• Re:

    From Charles Curley@3:633/10 to All on Tuesday, November 03, 2026 16:00:01
    On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 23:37:05 -0800
    Donald MacDougall <dmacdoug@usc.edu> wrote:

    Nov 2, 2026 6:34:22 AM Charles Curley
    <charlescurley@charlescurley.com>:

    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 23:25:25 -0800
    Donald MacDougall <dmacdoug@usc.edu> wrote:

    I have an Acer Aspire laptop.ÿ I hadn't upgraded it in a long tim
    e.
    It was still on bullseye which recently stopped receiving security
    updates, so I decided it was time to do it.ÿ I upgraded to bookwo
    rm
    which went swimmingly.ÿ Then I upgraded to Trixie which went even
    better.ÿ I have been using xfce for many many years and it seemed
    to work splendidly till I went to shut it down and found that the
    "Reboot" option which had always been the last option on the Apps
    list was no longer there,

    What "apps list"?

    Since I can't see it, from
    memory (not too good anymore) I really meant
    what you described below but the"Log Out"
    selection was missing from the bottom of the "Applications" list,
    thus I was unable to get the popup with six selections including (from memory) Reboot and Shut Down as well as sleep and several others.

    Fair enough. A secondary problem to be solved after you solve your
    black screen problem.



    I take it that you got a normal power up and were able to log in to
    XFCE.

    As I described in my reply to Greg, I have always logged in at the
    cli login prompt and then run XFCE by typing "startx".ÿ I've done
    this for many years.

    Noted. Thank you for the clarification.


    After the upgrade to Trixie and after opening the terminal and
    typing "systemctl poweroff" I was able to use the power key to
    to restart, then login, then type startx and see my normal XFCE
    desktop.ÿ But after I the "systemctl halt" command in the terminal
    window I used the power key then logged in at the login prompt,
    typed "startx" and saw no desktop, just the black screen.


    I had also
    noticed the "halt" option in the systemctl man page and remembered
    decades ago using the halt command to power down computers and
    wondered what the difference is between that and poweroff, so I
    tried it.ÿ After that when I started it up again, logged in and
    typed 'startx',

    Wait, logged in again to what? In a normal Debian XFCE installation
    you log in to lightdm, which means you are already running X.

    As noted above, I have always logged in at the cli
    login prompt then run XFCE by typing startx.

    So why did
    you type "startx"? And into what? Did you change from lightdm (on
    console 7) to a non-graphical console (1-6)? If so why?


    instead of seeing the normal desktop, all I see is a black
    screen with a mouse cursor in the middle which I can move around at
    will but it does nothing.ÿ Apparently halt has changed meaning
    since way back when.

    Or, more likely, you did something you haven't told us about because
    you didn't think it was significant. Which is why giving what you
    think are unnecessary details is sometimes very important.

    I have omitted nothing.ÿ I have described in detail the exact order
    of everything I did.

    In your original post, you omitted the fact that you do not have
    lightdm (or any other display manager) manager running, and that you do
    the atypical "log in to a console, then run startx" routine. Which
    omission lead to some of the confusion in this thread. Since you
    described an atypical startup routine, I and others asked for
    clarification.






    I'm on Wayland obviously with lightdm

    It is not obvious to me that you are on Wayland. How do you know you
    are on Wayland? Don't tell us that you are on Wayland (obvious or
    not). Show us you are on Wayland.

    Perhaps not.ÿ I've described my reasoning in detail
    in my reply to Greg and will not repeat it.ÿ I likely was wrong.

    Noted.

    The gold standard for that sort of thing is to run a test in the
    terminal and copy and pasted the whole thing into your email, like so:

    charles@peregrine:~$ echo "$XDG_SESSION_TYPE"
    x11
    charles@peregrine:~$

    Note that I include the trailing prompt. That makes it clear that the
    one line of response is the entire response.

    I understand that you are using your phone for email, and that copying
    and pasting is problematic. I don't believe I've seen any response to a
    number of suggestions that you run the above experiment.


    --
    Does anybody read signatures any more?

    https://charlescurley.com
    https://charlescurley.com/blog/

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Charles Curley@3:633/10 to All on Wednesday, November 04, 2026 01:30:01
    On Tue, 3 Nov 2026 15:29:51 -0800
    Donald MacDougall <dmacdoug@usc.edu> wrote:

    I ran it and. Must have forgotten to post the result.ÿ Here it is:

    dmacdoug@Acer-Laptop:~$ echo $XDG_SESSION_TYPE"
    tty
    dmacdoug@Acer-Laptop:~$

    Probably obvious since X11 isn't running.


    Well, that's interesting. I was about to suggest that you SSH into the
    machine while XFCE was running and run that command. So I SSHed from a
    machine running XFCE to a machine that doesn't have X on it at all. I
    then got:

    charles@issola:~$ echo $XDG_SESSION_TYPE
    tty
    charles@issola:~$

    So I tried SSHing into a machine that XFCE running. Same results. So
    SSHing into your machine only tells you about the SSH connection, not
    what is running on the machine's display.

    Maybe I should uninstall XFCE and just go back to X11.

    I doubt that will solve your problem, for reasons Greg just explained.

    --
    Does anybody read signatures any more?

    https://charlescurley.com
    https://charlescurley.com/blog/

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)