Recently, I had a reason to pull out of storage some DVD-RAM optical
discs that I burned in 2003:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DVD-RAM>
They were flawless. All data was spotless.
I did the same for some CD/DVD-R (not RW) discs with the same results.
After 23 years, my data is pristine and will likely remain so for
another 23 years.
All the burning was originally done with GNU/Linux utilities and, furthermore, with $49.95 burners from Newegg, BestBuy, or equivalent retailers.
Currently, I burn all my data onto Blu-Ray M-Discs which putatively
have a lifespan of 100+ years:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-DISC>
I post this message because there are many claims that state that
optical disc data becomes corrupted after just a few years. I say
"screw you" to such claims.
Give me GNU/Linux, M-Disc, and a $49.95 burner and I shall preserve
my data forever.
Have BR burner and, every few months, burn my
most important stuff. Still not 'very much'
storage but, organize properly, and it's
"enough".
On Wed, 18 Nov 2026 19:31:03 -0500, c186282 wrote:
Have BR burner and, every few months, burn my
most important stuff. Still not 'very much'
storage but, organize properly, and it's
"enough".
Excellent! A wise activity!
The only problem with burning to optical disk is that it requires
a huge amount of time. For example, I burn BDR 25 Gb disks at
the slowest speed (growisofs -speed=2 ...) and it takes about
2 hours to complete.
Of course, I could burn at a much higher speed but slower speeds
give better results.
However, the longevity of the results certainly negates any concern
about the burn time.
On 11/18/26 21:30, Leroy H wrote:
On Wed, 18 Nov 2026 19:31:03 -0500, c186282 wrote:
Have BR burner and, every few months, burn my
most important stuff. Still not 'very much'
storage but, organize properly, and it's
"enough".
Excellent! A wise activity!
The only problem with burning to optical disk is that it requires
a huge amount of time. For example, I burn BDR 25 Gb disks at
the slowest speed (growisofs -speed=2 ...) and it takes about
2 hours to complete.
Yep, close to 2 hours.
But ...
I post this message because there are many claims that state that
optical disc data becomes corrupted after just a few years. I say
"screw you" to such claims.
Because I'm paranoid, after I burn each disc I verify it with
both the drive that burned it and with a second drive.
On 18/11/2026 20:21, Leroy H wrote:
I post this message because there are many claims that state that
optical disc data becomes corrupted after just a few years.ÿ I say
"screw you" to such claims.
I had several CDs with holes in the data layer. Burned those in the late 90's. If I recall correctly they were all made by Sony.
On 19 Nov 2026 04:24:33 GMT, Robert Riches wrote:
Because I'm paranoid, after I burn each disc I verify it with
both the drive that burned it and with a second drive.
Real paranoia requires making ECC recovery files using dvdisaster:
<https://github.com/speed47/dvdisaster>
I just settle for multiple copies.
I make PAR2 files.
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 18:36:10 GMT, Charlie Gibbs wrote:
I make PAR2 files.
PAR2 is not recommended for optical media. That's why dvdisaster
was developed.
The exact reason for this is beyond me.
Recently, I had a reason to pull out of storage some DVD-RAM optical
discs that I burned in 2003:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DVD-RAM>
They were flawless. All data was spotless.
I did the same for some CD/DVD-R (not RW) discs with the same
results.
After 23 years, my data is pristine and will likely remain so for
another 23 years.
I post this message because there are many claims that state that
optical disc data becomes corrupted after just a few years. I say
"screw you" to such claims.
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 18:36:10 GMT, Charlie Gibbs wrote:
I make PAR2 files.
PAR2 is not recommended for optical media. That's why dvdisaster
was developed.
The exact reason for this is beyond me.
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming". I have actual disks that
I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later. Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
On 2026-11-19, c186282 <c186282@nnada.net> wrote:
On 11/18/26 21:30, Leroy H wrote:
On Wed, 18 Nov 2026 19:31:03 -0500, c186282 wrote:
Have BR burner and, every few months, burn my
most important stuff. Still not 'very much'
storage but, organize properly, and it's
"enough".
