On 16/10/2026 16:19, Rich wrote:
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:That is not true
On 15/10/2026 20:40, Charlie Gibbs wrote:
Actually, the question should probably not be how did we survive
without these things, but how long we're going to survive with them.
Or worse, how long would we survive without them?
The thought of a total loss of Internet, let alone the whole power grid, >>> fills me with horror.
So much depends on it. Almost everything runs on electricity these days. >>> The pumps that drain the marshes for agriculture. The pumps that supply
you with fresh drinkable water, the pumps that get the sewage to the
treatment plants. The pumps that put fuel into your car. The pumps that
run your refrigerator or your central heating. The computers that
process everyday money transactions...
All of those things (other than the computers that did not exist yet)
also ran on electricity in the 70's, 60's, 50's, etc. So while it does
not change the worry of a power grid collapse for any length of time,
it also also been an overhanging risk for a very long time.
Much ran on localised power sources from windmills, to steam end diesel engines right up to the 90s
Gas refrigerators are still being made
Petrol (gasoline) used to be pumped by hand
cash existed as the dominant means of payment
People had candles paraffin lamps and solid fuel or wood fires.
In short when things went sideways there was older technology to fall
back on
Who today carries a paper map and a compass?
The problem is that today apart from survivalists no one has the kit or
even knows how to use it
Yes. That is an aspect of it. Also the utter dependency of the city to a rural hinterland to supply the fresh food and water, the fundamental
energy, and have somewhere to dump the trash and the sewage. A rural hinterland that the urban dweller does not understand and despises. Yet whose impact is taken entirely for granted.
"We don't need farms! We have supermarkets!"
Anyone who does a systems analysis of modern post industrial
civilisation is horrified at the multiple single points of failure
and key infrastructures. Ukraine and Russia are currently engaged in
doing just that, the one to destroy a civilisation that wont submit,
and the other to destroy the war machine being used to try.
The one item left that isn't yet dependent upon electric supply is gas (methane/propane) tank hot water heaters. Those still seem to be built
as a mechanical thermostat driving a mechanical fuel valve to turn the burner on and off. Of course, to make hot water they do need a fuel
supply, and if that fuel is piped in from a distribution system instead
of a tank, there's a dependency on the distribution system working.
On 2026-10-23, Rich <rich@example.invalid> wrote:
The one item left that isn't yet dependent upon electric supply is gas
(methane/propane) tank hot water heaters. Those still seem to be built
as a mechanical thermostat driving a mechanical fuel valve to turn the
burner on and off. Of course, to make hot water they do need a fuel
supply, and if that fuel is piped in from a distribution system instead
of a tank, there's a dependency on the distribution system working.
True - but in my experience electrical failures happen far more
frequently than gas failures.
BTW gas stoves (at least basic cooktops) also run without electricity (although you might have to dig up some matches if you depend on a mains-driven spark to light it). This is quite handy during power
failures, since it means you can still heat something to eat - and
even get a bit of room heating on cold days.
Too bad the Powers that Be are trying to eliminate gas appliances.
I guess we need to save all that gas for LNG sales overseas.
But let something (could even be a weather event) interfearfreudian slip?
On 2026-10-23, Rich <rich@example.invalid> wrote:
The one item left that isn't yet dependent upon electric supply is gas
(methane/propane) tank hot water heaters. Those still seem to be built
as a mechanical thermostat driving a mechanical fuel valve to turn the
burner on and off. Of course, to make hot water they do need a fuel
supply, and if that fuel is piped in from a distribution system instead
of a tank, there's a dependency on the distribution system working.
True - but in my experience electrical failures happen far more
frequently than gas failures.
BTW gas stoves (at least basic cooktops) also run without electricity (although you might have to dig up some matches if you depend on a mains-driven spark to light it). This is quite handy during power
failures, since it means you can still heat something to eat - and
even get a bit of room heating on cold days.
Too bad the Powers that Be are trying to eliminate gas appliances.
I guess we need to save all that gas for LNG sales overseas.
On 10/23/26 16:28, Charlie Gibbs wrote:
On 2026-10-23, Rich <rich@example.invalid> wrote:
The one item left that isn't yet dependent upon electric supply is gas
(methane/propane) tank hot water heaters.ÿ Those still seem to be built
as a mechanical thermostat driving a mechanical fuel valve to turn the
burner on and off.ÿ Of course, to make hot water they do need a fuel
supply, and if that fuel is piped in from a distribution system instead
of a tank, there's a dependency on the distribution system working.
True - but in my experience electrical failures happen far more
frequently than gas failures.
ÿ I have exactly the opposite experience.
