• Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss

    From Alan@3:633/10 to All on Friday, November 20, 2026 15:09:49
    Subject: Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    On 2026-11-20 14:58, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still need to pull nails.

    You wouldn't buy it.


    Now you have to purchase a separate attachment just to restore
    functionality that a normal claw hammer already has built in.

    Which attachment may work better for you.


    Meanwhile, someone who bought a normal claw hammer can use that exact same attachment if they want to, while still retaining the ability to pull nails without it.

    But pay more for the hammer with the claw they don't want to use.


    Q: What exactly was traded?
    A: Nothing.

    The normal claw hammer can do everything the crippled hammer can do,
    plus it can pull nails without requiring an additional accessory.

    The missing-claw hammer hasn't gained a capability. It has lost one.
    That's not a tradeoff. It's a loss of functionality.

    Phones work the same way.

    If Phone B can do everything Phone A can do, but also includes an SD card slot and a headphone jack, the buyer of Phone A hasn't necessarily made a tradeoff.

    Phone A is missing functionality that Phone B retains.

    You're assuming that all else remains equal when it clearly does not.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Nuno Silva@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 13:15:51
    Subject: Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    On 2026-11-20, Alan wrote:

    On 2026-11-20 14:58, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of
    functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still >> need to pull nails.

    You wouldn't buy it.


    Now you have to purchase a separate attachment just to restore
    functionality that a normal claw hammer already has built in.

    Which attachment may work better for you.


    Meanwhile, someone who bought a normal claw hammer can use that exact same >> attachment if they want to, while still retaining the ability to pull nails >> without it.

    But pay more for the hammer with the claw they don't want to use.

    It is unrealistic to expect that this will really lead to a decrease in
    the price tag for the consumer, when, for new releases and
    relatively-new models, the approach seems to be more of staggered system
    of pricetag steps, where front-line models get very-expensive prices,
    then you have some steps e.g. at EUR 600 and EUR 300, and then lower
    prices are likely non-front-line models that are also not "new enough".

    And who are we kidding, if actual savings are made by removing ęSD slots
    or by choosing nano-SIM instead of mini-SIM or by ditching the audio
    jack, which manufacturers will not funnel that to bonuses or the like?

    (Actual question, if you know which ones would be above this, that'd be
    a good thing to know. Otherwise, it's pretending Ronald Reagan had a
    point with his tricke-down propaganda...)

    For cutting features to make it so that rising costs fit in the existing pricing model, the same question applies: which manufacturers won't just increase prices if it comes to that?

    --
    Nuno Silva

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Brock McNuggets@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 14:30:14
    Subject: Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt23v$35t$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you
    think we've "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to
    know what the replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial
    television is still relying on antennas being high enough and
    clear of obstacles to receive broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations,
    probably from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof"
    is fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have
    cable/fibre (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's
    not available or not possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV,
    which uses a small antenna, not one "on the roof". And for most
    people, TV (both live and on-demand) is available via the
    Internet.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still
    FM). And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it
    (1200 Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need
    it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is the
    clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not. You
    whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Brock McNuggets@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 14:35:57
    Subject: Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt2f9$l47$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    CrudeSausage wrote:
    Maria Sophia wrote:
    In the case of the phone sans the sd slot, there's *nothing* to
    trade!

    It's important to understand that when an intelligent logical
    person tries to understand the absurd excuses which are endlessly
    repeated by the Apple religious zealots, that well-educated people
    try to UNDERSTAND what it is that goes on inside the minds of
    these strange religious zealot nutcases.

    You have to question the "logic" when someone terms lost
    functionality, a
    *tradeoff*
    *How, exactly, is losing functionality a tradeoff?*

    You have been told: size, weight, water / dust resistance, battery
    life.

    How is losing basic functionality ever a good thing?

    I still have headphones -- wired and wireless. No loss of "basic functionality".

