 people have received MAID since it
became legal in 2016, counting through the end of 2024. In 2024 alone
there were 16,499 MAID deaths, about 5.1 per cent of all deaths in
Canada. For scale, the annual count was 1,018 in 2016. Year-over-year
growth has been shrinking, from 36.8 per cent between 2019 and 2020 to
6.9 per cent between 2023 and 2024.
Elevate your local knowledge
+3
The national report for 2025 doesn?t appear to be out yet; the 2024
report came out in late November 2025. Some provinces have published
2025 numbers, such as 3,189 MAID deaths in B.C. and 1,242 in Alberta.
Some advocacy groups already cite a total near 90,000, but that?s an
estimate rather than an official figure. By my own rough arithmetic, the official total would likely pass 90,000 once 2025 is counted.
Friday, November 28, 2025
+2
Deaths while waiting for care
There?s no official national count. The best-known figures come from SecondStreet.org, a think tank that files freedom-of-information
requests with health authorities. Their latest release found at least
23,746 patients died while waiting for surgeries or diagnostic scans
between April 2024 and March 2025, and more than 100,876 such cases
since April 2018. The prior year?s figure was 15,474. Ontario had the
most, at 10,634, with over 9,100 of those among people waiting for
diagnostic scans.
23,746 Patients Died on Waitlists in Past Year
+3
These numbers need careful reading:
They count deaths, not causes. The data mostly doesn?t show how closely
the deaths were linked to the treatment being awaited. Many involve
people waiting for things like MRIs, hip and knee surgery, or cataract operations, and a significant subset involved potentially life-saving procedures such as heart surgery and cancer treatment. In an elderly population, many would have died on a list regardless.
washingtonexaminer
ctvnews
They?re incomplete. Alberta and parts of Manitoba are missing, and most provinces have no data on deaths while waiting for specialist
appointments. So your specific question about specialist referrals is
largely unanswered by existing data.
secondstreet
The source has a viewpoint. SecondStreet.org advocates for health system reform, including a larger role for private options. Its data comes from government records, but the framing is advocacy.
If you want to dig further, the Health Canada annual MAID reports are
the authoritative source for the first question. For the second, SecondStreet.org?s ?Died on a Waiting List? briefs link to the
underlying FOI responses, so you can check the data yourself. ===================================================================
--
Rhino
--- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
* Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)