ÿ ELECTRIC is VERY reliable (USA) - gas shit,
ÿ well, weekly news about huge explosions or
ÿ fires.
BTW gas stoves (at least basic cooktops) also run without electricity
(although you might have to dig up some matches if you depend on a
mains-driven spark to light it).ÿ This is quite handy during power
failures, since it means you can still heat something to eat - and
even get a bit of room heating on cold days.
Too bad the Powers that Be are trying to eliminate gas appliances.
I guess we need to save all that gas for LNG sales overseas.
ÿ Gas cooking ... WILL admit it's "superior" for the
ÿ purpose. However that's hardly relevant when your
ÿ entire house explodes suddenly or everyone dies
ÿ from suffocation or monoxide. WON'T have gas !
Gas cooking ... WILL admit it's "superior" for the
ÿÿ purpose. However that's hardly relevant when your
ÿÿ entire house explodes suddenly or everyone dies
ÿÿ from suffocation or monoxide. WON'T have gas !
I guess that your mandatory periodical gas inspection services are not
up to par.ÿ >:-)
On 24/10/2026 12:44, Carlos E.R. wrote:
Gas cooking ... WILL admit it's "superior" for the
ÿÿ purpose. However that's hardly relevant when your
ÿÿ entire house explodes suddenly or everyone dies
ÿÿ from suffocation or monoxide. WON'T have gas !
I guess that your mandatory periodical gas inspection services are not
up to par.ÿ >:-)
Let alone his smoke alarms or CO detectors...
On 2026-10-24 14:09, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 24/10/2026 12:44, Carlos E.R. wrote:
Gas cooking ... WILL admit it's "superior" for the
ÿÿ purpose. However that's hardly relevant when your
ÿÿ entire house explodes suddenly or everyone dies
ÿÿ from suffocation or monoxide. WON'T have gas !
I guess that your mandatory periodical gas inspection services are
not up to par.ÿ >:-)
Let alone his smoke alarms or CO detectors...
Well, those are not mandatory in Spain, not even recommended.
I do remember cases of CO poisoning, but it was in a second residence,
so perhaps not inspected because there was nobody there.
More common are those poisoned in houses that were using the traditional wood coal stoves (usually placed under a table). No inspection in those, obviously.
Gas explosions do happen, but not "many".
On 2026-10-23, Rich <rich@example.invalid> wrote:
The one item left that isn't yet dependent upon electric supply is gas
(methane/propane) tank hot water heaters. Those still seem to be built
as a mechanical thermostat driving a mechanical fuel valve to turn the
burner on and off. Of course, to make hot water they do need a fuel
supply, and if that fuel is piped in from a distribution system instead
of a tank, there's a dependency on the distribution system working.
True - but in my experience electrical failures happen far more
frequently than gas failures.
BTW gas stoves (at least basic cooktops) also run without electricity (although you might have to dig up some matches if you depend on a mains-driven spark to light it). This is quite handy during power
failures, since it means you can still heat something to eat - and
even get a bit of room heating on cold days.
Too bad the Powers that Be are trying to eliminate gas appliances.
I guess we need to save all that gas for LNG sales overseas.
ÿ ELECTRIC is VERY reliable (USA) - gas shit,Not here in California. Wildfires - or even the threat of wildfires -
ÿ well, weekly news about huge explosions or
ÿ fires.
On 2026-10-23, Rich <rich@example.invalid> wrote:
The one item left that isn't yet dependent upon electric supply is
gas (methane/propane) tank hot water heaters. Those still seem to
be built as a mechanical thermostat driving a mechanical fuel valve
to turn the burner on and off. Of course, to make hot water they do
need a fuel supply, and if that fuel is piped in from a distribution
system instead of a tank, there's a dependency on the distribution
system working.
True - but in my experience electrical failures happen far more
frequently than gas failures.
BTW gas stoves (at least basic cooktops) also run without electricity (although you might have to dig up some matches if you depend on a mains-driven spark to light it). This is quite handy during power
failures, since it means you can still heat something to eat - and
even get a bit of room heating on cold days.
Too bad the Powers that Be are trying to eliminate gas appliances. I
guess we need to save all that gas for LNG sales overseas.
| Sysop: | Jacob Catayoc |
|---|---|
| Location: | Pasay City, Metro Manila, Philippines |
| Users: | 5 |
| Nodes: | 4 (0 / 4) |
| Uptime: | 498677:20:30 |
| Calls: | 212 |
| Calls today: | 3 |
| Files: | 910 |
| D/L today: |
31 files (22,593K bytes) |
| Messages: | 69,826 |