• Meta warns it may pull encrypted services from Canada

    From Mike Powell@1:2320/107 to All on Wednesday, November 18, 2026 10:12:14
    Meta warns it may pull encrypted services from Canada over controversial bill C-22

    Date:
    Tue, 17 Nov 2026 17:02:25 +0000

    Description:
    Meta has joined Apple, Google, and Signal in opposing Canada's Bill C-22, warning it may consider pulling encrypted services if the surveillance bill passes as written.

    FULL STORY
    Executives testified before the Senate national security committee alongside Signal and Tailscale -- Meta has joined the escalating
    industry revolt against Canada's proposed lawful access legislation,
    warning lawmakers that it may have to consider pulling encrypted
    communications tools from the country.

    The tech giant behind Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp cautioned that the draft law would undermine user security by demanding data access capabilities that cannot coexist with mathematical privacy. Whether you are using a secure chat app or setting up (a) VPN to shield your web traffic, these apps
    rely entirely on strict end-to-end encryption. Under Bill C-22 , known as the Lawful Access Act, Canadian authorities could compel electronic service providers to modify their systems to help police and intelligence agencies intercept communications.

    Appearing on Monday evening before the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs, Meta delivered a blunt challenge to the proposal.

    The hearing took place as Prime Minister Mark Carney's government faces growing pressure from digital rights groups and tech firms, with representatives from Signal and Tailscale also appearing before the committee to lodge objections, according to Bloomberg .

    During Monday's committee hearing, Meta told lawmakers that Ottawa's demands ignore software realities.

    "Ultimately, the Canadian government would be enforcing and imposing a law that it is not technically feasible to comply with and still offer secure, end-to-end encrypted services to Canadians," Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told senators, as reported by CBC .

    When asked if the legislation would prompt Meta to withdraw services from Canada, Rachel Curran, Meta's head of public policy for Canada, said the company would have to "review all of our options". However, Curran confirmed that leaving is something the company would have to "consider".

    Curran previously told Bloomberg that weakening system security is a "red line" for the company, warning that the bill would turn private platforms
    into "an arm of the government's surveillance apparatus".

    Why tech platforms and VPNs oppose Bill C-22

    Opposition to the draft law has mounted steadily since Canada's Bill C-22 passed the House of Commons in June.

    The primary friction point lies in Part 2 of the bill, which authorizes confidential ministerial orders requiring electronic service providers to build ways to give access to law enforcement upon request. It also allows regulations compelling providers to store sensitive customer metadata , such as connection records and IP addresses, for up to six months.

    Can police really access private chats without breaking security for
    everyone? Cryptographers and privacy advocates insist they cannot. If
    software engineers build an interception mechanism for domestic authorities, cybercriminals and foreign spies will inevitably find and exploit that same mechanism.

    Ottawa introduced amendments barring orders that mandate a "systemic vulnerability," but industry leaders argue that definition is vague and
    leaves essential protections open to interpretation.

    The coalition resisting the bill extends well beyond social media.

    Google warned Bill C-22 could break end-to-end encryption , while Apple warned the powers risk customer security. Messaging provider Signal announced it would rather leave Canada than weaken its protocol. Canadian provider Windscribe pledged no changes to its no-logs policy , while advocacy groups have urged the government to fix the bill and pushed for European authorities to intervene .

    With the Senate committee representing the bill's final legislative hurdle before potential passage, platforms are betting that the threat of service withdrawals will push Canadian lawmakers to amend the text.

    Link to news story: https://www.techradar.com/vpn/vpn-privacy-security/meta-warns-it-may-pull-encr ypted-services-from-canada-over-controversial-bill-c-22

    $$
    --- MultiMail/DOS
    * Origin: capitolcityonline.net * KY, USA (1:2320/107)
  • From August Abolins@1:153/757.21 to Mike Powell on Wednesday, November 18, 2026 15:24:00
    Hello Mike!

    ** On Wednesday 18.11.26 - 10:12, Mike Powell wrote to All:

    Meta warns it may pull encrypted services from Canada over controversial bill C-22

    Date:
    Tue, 17 Nov 2026 17:02:25 +0000

    [...]

