• Taking Speedy too seriously (Was: Back To CS Basics. Fuck AI)

    From Kenny McCormack@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, October 24, 2026 12:10:39
    In article <11bhv61$1bjd2$2@dont-email.me>,
    Janis Papanagnou <janis_papanagnou+ng@hotmail.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 05:59, c186282 wrote:

    KSH and BASH are "mostly compatible". Minor diffs but
    nothing hard to get around. Anything you can do in KSH
    can be done in BASH.

    This is not correct. While Bash has over time adopted quite
    some features from Ksh - but sadly needed often far too many
    years for that - there's still a lot substantial functions
    in Ksh that Bash has not implemented (or substituted by some
    equivalent feature).

    I think you're taking Speedy way too seriously here. All of your points
    are valid, of course, but it should not be necessary to respond to the
    troll.

    BTW, you assert that there are (many) features of Ksh that are not (yet) present in bash. I'm not doubting you, but I am curious about examples.
    It seems to me that if you assert something like that, you should give examples.

    --
    Rich people pay Fox people to convince middle class people to blame poor people.

    (John Fugelsang)

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Janis Papanagnou@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, October 24, 2026 18:53:40
    On 2026-10-24 14:10, Kenny McCormack wrote:
    In article <11bhv61$1bjd2$2@dont-email.me>,
    Janis Papanagnou <janis_papanagnou+ng@hotmail.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 05:59, c186282 wrote:

    KSH and BASH are "mostly compatible". Minor diffs but
    nothing hard to get around. Anything you can do in KSH
    can be done in BASH.

    This is not correct. While Bash has over time adopted quite
    some features from Ksh - but sadly needed often far too many
    years for that - there's still a lot substantial functions
    in Ksh that Bash has not implemented (or substituted by some
    equivalent feature).

    I think you're taking Speedy way too seriously here. All of your points
    are valid, of course, but it should not be necessary to respond to the
    troll.

    Oh, I didn't knew that he's considered a troll. His post looked just uninformed, or opinionated, not trollish.


    BTW, you assert that there are (many) features of Ksh that are not (yet) present in bash. I'm not doubting you, but I am curious about examples.
    It seems to me that if you assert something like that, you should give examples.

    Mind that his post says "Minor diffs"; and I was not (not primarily)
    addressing the absolute number of features but those features that
    are hard(er) or in practice impossible [based on existing functions]
    to substitute. Off the top of my head I had been thinking of discipline functions, or the "type system" - these are very closely embedded in
    the shell.

    Note that while these features are probably not widely used there's
    also many often used details I used, functions and options, that Bash
    doesn't have as I noticed over the time. I've occasionally mentioned
    those in some posts that where about such functionality, but I'm too
    lazy to create a list or something, which would require to re-test
    every features whether one or another has meanwhile been implemented;
    that would be too much effort.[*])

    Janis

    [*] After finishing writing the post I remembered that we could ask
    a search machine AI, but strangely it had no or found any substantial information, not even the obvious examples; so we have to rely on the
    experts or own experience here.


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From c186282@3:633/10 to All on Monday, October 26, 2026 00:28:00
    On 10/24/26 12:53, Janis Papanagnou wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 14:10, Kenny McCormack wrote:
    In article <11bhv61$1bjd2$2@dont-email.me>,
    Janis Papanagnou˙ <janis_papanagnou+ng@hotmail.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 05:59, c186282 wrote:

    ˙˙ KSH and BASH are "mostly compatible". Minor diffs but
    ˙˙ nothing hard to get around. Anything you can do in KSH
    ˙˙ can be done in BASH.

    This is not correct. While Bash has over time adopted quite
    some features from Ksh - but sadly needed often far too many
    years for that - there's still a lot substantial functions
    in Ksh that Bash has not implemented (or substituted by some
    equivalent feature).

    I think you're taking Speedy way too seriously here.˙ All of your points
    are valid, of course, but it should not be necessary to respond to the
    troll.

    Oh, I didn't knew that he's considered a troll. His post looked just uninformed, or opinionated, not trollish.

    Thanks, I think :-)

    I never 'troll' - just relate MY experiences and what
    I've learned from them. I had my own path, own needs,
    my own 'environments', starting in the punch-card days.
    But what served ME best may not be what served YOU, what
    I learned may not be what YOU learned.