Excellent! A wise activity!
The only problem with burning to optical disk is that it requires
a huge amount of time. For example, I burn BDR 25 Gb disks at
the slowest speed (growisofs -speed=2 ...) and it takes about
2 hours to complete.
Yep, close to 2 hours.
But ...
Takes me about 30 minutes to burn ~24.8GB to a BD-R with a
Pioneer burner at default speed.
I use PlexDisc brand media. I had been using Verbatim brand but
was making lots of coasters. I bought one spindle of each of 3-4
brands and tested them. Verbatim made ~20% coasters. The others
made vastly fewer or none at all.
Because I'm paranoid, after I burn each disc I verify it with
both the drive that burned it and with a second drive.
On 18/11/2026 20:21, Leroy H wrote:
I post this message because there are many claims that state that
optical disc data becomes corrupted after just a few years.ÿ I say
"screw you" to such claims.
I had several CDs with holes in the data layer. Burned those in the late 90's. If I recall correctly they were all made by Sony.
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 21:06:21 -0000 (UTC), Rich wrote:
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming". I have actual disks that
I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later. Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
All that I can say is that your disks must have been inferior
budget brands.
We are considering here the consumer market which is always
flooded with cheap brands that are designed for quick sale.
But, with a bit of research, one can locate high quality disks.
Taiyo Yuden, a former Japanese manufacturer of high quality
DVD disks, is one example. All of my DVDs, burned years ago,
are Taiyo Yuden and I have never experienced any failures.
But DVDs are limited in storage and now I use M-Disk BDR.
Likewise, there have been no failures and I don't expect any
in the future.
I cannot answer for your observed failures but possibly it
is the rapid burn speed or even the burn software/hardware.
Whatever, my confidence in optical storage, based on my own
experience, is unshakable.
Leroy H <lh@somewhere.net> wrote:
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 18:36:10 GMT, Charlie Gibbs wrote:
I make PAR2 files.
PAR2 is not recommended for optical media. That's why dvdisaster
was developed.
The exact reason for this is beyond me.
PAR2 operates at the file level, within the filesystem. If you can not
read the disk, because filesystem metadata is corrupted, you cannot
retreive the files, so you have no PAR2 files (nor the protected files)
with which to perform a par repair.
DVDisaster operates at the level of the optical disk sectors. It
repairs the stored files (if they are corrupted), and the filesystem metadata needed to read off those files, so what you get back (assuming enough redundancy to fix any issues) is an ISO image file with all the stored files inside intact and readable.
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 21:06:21 -0000 (UTC), Rich wrote:
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming". I have actual disks that
I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later. Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
All that I can say is that your disks must have been inferior
budget brands.
We are considering here the consumer market which is always
flooded with cheap brands that are designed for quick sale.
But, with a bit of research, one can locate high quality disks.
Taiyo Yuden, a former Japanese manufacturer of high quality
DVD disks, is one example. All of my DVDs, burned years ago,
are Taiyo Yuden and I have never experienced any failures.
But DVDs are limited in storage and now I use M-Disk BDR.
Likewise, there have been no failures and I don't expect any
in the future.
On 2026-11-19, Rich <rich@example.invalid> wrote:
Leroy H <lh@somewhere.net> wrote:
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 18:36:10 GMT, Charlie Gibbs wrote:
I make PAR2 files.
PAR2 is not recommended for optical media. That's why dvdisaster
was developed.
The exact reason for this is beyond me.
PAR2 operates at the file level, within the filesystem. If you can not
read the disk, because filesystem metadata is corrupted, you cannot
retreive the files, so you have no PAR2 files (nor the protected files)
with which to perform a par repair.
DVDisaster operates at the level of the optical disk sectors. It
repairs the stored files (if they are corrupted), and the filesystem
metadata needed to read off those files, so what you get back (assuming
enough redundancy to fix any issues) is an ISO image file with all the
stored files inside intact and readable.
