• Re: PSA: Split APKs & sideloading: What works outside of Google Play?

    From Arno Welzel@3:633/10 to All on Wednesday, September 30, 2026 13:56:11
    Maria Sophia, 2026-09-29 19:57:

    PSA: Split APKs & sideloading: What works outside of Google Play?

    More and more, Google is making normal loading, aka sideloading, harder.

    Why "more and more"? Please be more specific.

    I pity people who won't be able to sideload because of Google copying
    Apple's anti-consumer Draconian control over your personal device.

    Yes, but this is not now but will start in the future. So what exactly
    did Google in the *past* to make sideloading harder?

    Otherwise it is not "more and more".

    For example, AFAIK, native Android doesn't have an app that will install split APKs, outside the Google Play Store app, which can install them.

    There is no need to use split APKs at all. If a software developers or
    vendors want to distribute apps, they can just provide APKs as usual.
    Google did not remove the option for that.

    Yet, almost every app on the Google Play repository, is a split APK.
    How do you install that split APK without using the Google Play Store app?

    You don't. Split APKs are specifically for Google Play. Nearly every
    other app store doesn't use them - like F-Droid or direct downloads.

    Or, what if you have a split APK that you downloaded from the Google Play Store without using the Google Play Store app to obtain it, or, what if you have the split APK in your archives, perhaps saved during a backup/restore?

    Just don't use Google Play - problem solved.

    Yes, this will be harder in the future, but not impossible.


    --
    Arno Welzel
    https://arnowelzel.de

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Arno Welzel@3:633/10 to All on Thursday, October 01, 2026 09:38:03
    Maria Sophia, 2026-09-30 18:21:

    Arno Welzel wrote:
    PSA: Split APKs & sideloading: What works outside of Google Play?

    More and more, Google is making normal loading, aka sideloading, harder.

    Why "more and more"? Please be more specific.

    Hi Arno,

    I get it you defend Google with every breath, but when you do that, you
    need to understand that I back up every single claim I make, with facts.

    No, I don't defend Google. In fact I *hate* Google for their behaviour
    and run Nextcloud, DAVx5, use und publish stuff on F-Droid and tell
    people to NOT USE GOOGLE whenever possible!

    But I don't like bullshit either.

    On XDA Developers, we counted over a dozen *new* points of friction Google has recently *added* to the task of normal loading (aka sideloading).
    <https://xdaforums.com/t/ongoing-january-2027-googles-plan-to-end-sideloading-on-android.4756353/page-16>

    No, this is not "makeing sideloading harder" but "making faking Google
    Play harder".

    Especially Aurora is *not* just simple "sideloading2. Aurora tries to
    act as Google Play replacement. This is something completely different
    than just "sideloading".

    [...]> Oh, I see where your confusion lies. You need more data. Current
    data.
    You are unaware of the sideloading friction employed at this very moment.

    You've never run into "this", but I have, and so have many other people:
    <https://i.postimg.cc/MpKvmcgG/aurora-actual-installer.jpg>

    Yes, because I don't use Aurora, since it is a real bad idea in most
    cases. If you want to use an alternative to paid apps on Google Play,
    use F-Droid. But of course than you can not get all the fancy apps which
    are supposed to be downloaded from Google Play.

    [...]>> There is no need to use split APKs at all. If a software
    developers or
    vendors want to distribute apps, they can just provide APKs as usual.
    Google did not remove the option for that.

    Google did effectively remove the option to upload traditional all-in-one APKs for new apps (mandating the Android App Bundle / AAB format since
    August 2021). <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_App_Bundle>

    Yes, for Google Play(!). I can still provide APKs for my users:

    <http://arnowelzel.de/download/Periodical.apk>

    <https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdid=de.arnowelzel.android.periodical>

    <https://f-droid.org/repo/de.arnowelzel.android.periodical_110.apk>

    <https://f-droid.org/repo/de.arnowelzel.android.periodical_109.apk>

    <https://f-droid.org/repo/de.arnowelzel.android.periodical_108.apk>

    That's why I suggested - just don't use Google Play! Android still
    supports APK.


    [...]> Google's server-side system generates split APKs automatically
    from the
    developer's submitted AAB. Therefore, a developer can't just choose to hand out a monolithic APK if they rely on the Play Store's delivery mechanism.

    Don't use Google Play and also no other app stores who try to "emulate" it.

    Just don't use Google Play - problem solved.

    That's kind of like saying you can avoid being seen by Flock cameras.
    Just don't go anywhere.

    No, that's not the same.

    Your behaviour reminds me on people who complain about Microsoft Windows
    all the time and find dozens of ways to "hack" and "optimize" it and get
    rid of annoyances like circumvent OOBE during installation etc. instead
    of just switching to Linux.

    Oh - and yes, I don't use Windows either. At the moment I have Linux
    with KDE 6.6 and don't miss anything and most of the apps I use in
    Android come from F-Droid.

    Yes, this will be harder in the future, but not impossible.

    Actually, these tactics are making it impossible to use NewPipe, which I
    use every day, so they are making it impossible to sideload, in effect.
    <https://newpipe.net>

    No issues here. I just downloaed the APK and it works as usual on my
    Google Pixel 6a with Android 16 without any "hacks".

    Yes, Google will fuck up Android at some point, but these measures seem
    to be not in place on my device yet.


    --
    Arno Welzel
    https://arnowelzel.de

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Arno Welzel@3:633/10 to All on Thursday, October 01, 2026 14:24:40
    Maria Sophia, 2026-10-01 10:51:

    Arno Welzel wrote:

    [...]

    Yes, Google will fuck up Android at some point, but these measures seem
    to be not in place on my device yet.

    I need you to think about what will happen when you back up an APK (perhaps

    Which I don't.

    it's a Split APK if it came from the Google Play Store app) and then,
    later, you want to re-install that APK on another device (or the same device), especially if that particular version is no longer on the Google Play Store repository (e.g., the last known good version of something)?

    Why should I use crap where I have to backup the binary APK file not to
    loose it? Good software has a well known source and can be built or
    downloaded based on that source.

    --
    Arno Welzel
    https://arnowelzel.de

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)