This monthly report was an example not an exception for this Freexian contributor, and a point could be made that a DD who is defrauding
Debian LTS is defrauding Debian and should therefore be expelled
from Debian.
On 18025 March 1977, Adrian Bunk wrote:
I do agree that something like Freexian and it's effects (both, good and
bad) do warrant some project internal discussions. The size (small) and workload (huge) of our security team (and other core teams) is known. How that could be improved (or not) with the kind of fundraising done is a topic that had strong positions in the past. And for sure will still have that
now.
I do not think your mail does help this case.
It does read quite a lot of
"they kicked me, now I fight them". That is a bad start.
But the most interesting part in my first read of it is this:
This monthly report was an example not an exception for this Freexian contributor, and a point could be made that a DD who is defrauding
Debian LTS is defrauding Debian and should therefore be expelled
from Debian.
First, we do have a process around somewhere, if one DD thinks another
should be out of the project. Not used often, thankfully, but existing.
Second, while the above is written without names, it shouldn't be hard for people involved to find out who is meant. Something like slander, defamation or similar could get lawyers involved. Doesn't sound like a way to take. Please be careful what you write on our public lists.
bye, Joerg
...
https://www.isocfoundation.org/grant-programme/common-good-cyber-fund/
How could Debian use such a fund
(since all of it would require
financial control and lots of paperwork)?
...
and if you think Debian should apply for it
...
Regards
Worse than GitLab Inc., which is a neutral player providing equalThis does neither seem true (about GitLab being neutral) nor really
offers to everyone in the Debian ecosystem, Freexian SARL is competing directly with the businesses and employers of many other contributors (including many DDs) in our ecosystem.[3]
2. Debusine, and Freexian in general
------------------------------------
While it is laudable that Freexian has the explicit goal of helping
Debian, Debian giving preferential treatment to one company might
outweigh the benefits when this drives away other contributors.
While there is valid criticism at the current use of GitLab in our core infrastructure,[1] using Debusine in our infrastructure would be worse:
Similar to GitLab, Freexian SARL is a private for-profit company.
Similar to Gitlab, Debusine is Open Source that is also commercially
offered as SaaS.[2]
Worse than GitLab Inc., which is a neutral player providing equal offers
to everyone in the Debian ecosystem, Freexian SARL is competing directly with the businesses and employers of many other contributors (including
many DDs) in our ecosystem.[3]
The first problem would be the requirement "that the applicant is a qualifying nonprofit organization", which is the old issue that Debian
is not a legal entity.
Perhaps SPI might be sufficient.
(since all of it would require
financial control and lots of paperwork)?
This is the longstanding problem that a non-profit project of our size
and asking for donations should really have a proper budget process and annual financial reports on our website.
The program you are linking to would be one person paid full-time fornts.
two years, and then there would have to be both a suitable project
planned, and confidence that paying money there won't have a negative
impact on the unpaid volunteers working in that area.
A project that might fit the last bullet point of Objective 1 in this
grant would be to make our own infrastructure more resilient, two years wouldn't be too much for designing, discussing and implementing improveme
But such a project would have to be properly planned before applying.
And it would need someone available with the required skills in
security and AI.
Hi,Would that even be possible if Debian buildds were to use Debusine?
On 19/07/26 at 19:57 +0300, Adrian Bunk wrote:
2. Debusine, and Freexian in general
------------------------------------
While it is laudable that Freexian has the explicit goal of helping
Debian, Debian giving preferential treatment to one company might
outweigh the benefits when this drives away other contributors.
A long time ago, I was the DPL when Debian LTS was set up.
I was very careful at the time to defend a setup where mutiple actors
could collaborate on Debian LTS. I think that this still holds: if
someone if sufficiently unhappy with Freexian's contributions to LTS,
there's space to setup other actors, with their own funding models.
Hello Adrian,
El mi‚, 22 jul 2026 a las 13:21, Adrian Bunk (<bunk@debian.org>) escribi˘:
The first problem would be the requirement "that the applicant is a qualifying nonprofit organization", which is the old issue that Debian
is not a legal entity.
Perhaps SPI might be sufficient.
Yes, SPI qualifies.
(since all of it would require
financial control and lots of paperwork)?
This is the longstanding problem that a non-profit project of our size
and asking for donations should really have a proper budget process and annual financial reports on our website.
That should be covered by SPI, the non-profit, Debian is associated project.
The program you are linking to would be one person paid full-time for
two years, and then there would have to be both a suitable project
planned, and confidence that paying money there won't have a negative impact on the unpaid volunteers working in that area.
A project that might fit the last bullet point of Objective 1 in this
grant would be to make our own infrastructure more resilient, two years wouldn't be too much for designing, discussing and implementing improvements.
But such a project would have to be properly planned before applying.
And it would need someone available with the required skills in
security and AI.
When reading your email about "security team burnout", I thought this
fund could be an option to mitigate such concern, however, how could
make it fit and work for the project? Would it be valuable?
Regards
Just jumping on this bit.