    A great purpose of groups like these is to bring in
    a LOT of experiences and perspectives. You MAY find
    something compatible/useful in all the diverse advice.
    I don't pretend to know-it-all, nothing close (though
    a few, well, SAY they do :-)

    As said elsewhere, "NEED" eventually supersedes all else.
    Earlier on, all the shells maybe started with a narrow
    'vision' but HAD to include capabilities the other people
    put in. Sometimes the additions were neat/clear, sometimes
    not so much, but they're THERE.

    A sort of 'functional convergence' due to NEEDS.

    Anyway, I reject 'religions' built around shells or
    langs and such. For each need, pick the best tools
    and approaches. "Best" - sometimes that's what most
    harmonizes with YOUR brand of thinking.

    BTW, you assert that there are (many) features of Ksh that are not (yet)
    present in bash.˙ I'm not doubting you, but I am curious about examples.
    It seems to me that if you assert something like that, you should give
    examples.

    Mind that his post says "Minor diffs"; and I was not (not primarily) addressing the absolute number of features but those features that
    are hard(er) or in practice impossible [based on existing functions]
    to substitute. Off the top of my head I had been thinking of discipline functions, or the "type system" - these are very closely embedded in
    the shell.

    Note that while these features are probably not widely used there's
    also many often used details I used, functions and options, that Bash
    doesn't have as I noticed over the time. I've occasionally mentioned
    those in some posts that where about such functionality, but I'm too
    lazy to create a list or something, which would require to re-test
    every features whether one or another has meanwhile been implemented;
    that would be too much effort.[*])

    Janis

    [*] After finishing writing the post I remembered that we could ask
    a search machine AI, but strangely it had no or found any substantial information, not even the obvious examples; so we have to rely on the
    experts or own experience here.

    "AI"s aren't really as all-around 'smart' as their
    sellers suggest :-)

    You generally find that out AFTER you $ubscribe .....


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From c186282@3:633/10 to All on Monday, October 26, 2026 00:57:26
    On 10/24/26 08:10, Kenny McCormack wrote:
    In article <11bhv61$1bjd2$2@dont-email.me>,
    Janis Papanagnou <janis_papanagnou+ng@hotmail.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 05:59, c186282 wrote:

    KSH and BASH are "mostly compatible". Minor diffs but
    nothing hard to get around. Anything you can do in KSH
    can be done in BASH.

    This is not correct. While Bash has over time adopted quite
    some features from Ksh - but sadly needed often far too many
    years for that - there's still a lot substantial functions
    in Ksh that Bash has not implemented (or substituted by some
    equivalent feature).

    I think you're taking Speedy way too seriously here. All of your points
    are valid, of course, but it should not be necessary to respond to the
    troll.

    BTW, you assert that there are (many) features of Ksh that are not (yet) present in bash. I'm not doubting you, but I am curious about examples.
    It seems to me that if you assert something like that, you should give examples.

    I've mentioned (necessary) "Functional Convergence". If yer
    shell doesn't do something neat-o some other one does NOW,
    it WILL soon enough. Might get squeezed-in nice/neat, or
    maybe NOT. All great/pure ideas/visions eventually HAVE to
    converge somewhere - or vanish into the historical recycle bin.

    Anyway, for 'scripts', I'm 99% Python now. Does EVERYTHING
    and MUCH clearer than any old shell.

    Of note, did NOT use Python until P3 came out. It seemed
    interesting/versatile but why learn an obsolete version ?
    BASIC, skip the bile, became a fair 'script' lang after
    awhile - but, too clunky IMHO - meant for a different
    era, different environment, different mindset.



    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Janis Papanagnou@3:633/10 to All on Monday, October 26, 2026 06:20:48
    On 2026-10-26 05:28, c186282 wrote:
    On 10/24/26 12:53, Janis Papanagnou wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 14:10, Kenny McCormack wrote:
    In article <11bhv61$1bjd2$2@dont-email.me>,
    Janis Papanagnou˙ <janis_papanagnou+ng@hotmail.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 05:59, c186282 wrote:

    ˙˙ KSH and BASH are "mostly compatible". Minor diffs but
    ˙˙ nothing hard to get around. Anything you can do in KSH
    ˙˙ can be done in BASH.

    This is not correct. While Bash has over time adopted quite
    some features from Ksh - but sadly needed often far too many
    years for that - there's still a lot substantial functions
    in Ksh that Bash has not implemented (or substituted by some
    equivalent feature).

    I think you're taking Speedy way too seriously here.˙ All of your points >>> are valid, of course, but it should not be necessary to respond to the
    troll.

