• Re: Is it true there isn't a single one combined TRASH on Android?

    From doseas@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 09, 2026 11:47:33
    On 10/7/2026 5:02 PM, Maria Sophia wrote:


    Is it really true that there's no central trash on Android?
    Why not?

    It seems every app, e.g., "Gallery", has their own separate trash empty.


    On my Samsung Galaxy S23, MyFiles app > Trash is the centralized trash.

    That doesn't preclude apps from also having their own.

    Regards,

    -David

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Frank Slootweg@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 09, 2026 19:46:25
    doseas <not@here.com> wrote:
    On 10/7/2026 5:02 PM, Maria Sophia wrote:

    Is it really true that there's no central trash on Android?
    Why not?

    It seems every app, e.g., "Gallery", has their own separate trash empty.

    On my Samsung Galaxy S23, MyFiles app > Trash is the centralized trash.

    Well, for a very small value of "centralized"!

    For example on Samsung phones, these days the 'Messages' app is the
    Google - not Samsung - version. And when you delete a SMS ('text')
    message from this app, it says 'This action cannot be undone.', so it
    does *not* use the My Files app -> Trash.

    So it's better to say that on Samsung phones, My Files app -> Trash is
    the 'centralized' trash for *Samsung* apps, i.e. for example for
    Samsung's 'My Files' and 'Gallery' apps.

    That doesn't preclude apps from also having their own.

    Exactly.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Arno Welzel@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 09, 2026 21:59:53
    Maria Sophia, 2026-10-08 02:02:

    The wife's 128GB sdcard is full and her 64GB internal Galaxy A32-5G sd is full, so I copy it to USB drive using robocopy for the sd card & adb for
    the internal storage, and that way she can delete anything she wants to.

    a. She has the setting to keep trash for 30 days turned off.
    b. She has 75GB in the sd card trash and 15GB in the internal sd trash.
    c. Yet, with Samsung OneUI, there is no central "delete trash" button.

    Because, there is no concept of a "filesystem" for apps.
    Is it really true that there's no central trash on Android?
    Why not?

    It seems every app, e.g., "Gallery", has their own separate trash empty.

    Because of the Storage Access Framework. Apps nowadays do not access
    "files", the access storage objects and there is no "drive" with a
    "trash can" like in Windows, macOS or Linux desktops.


    --
    Arno Welzel
    https://arnowelzel.de

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From doseas@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, October 10, 2026 11:02:11
    On 10/9/2026 12:46 PM, Frank Slootweg wrote:
    doseas <not@here.com> wrote:

    On my Samsung Galaxy S23, MyFiles app > Trash is the centralized trash.

    Well, for a very small value of "centralized"!

    For example on Samsung phones, these days the 'Messages' app is the
    Google - not Samsung - version. And when you delete a SMS ('text')
    message from this app, it says 'This action cannot be undone.', so it
    does *not* use the My Files app -> Trash.

    So it's better to say that on Samsung phones, My Files app -> Trash is
    the 'centralized' trash for *Samsung* apps, i.e. for example for
    Samsung's 'My Files' and 'Gallery' apps.


    But the centralized trash does exist for many non-Samsung apps that use
    the filesystem -- most 3rd party text editors, for example.

    Android is no different in its handling of "trash" than any other
    operating system that I've ever used.

    For example, in Windows the "Recycle Bin" is the centralized trash can.

    However, if I'm in Outlook and delete an Email, it doesn't go to Recycle
    Bin, instead it goes to Outlook's "Deleted Items", which I must empty separately.

    Google Photos doesn't use make use of Android's centralized trash, it
    uses its own.

    My favorite open-source, cross-platform crossword puzzle app downloads
    new puzzle files from the Internet and stores them in its own folder.
    When I mark them "deleted" it simply flags them in its DB. I then need
    to periodically click on "Clean Up", in which case it removes the files without ever sending them to the OS trash.

    None of the examples that I've cited take away from the OS having a centralized trash.

    -David


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Stan Brown@3:633/10 to All on Sunday, October 11, 2026 16:15:09
    On 9 Oct 2026 19:46:25 GMT, Frank Slootweg wrote:
    For example on Samsung phones, these days the 'Messages' app is the
    Google - not Samsung - version. And when you delete a SMS ('text')
    message from this app, it says 'This action cannot be undone.', so it
    does *not* use the My Files app -> Trash.