Good point. Recently I tried reading some DVD-Rs that I burned
20 years ago. Most of them are fine. One or two have errors
which the PAR2 files are able to repair. But you're right,
if it was the directory blocks that got corrupted I'd be screwed.
I don't burn many discs anymore - my backups are now on pairs
of terabyte drives, and I keep one of each pair offsite.
But if I do get back into burning archival discs,
I'll definitely give DVDisaster a look.
Who are the best brands these days?
Aren't they still very slow like CDs and DVDs?
Leroy H <lh@somewhere.net> wrote:
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 21:06:21 -0000 (UTC), Rich wrote:
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming". I have actual disks that
I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later. Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
All that I can say is that your disks must have been inferior
budget brands.
We are considering here the consumer market which is always
flooded with cheap brands that are designed for quick sale.
But, with a bit of research, one can locate high quality disks.
Taiyo Yuden, a former Japanese manufacturer of high quality
DVD disks, is one example. All of my DVDs, burned years ago,
are Taiyo Yuden and I have never experienced any failures.
Who are the best brands these days?
But DVDs are limited in storage and now I use M-Disk BDR.
Likewise, there have been no failures and I don't expect any
in the future.
Aren't they still very slow like CDs and DVDs?
I make PAR2 files.
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 18:36:10 GMT, Charlie Gibbs wrote:
I make PAR2 files.
Erasure codes are a neat concept for adding an extra layer of
tolerance against failures, but they should be an addition to
redundant backups, not a replacement for them.
I post this message because there are many claims that state that
optical disc data becomes corrupted after just a few years. I say
"screw you" to such claims.
I had several CDs with holes in the data layer. Burned those in the late >90's. If I recall correctly they were all made by Sony.
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:51:21 +0100, John Bokma <contact@johnbokma.com> wrote:
On 18/11/2026 20:21, Leroy H wrote:
I post this message because there are many claims that state that
optical disc data becomes corrupted after just a few years. I say
"screw you" to such claims.
I had several CDs with holes in the data layer. Burned those in the late
90's. If I recall correctly they were all made by Sony.
Same.
I have a cd-case full of burned media going back about 25 years. Some of them have bit-rotted in place to the point where when holding the disk up to a
light, it looks likes a starfield.
Others, you can see the dye dis-coloring from the outside edge in.
Others are fine...so far.
This is a mix of brands, some cheap, some good, with no real correlation between
the stuff that's gone bad and the stuff that's stayed good. Regardless, it's a clear physical failure of the media.
Each year, another couple go bad.
These are not backups -- at least not any more. (Storage and backups are done
with multi-drive ZFS arrays at this point.)
These are burned discs of convenience, such as a set of Layered Products CDs for
my VAX or a Polish Bootleg of Office 97 which helpfully slipstreams the licence
key. Well, I found that one had bit the dust when I did fresh Windows 98 build last year.
Anyway. Would I trust a burned disk 5 years? 100%
10 years? probably.
20? I'd be making sure I had that data safely stored away somewhere else.
Replication is the ONLY safe tactic for true archival
data storage.
Put it on mag disks, put it on optical
disks, put it on the 'cloud' too. Move it to new disks
every so often.
The National Archives and Smithsonian are already
freaking because there are no living devices to
READ old data tapes/drums/gen-1-disks. Every maker
used different encoding too. Esp for NASA stuff
much equipment tended to be one-off, and docs
seem hard to find.
On Fri, 20 Nov 2026 21:03:41 -0500, c186282 wrote:
Replication is the ONLY safe tactic for true archival
data storage.
I have amassed probably a few hundred archival optical disks of various types.
What concerns me is not the longevity of the optical media but the
hardware that is used to read such media. This is why I have stockpiled
many CD/DVD/BDR readers/burners. At least every year I will purchase
a new CD/DVD/BDR reader/burner even if I will not immediately use it. Fortunately, GNU/Linux has the software to access this hardware and always will (unlike the commercial OSs).
Put it on mag disks, put it on optical
disks, put it on the 'cloud' too. Move it to new disks
every so often.