    Apple removed the aux jack, claiming they did it to be
    "courageous". Well. OK. But how is losing the aux jack
    functionality a good thing?

    For the reasons you have been told.

    <snip>

    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Your Name@3:633/10 to All on Sunday, November 22, 2026 11:13:18
    Subject: Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    On 2026-11-21 21:30:14 +0000, Brock McNuggets said:
    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt23v$35t$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've >>>> "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still
    relying on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive >>>> broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably from >>> his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not >>> possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna,
    not one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and
    on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM). And >>> yes, my emergency radio has both.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is the
    clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not. You
    whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    I would ... I detest automatic cars. :-p I especially hate automatic gearboxes in so-called "sports cars", which are made for lazy posers
    and those who think 0.5 seconds quicker to change (into the wrong gear)
    is an advantage. Equally as stupid are the auotmatic cars with faked
    gear changes (flappy paddles, rocking the gear stick up / down, or even
    more useless when in electric cars). :-\






    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Brock McNuggets@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 15:34:03
    Subject: Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    On 21 Nov 2026, Your Name wrote in <11dt51u$faab$1@dont-email.me>:
    On 2026-11-21 21:30:14 +0000, Brock McNuggets said:
    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in
    <11dt23v$35t$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    <snip>

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is
    the clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not.
    You whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    I would ... I detest automatic cars. :-p I especially hate
    automatic gearboxes in so-called "sports cars", which are made for
    lazy posers and those who think 0.5 seconds quicker to change
    (into the wrong gear) is an advantage. Equally as stupid are the
    auotmatic cars with faked gear changes (flappy paddles, rocking
    the gear stick up / down, or even more useless when in electric
    cars). :-\

    I have nothing against manual cars... and of course having such a
    pedal makes sense in them. But for an automatic it generally does
    not. Some prefer one type. Some the other.

    I am very happy with using USB-C headphones (or wireless). I have no
    need or desire for the old AUX style (for my phone). I like that it
    allows the phone to be smaller and more water / dust resistant and
    have better speakers.

    Would I be crying if it did? Nope. It is a small issue. And there
    was minor "pain" in the transition (buying new headphones). Welcome
    to tech.

    Maria struggles to understand this simple concept.



    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Brock McNuggets@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, November 21, 2026 16:14:40
    Subject: Re: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt7fr$2o65$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Your Name wrote:
    <snip>

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is
    the clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not.
    You whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    I would ... I detest automatic cars. :-p I especially hate
    automatic gearboxes in so-called "sports cars", which are made
    for lazy posers and those who think 0.5 seconds quicker to change
    (into the wrong gear) is an advantage. Equally as stupid are the
    auotmatic cars with faked gear changes (flappy paddles, rocking
    the gear stick up / down, or even more useless when in electric
    cars). :-\

    Like you, I have a 30-year old car, and mine is a manual
    transmission. I've even written DIYs on how to replace the clutch
    & flyweel on r.a.t.

    It has 300K miles, where I replaced the clutch at 100K and at
    200K. What I love is the CONTROL we have on the drivetrain of the
    vehicle.

    Especially as I live in steep twisty mountain terrain above
    Silicon Valley.

    The fundamental point here is that calling something a 'tradeoff'
    is incorrect when you get nothing in return for the missing
    functionality.

    The case in point is there is no tradeoff when we don't get an sd
    slot. Likewise with the loss of the aux jack hardware.

    The parrots on this newsgroup often try to explain their distorted
    logic. Which is that they buy a replacement for the missing
    functionality. And, that extra-cost replacement, has functionality
    the lost H/W didn't.

    Fine. But that's not a tradeoff.

    The aux jack phone can do everything that the non-aux jack phone
    can do.

    How can it work with a USB-C headphone?

    While the non-aux-jack phone can't do what the aux-jack
    phone can do.

    It's not a tradeoff when you lose basic H/W but get nothing in
    return.

    You are actively clueless.

    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)