    That's interesting. On Googol Messages on my Pixel phone, I can hit
    the trash can after selecting one or more messages, and I get the
    delete confirmation prompt warning that the delete can't be undone.
    But if I hit the 3 dots without selecting particular messages and
    select Trash, I get a confirmation message that the whole chat will
    be moved deleted after 30 days if I select Move to Trash.

    --
    Trolls wouldn't be trolling if nobody would take the flamebait.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Frank Slootweg@3:633/10 to All on Monday, October 12, 2026 14:07:04
    Stan Brown <someone@example.com> wrote:
    On 9 Oct 2026 19:46:25 GMT, Frank Slootweg wrote:
    For example on Samsung phones, these days the 'Messages' app is the Google - not Samsung - version. And when you delete a SMS ('text')
    message from this app, it says 'This action cannot be undone.', so it
    does *not* use the My Files app -> Trash.

    That's interesting. On Googol Messages on my Pixel phone, I can hit
    the trash can after selecting one or more messages, and I get the
    delete confirmation prompt warning that the delete can't be undone.
    But if I hit the 3 dots without selecting particular messages and
    select Trash, I get a confirmation message that the whole chat will
    be moved deleted after 30 days if I select Move to Trash.

    Interesting. Apparently Google uses a special 'Messages' version for
    Samsung phones (it also does that for it's Google Health app), because
    for me the behaviour of the 3-dots-Delete is the same as the one for a
    single message: "This action cannot be undone".

    FWIW, the Google Messages on Samsung version is

    "Version info
    messages.android_20260928_02_RCOO.phone_samsung_dynamic"

    Bottom line: Google Messages != Google Messages

    Sigh!

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Wendelin Uez@3:633/10 to All on Monday, October 12, 2026 14:32:43
    Because, there is no concept of a "filesystem" for apps.

    Miracle of miracles, then I must have a special version of Android because mine is full of files.

    Of course Android uses a real filesystem, but it has no central recycle bin like Windows. In Android, each app must provide its own one, but most apps
    do not need to manage one. Apps dealing with files like Samsungs's file manager often provide one.

    In Windows, deleting a file simply means to move its system record into recycle bin, and Windows can restore the file by moving back this record. In Android, a deleted file might immediately be overwritten by other data if
    the deleting app does not manage recycling.


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From doseas@3:633/10 to All on Tuesday, October 13, 2026 11:52:04
    On 10/13/2026 11:34 AM, Maria Sophia wrote:


    With Android being kind'a sort'a like Linux, why can't Android do that?
    <https://r1.community.samsung.com/t5/others/android-12-may-support-a-trash-bin-for-deleted-files-but-it-s/td-p/10112438>


    The MediaStoreTrash API has been part of Android since at least Android
    12. IIRC, Java's moveToTrash was used before then.


    -David

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Arno Welzel@3:633/10 to All on Tuesday, October 20, 2026 12:34:25
    Wendelin Uez, 2026-10-12 14:32:

    Because, there is no concept of a "filesystem" for apps.

    Miracle of miracles, then I must have a special version of Android because mine is full of files.

    I talk about how apps access these files.

    <https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/providers/document-provider>

    Of course Android uses a real filesystem, but it has no central recycle bin like Windows. In Android, each app must provide its own one, but most apps do not need to manage one. Apps dealing with files like Samsungs's file manager often provide one.

    Even the file manager does not use a "filesystem", but only storage
    providers. And if every "file" is only a storage object with an UUID
    what should a "trash can" then store? Or do you expect very SAF storage provider to bring its own "trash can" interface and a documented way,
    how apps can access it?

    In Windows, deleting a file simply means to move its system record into recycle bin, and Windows can restore the file by moving back this record. In Android, a deleted file might immediately be overwritten by other data if the deleting app does not manage recycling.

    Even in Windows the recycle bin is *not* used, when you access a remote
    file systems on a NAS - even when which is available as "drive".

    Seen from an app in Android, every file is just a storage object and not
    some file on some "local drive".



    --
    Arno Welzel
    https://arnowelzel.de

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)