    Oh, I didn't knew that he's considered a troll. His post looked just
    uninformed, or opinionated, not trollish.

    ˙ Thanks, I think˙ :-)

    ˙ I never 'troll' - just relate MY experiences and what
    ˙ I've learned from them. I had my own path, own needs,
    ˙ my own 'environments', starting in the punch-card days.

    (I've still a block of punch-cards in the cellar, so I've got an
    impression where you're coming from.)

    ˙ But what served ME best may not be what served YOU, what
    ˙ I learned may not be what YOU learned.

    Oh, in my previous reply I said something like that; that it's
    fine if it serves you in your private contexts.

    A discrepancy might appear when you are working in a larger area
    with rules that are not tailored to your personal likings but to
    experiences from a larger (or another) group of persons.


    ˙ A great purpose of groups like these is to bring in
    ˙ a LOT of experiences and perspectives. You MAY find
    ˙ something compatible/useful in all the diverse advice.
    ˙ I don't pretend to know-it-all, nothing close (though
    ˙ a few, well, SAY they do :-)

    Oh, I'm completely fine with that. - If statements are formulated
    as opinions, what else can we do than agree to those or disagree.
    A problem, though, is, when opinions are stated as facts, and if
    statements are even wrong, then they should be corrected. (Or
    clarified if it was just a communication or expression problem.)


    ˙ As said elsewhere, "NEED" eventually supersedes all else.
    ˙ Earlier on, all the shells maybe started with a narrow
    ˙ 'vision' but HAD to include capabilities the other people
    ˙ put in. Sometimes the additions were neat/clear, sometimes
    ˙ not so much, but they're THERE.

    ˙ A sort of 'functional convergence' due to NEEDS.

    ˙ Anyway, I reject 'religions' built around shells or
    ˙ langs and such. For each need, pick the best tools
    ˙ and approaches. "Best" - sometimes that's what most
    ˙ harmonizes with YOUR brand of thinking.

    (Unfortunately language topics are often presented with religious
    fervor.)

    Janis

    [...]

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From c186282@3:633/10 to All on Monday, October 26, 2026 03:38:31
    On 10/26/26 01:20, Janis Papanagnou wrote:
    On 2026-10-26 05:28, c186282 wrote:
    On 10/24/26 12:53, Janis Papanagnou wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 14:10, Kenny McCormack wrote:
    In article <11bhv61$1bjd2$2@dont-email.me>,
    Janis Papanagnou˙ <janis_papanagnou+ng@hotmail.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-24 05:59, c186282 wrote:

    ˙˙ KSH and BASH are "mostly compatible". Minor diffs but
    ˙˙ nothing hard to get around. Anything you can do in KSH
    ˙˙ can be done in BASH.

    This is not correct. While Bash has over time adopted quite
    some features from Ksh - but sadly needed often far too many
    years for that - there's still a lot substantial functions
    in Ksh that Bash has not implemented (or substituted by some
    equivalent feature).

    I think you're taking Speedy way too seriously here.˙ All of your
    points
    are valid, of course, but it should not be necessary to respond to the >>>> troll.

    Oh, I didn't knew that he's considered a troll. His post looked just
    uninformed, or opinionated, not trollish.

    ˙˙ Thanks, I think˙ :-)

    ˙˙ I never 'troll' - just relate MY experiences and what
    ˙˙ I've learned from them. I had my own path, own needs,
    ˙˙ my own 'environments', starting in the punch-card days.

    (I've still a block of punch-cards in the cellar, so I've got an
    impression where you're coming from.)

    ˙˙ But what served ME best may not be what served YOU, what
    ˙˙ I learned may not be what YOU learned.

    My first computer was a PDP-11. Great unit.
    But still remember having to submit my card
    stack (DON'T drop it !) to the IT overlords.
    Helped a bit if you offered them 'gifts'.

    Oh, in my previous reply I said something like that; that it's
    fine if it serves you in your private contexts.

    Most everybody has a 'private context'. Doesn't
    matter what you do in 'IT'. Every life experience
    and need is a bit different, takes you down
    different paths. Since the 70s the field was
    SO wide that nobody could do it ALL, keep it
    ALL in mind.

    DID like that newfangled 'C' language for
    the PDPs though :-)

    A discrepancy might appear when you are working in a larger area
    with rules that are not tailored to your personal likings but to
    experiences from a larger (or another) group of persons.

    Been there.