Adrian Bunk <bunk@debian.org> wrote on 19/07/2026 at 18:57:21+0200:
Worse than GitLab Inc., which is a neutral player providing equal
offers to everyone in the Debian ecosystem, Freexian SARL is competing directly with the businesses and employers of many other contributors (including many DDs) in our ecosystem.[3]
This does neither seem true (about GitLab being neutral) nor really
relevant.
Many of us have employers that are competing with each others.
But the most interesting part in my first read of it is this:Right. Adrian, it was irresponsible of you to post this to a public
This monthly report was an example not an exception for this Freexian
contributor, and a point could be made that a DD who is defrauding
Debian LTS is defrauding Debian and should therefore be expelled
from Debian.
First, we do have a process around somewhere, if one DD thinks another
should be out of the project. Not used often, thankfully, but existing.
Second, while the above is written without names, it shouldn't be hard
for people involved to find out who is meant. Something like slander, defamation or similar could get lawyers involved. Doesn't sound like a
way to take. Please be careful what you write on our public lists.
On Wed, Jul 22, 2026 at 04:05:32PM +0200, Pierre-Elliott B‚cue wrote:And all our employers are all in competition with each other already?
Just jumping on this bit.
Adrian Bunk <bunk@debian.org> wrote on 19/07/2026 at 18:57:21+0200:
Worse than GitLab Inc., which is a neutral player providing equal
offers to everyone in the Debian ecosystem, Freexian SARL is competing
directly with the businesses and employers of many other contributors
(including many DDs) in our ecosystem.[3]
This does neither seem true (about GitLab being neutral) nor really
relevant.
The Debian services Frexian offers[1] are in direct competition to the
Debian services offered by many Debian contributors or their
employers.
And if Debusine would become the official way for building Debian, thenDebusine can be installed on premise so this is blatantly false.
the SaaS offer of the company maintaining Debusine would be a unique
selling point.
GitLab is in a different market.This makes no sense and still is not relevant.
Other competitors could have asked for funding for their projectMany of us have employers that are competing with each others.
Other competitors did not receive ? 485k taxpayer money to develop
their product by presenting it as "aimed at modernizing Debian's infrastructure" so that Debian can "attract [and] mantain its
community of highly skilled volunteers".[2]
This is the longstanding problem that a non-profit project of our size
and asking for donations should really have a proper budget process and annual financial reports on our website.
That should be covered by SPI, the non-profit, Debian is associatedproject.
What about money in other TOs?
When reading your email about "security team burnout", I thought this
fund could be an option to mitigate such concern, however, how could
make it fit and work for the project? Would it be valuable?
The general problem with such grants is that they are for additional features[1] - this is temporary funding of additional work, not
long-term funding of everyday work.
Hello,
El mi‚, 22 jul 2026, 22:14, Adrian Bunk <bunk@debian.org> escribi˘:
This is the longstanding problem that a non-profit project of our size
and asking for donations should really have a proper budget process and annual financial reports on our website.
That should be covered by SPI, the non-profit, Debian is associatedproject.
What about money in other TOs?
Every TO should have a yearly financial report, I assume they need to keep legal compliance.
Is "A current operational budget" something Debian has?
No, a community usually is not run by budgets.
...
Regards
Hi,
On 19/07/26 at 19:57 +0300, Adrian Bunk wrote:
2. Debusine, and Freexian in general
------------------------------------
While it is laudable that Freexian has the explicit goal of helping Debian, Debian giving preferential treatment to one company might
outweigh the benefits when this drives away other contributors.
A long time ago, I was the DPL when Debian LTS was set up.
I was very careful at the time to defend a setup where mutiple actors
could collaborate on Debian LTS. I think that this still holds: if
someone if sufficiently unhappy with Freexian's contributions to LTS,
there's space to setup other actors, with their own funding models.
While there is valid criticism at the current use of GitLab in our core infrastructure,[1] using Debusine in our infrastructure would be worse:
Similar to GitLab, Freexian SARL is a private for-profit company.
Similar to Gitlab, Debusine is Open Source that is also commercially offered as SaaS.[2]
Worse than GitLab Inc., which is a neutral player providing equal offers to everyone in the Debian ecosystem, Freexian SARL is competing directly with the businesses and employers of many other contributors (including many DDs) in our ecosystem.[3]
Unlike GitLab, Debusine does not have an Open Core business model, where
the editor could decide to remove important features from the Community Edition we are using. It is pure GPLv3 with no CLA. I think that's a key distinction.
Lucas
...
Right. Adrian, it was irresponsible of you to post this to a public
list. If you thought it was very important to include it (and I'm not convinced it was), you could have sent it as a reply but addressed only
to debian-private@.
Sean Whitton
...
Other competitors could have asked for funding for their project
provided it adhered to the conditions described here[1] or there[2].
I really don't know what you are trying to prove here, but you are doing
it badly, in my opinion.
...
Bests,
...
[2] https://www.sovereign.tech/programs/fund
| Sysop: | Jacob Catayoc |
|---|---|
| Location: | Pasay City, Metro Manila, Philippines |
| Users: | 5 |
| Nodes: | 4 (0 / 4) |
| Uptime: | 498677:40:46 |
| Calls: | 212 |
| Calls today: | 3 |
| Files: | 910 |
| D/L today: |
31 files (22,593K bytes) |
| Messages: | 69,826 |