    Bill C-22 , known as the Lawful Access Act, Canadian authorities could compel electronic service providers to modify their systems to help
    police and intelligence agencies intercept communications.

    [...]


    "Ultimately, the Canadian government would be enforcing and imposing a
    law that it is not technically feasible to comply with and still offer secure, end-to-end encrypted services to Canadians," Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told senators, as reported by CBC
    .

    I read C-22 some time ago, and found no specific requirement that required services to allow access to encrypted content. The gov't shouldn't be interferring with privacy. But.. maybe the re-drafts have changed things. Will have to try and re-read that monstrosity.


    Curran previously told Bloomberg that weakening system security is a "red line" for the company, warning that the bill would turn private platforms into "an arm of the government's surveillance apparatus".

    According to one "bill c-22 explainer" site, metadata is being defined to include the content of a message.

    "Metadata, as defined in C-22, excludes things such as the content of a text message, a person's web browsing history, a person's social media activities. In other words, although the bill will not require internet providers to keep all of your text messages, it does allow the government to require that cellphone companies track the location of devices for up to one year, so that law enforcement and CSIS can later access that data if given judicial authorization. This will turn every cell phone in Canada into a tracking device."

    https://theccf.ca/bill-c-22-explainer/

    But I have a solution. Since messages are "blobs" of text, then the content can be aptly represented as the "stuff" after the header and before the end.

    And that part looks like this example..

    hQIMAzrAVz4tNILzARAAjYEwdvC4TapC5QDUB2SYLIUXfu30Ve8ZtDrJCxtqMBrP yPIUjisYV7i6xrDS0RHE/QWQkzA1REiVZVNV+3v5HqkP5EuiUOZZmAmyaZO3n2qQ xAb5CtR3CILefrHuVQaTrLpJTGNJzepUQSZ/9opTO7umV+ezQ79kUO0PMm87MwZK BIqClrC1wo91Fv+LXB2aEKd4YooY5irjX+AIgVFEG01BxmDst/+UDjQd1HHrCq3U 2JNK0phoTQyR3SeS58nAlqiXikoQkxQo8G+Jubjd05Xshljomm9XnmA/jZIVrOGG mxGMX+pqCy8KUADt99PMEhPm+ftfCmiryxQX7oq6oo219jrMQfl3R6KPq+ePBsC+

    ..then that's what they get! :D That's the "content". Simple.

    The providers don't have to re-engineer things to open security holes. They just have to offer the best attempt to provide that "content" above when requested.

    Also, the gov't has no business telling messaging systems to log all content (outside normal meta-data) for years. If they want logging, maybe the gov't can start promoting fidonet which its sysops are excited about retaining messages in perpetuity! LOL


    The primary friction point lies in Part 2 of the bill, which authorizes confidential ministerial orders requiring electronic service providers to build ways to give access to law enforcement upon request.

    I say fine. Give them the blobs as illustrated above.


    Can police really access private chats without breaking security for everyone? Cryptographers and privacy advocates insist they cannot. If software engineers build an interception mechanism for domestic authorities, cybercriminals and foreign spies will inevitably find and exploit that same mechanism.

    I don't think the bill specifically says "access to private chats/messages".



    Google warned Bill C-22 could break end-to-end encryption , while Apple warned the powers risk customer security. Messaging provider Signal announced it would rather leave Canada than weaken its protocol. Canadian provider Windscribe pledged no changes to its no-logs policy , while advocacy groups have urged the government to fix the bill and pushed for European authorities to intervene .

    I don't think end-to-end encryption is at risk. The bill doesn't even use those terms, at least from what I remember.


    With the Senate committee representing the bill's final legislative
    hurdle before potential passage, platforms are betting that the threat of service withdrawals will push Canadian lawmakers to amend the text.

    The Senate is a bunch old tech-ignorant people, it seems.
    --
    ../|ug

    --- OpenXP 5.0.64
    * Origin: Stare into this point intently ->.<- (1:153/757.21)