    ˙˙ A great purpose of groups like these is to bring in
    ˙˙ a LOT of experiences and perspectives. You MAY find
    ˙˙ something compatible/useful in all the diverse advice.
    ˙˙ I don't pretend to know-it-all, nothing close (though
    ˙˙ a few, well, SAY they do :-)

    Oh, I'm completely fine with that. - If statements are formulated
    as opinions, what else can we do than agree to those or disagree.
    A problem, though, is, when opinions are stated as facts, and if
    statements are even wrong, then they should be corrected. (Or
    clarified if it was just a communication or expression problem.)

    Still a lot of 'religion' involved ... some present
    THE Way ... holy writ. Rarely works for most.

    Yea, there are maybe a few IQ-200 people who post.
    Well, good for them. we need some IQ-200 people.
    However even they have their prejudices and
    preferences that may not serve all. It's the
    tendency for ATTITUDE that most annoys me. Not
    looking for an Ayatollah.

    Ever see that "Sheldon" character from the TV series ?
    HIS way or you get the "retard" label :-)

    ˙˙ As said elsewhere, "NEED" eventually supersedes all else.
    ˙˙ Earlier on, all the shells maybe started with a narrow
    ˙˙ 'vision' but HAD to include capabilities the other people
    ˙˙ put in. Sometimes the additions were neat/clear, sometimes
    ˙˙ not so much, but they're THERE.

    ˙˙ A sort of 'functional convergence' due to NEEDS.

    ˙˙ Anyway, I reject 'religions' built around shells or
    ˙˙ langs and such. For each need, pick the best tools
    ˙˙ and approaches. "Best" - sometimes that's what most
    ˙˙ harmonizes with YOUR brand of thinking.

    (Unfortunately language topics are often presented with religious
    fervor.)

    Very much noted.

    But, bigger picture, I think that's *wrong*.

    MANY paths to "your solution". Pick the best
    and most compatible. SO many paths to be had
    these days. Be smart and sensible. Simpler
    TENDS to be better long-term.


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Janis Papanagnou@3:633/10 to All on Tuesday, October 27, 2026 05:01:49
    On 2026-10-26 08:38, c186282 wrote:
    [...]
    ˙ My first computer was a PDP-11. Great unit.
    ˙ But still remember having to submit my card
    ˙ stack (DON'T drop it !) to the IT overlords.

    Corrupted data (if you've dropped it)...

    ˙ Helped a bit if you offered them 'gifts'.

    ...and corrupted people?

    Janis

    PS: The nastiest thing I've encountered with the
    card deck was that a friend exchanged all my cards
    which carried the word 'BEGIN' with cards carrying
    the word 'SADAT' - just as a hilarious play with
    words WRT two international politicians back then.
    Not so funny for me when I noticed all the syntax
    errors and had to wait another hour for the next
    batch run.


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From c186282@3:633/10 to All on Tuesday, October 27, 2026 12:24:16
    On 10/27/26 00:01, Janis Papanagnou wrote:
    On 2026-10-26 08:38, c186282 wrote:
    [...]
    ˙˙ My first computer was a PDP-11. Great unit.
    ˙˙ But still remember having to submit my card
    ˙˙ stack (DON'T drop it !) to the IT overlords.

    Corrupted data (if you've dropped it)...

    Well, a lot of re-sorting at the very least.

    Punch cards and paper tape WORKED. Clunky and
    low-density but they worked - and were used
    for quite awhile. However putting a COBOL
    corporate accounting system on cards is
    not an attractive prospect.

    I've run into people who remember those
    mag tape towers from old movies and think
    the programs/data was just magically
    uploaded directly to them. Nope, paper
    cards first .....

    Found a PDP-11 emulator for Linux, but it
    just wouldn't be quite the same. MAY be
    some actual working units still out there
    however. Weak unit by today's standards,
    but at the time it was pretty good.

    ˙˙ Helped a bit if you offered them 'gifts'.

    ...and corrupted people?

    People are mostly pre-corrupted :-)

    The SysLord had a serial terminal, but all
    the rest of us had to do cards.

    Janis

    PS: The nastiest thing I've encountered with the
    card deck was that a friend exchanged all my cards
    which carried the word 'BEGIN' with cards carrying
    the word 'SADAT' - just as a hilarious play with
    words WRT two international politicians back then.
    Not so funny for me when I noticed all the syntax
    errors and had to wait another hour for the next
    batch run.

    Admit it, was a CLEVER joke !

    SADAT ... do, but barely, remember it now.

    The dictator, well, things didn't work out so
    well for him :-)


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)