To transfer hundreds of optical disks to other media would be an undertaking far beyond the capability of a single person. Thus, my optical archives
must remain as is. Whether or not this situation will be stable in the long term only time will tell.
The National Archives and Smithsonian are already
freaking because there are no living devices to
READ old data tapes/drums/gen-1-disks. Every maker
used different encoding too. Esp for NASA stuff
much equipment tended to be one-off, and docs
seem hard to find.
NASA, and others, seem to consider data archives as a low priority.
NASA, fer chrissake, lost the original moon landing video tapes:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_11_missing_tapes>
But what does profit-hungry Hollywood do to preserve its perhaps
millions of hours of film footage? Mickey Mouse will likely
copyrighted forever and preserving such money-making fantasies will
be a lesson for all of us.
I'm just old enough to remember when those old
spinney tapes were still REAL. Lots of data on
them, from pgm code snips to databases and such.
Others in this group are older than me, remember
them even better. The PDP-11 I learned on had
one of those tape drives, but big biz and NASA
and such had vast BANKS of them. Batch files,
code overlays ... the info still exists, is still
interesting/historical, but how to READ it ?
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 21:06:21 -0000 (UTC), Rich wrote:
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming". I have actual disks that
I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later. Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
All that I can say is that your disks must have been inferior
budget brands.
We are considering here the consumer market which is always
flooded with cheap brands that are designed for quick sale.
But, with a bit of research, one can locate high quality disks.
Taiyo Yuden, a former Japanese manufacturer of high quality
DVD disks, is one example. All of my DVDs, burned years ago,
are Taiyo Yuden and I have never experienced any failures.
But DVDs are limited in storage and now I use M-Disk BDR.
Likewise, there have been no failures and I don't expect any
in the future.
I cannot answer for your observed failures but possibly it
is the rapid burn speed or even the burn software/hardware.
Whatever, my confidence in optical storage, based on my own
experience, is unshakable.
On 2026-11-19 23:22, Leroy H wrote:
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 21:06:21 -0000 (UTC), Rich wrote:
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming".ÿ I have actual disks that
I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later.ÿ Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
All that I can say is that your disks must have been inferior
budget brands.
We are considering here the consumer market which is always
flooded with cheap brands that are designed for quick sale.
But, with a bit of research, one can locate high quality disks.
Taiyo Yuden, a former Japanese manufacturer of high quality
DVD disks, is one example.ÿ All of my DVDs, burned years ago,
are Taiyo Yuden and I have never experienced any failures.
But DVDs are limited in storage and now I use M-Disk BDR.
Likewise, there have been no failures and I don't expect any
in the future.
I cannot answer for your observed failures but possibly it
is the rapid burn speed or even the burn software/hardware.
Whatever, my confidence in optical storage, based on my own
experience, is unshakable.
If you are using Taiyo Yuden, I am not surprised. But that is only a fraction of the DVDs that have been sold. Many are low quality for
archival, and there is no way that the people know about that.
There was a web page that classified DVD blanks for quality, and you
could find out if any given DVD was good or bad. I can't find the link now.
If you are using Taiyo Yuden, I am not surprised. But that is only a fraction of the DVDs that have been sold. Many are low quality for archival, and there is no way that the people know about that.
There was a web page that classified DVD blanks for quality, and you
could find out if any given DVD was good or bad. I can't find the
link now.
Carlos E.R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:
If you are using Taiyo Yuden, I am not surprised. But that is only a
fraction of the DVDs that have been sold. Many are low quality for
archival, and there is no way that the people know about that.
There was a web page that classified DVD blanks for quality, and you
could find out if any given DVD was good or bad. I can't find the
link now.
The sad part was there was no way to ever be certian you were actually
buying what you thought. The end consumer brand labels tended to shift
back in suppliers often enough that a web page that said that, say,
Memorex DVD-R's were actually made by Taiyo Yuden might have been
accurate at the time. But three years later, one never knew if
"Memorex" was still using Taiyo Yuden as a supplier, or had shifted to
a different supplier in the ensuing time.
And since none of them documented, anywhere, on the packaging the
actual OEM maker, there was no way to tell from the packaging either.
On Fri, 20 Nov 2026 01:39:47 -0000 (UTC), Ant wrote:
Who are the best brands these days?
Probably M-Disc BDR:
<https://www.amazon.com/dp/B011PZALWA>
But the burner has to support M-Disc. Check the specs.
Aren't they still very slow like CDs and DVDs?
Well, since the intended purpose is data archiving the discs
will only be read occasionally and speed doesn't matter much.
On 2026-11-21 21:14, Carlos E.R. wrote:
On 2026-11-19 23:22, Leroy H wrote:
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 21:06:21 -0000 (UTC), Rich wrote:
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming".? I have actual disks that >>> I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later.? Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
All that I can say is that your disks must have been inferior
budget brands.
We are considering here the consumer market which is always
flooded with cheap brands that are designed for quick sale.
But, with a bit of research, one can locate high quality disks.
Taiyo Yuden, a former Japanese manufacturer of high quality
DVD disks, is one example.? All of my DVDs, burned years ago,
are Taiyo Yuden and I have never experienced any failures.
But DVDs are limited in storage and now I use M-Disk BDR.
Likewise, there have been no failures and I don't expect any
in the future.
I cannot answer for your observed failures but possibly it
is the rapid burn speed or even the burn software/hardware.
Whatever, my confidence in optical storage, based on my own
experience, is unshakable.
If you are using Taiyo Yuden, I am not surprised. But that is only a fraction of the DVDs that have been sold. Many are low quality for archival, and there is no way that the people know about that.
There was a web page that classified DVD blanks for quality, and you
could find out if any given DVD was good or bad. I can't find the link now.
<https://www.digitalfaq.com/reviews/dvd-media.htm>
<https://adterrasperaspera.com/blog/2006/10/30/how-to-choose-cddvd-archival-media/>
Carlos E.R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:
On 2026-11-21 21:14, Carlos E.R. wrote:
On 2026-11-19 23:22, Leroy H wrote:
On Thu, 19 Nov 2026 21:06:21 -0000 (UTC), Rich wrote:
I've seen it directly, so I'm not "claiming".ÿ I have actual disks that >>>>> I burned myself become non-readable when checking on them some time
later.ÿ Where "some time" was on the order of only a few years.
All that I can say is that your disks must have been inferior
budget brands.
We are considering here the consumer market which is always
flooded with cheap brands that are designed for quick sale.
But, with a bit of research, one can locate high quality disks.
Taiyo Yuden, a former Japanese manufacturer of high quality
DVD disks, is one example.ÿ All of my DVDs, burned years ago,
are Taiyo Yuden and I have never experienced any failures.
But DVDs are limited in storage and now I use M-Disk BDR.
Likewise, there have been no failures and I don't expect any
in the future.
I cannot answer for your observed failures but possibly it
is the rapid burn speed or even the burn software/hardware.
Whatever, my confidence in optical storage, based on my own
experience, is unshakable.
If you are using Taiyo Yuden, I am not surprised. But that is only a
fraction of the DVDs that have been sold. Many are low quality for
archival, and there is no way that the people know about that.
There was a web page that classified DVD blanks for quality, and you
could find out if any given DVD was good or bad. I can't find the link now.
<https://www.digitalfaq.com/reviews/dvd-media.htm>
When was this updated?
<https://adterrasperaspera.com/blog/2006/10/30/how-to-choose-cddvd-archival-media/>
Last updated January 11th 2013. :/
| Sysop: | Jacob Catayoc |
|---|---|
| Location: | Pasay City, Metro Manila, Philippines |
| Users: | 5 |
| Nodes: | 4 (0 / 4) |
| Uptime: | 498677:21:09 |
| Calls: | 212 |
| Calls today: | 3 |
| Files: | 910 |
| D/L today: |
31 files (22,593K bytes) |
| Messages: | 69,826 |