On Wed, 11/4/2026 12:08 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Yes, it just occurred to me, anybody who says they have nothing to
hide, then why do they have curtains over their windows?
https://www.youtube
Maybe you could put the ASCII transcript of the vid, into your USENET post ?
Then we would have some context for whatever the title of this video happens to be.
41 minutes ? Really ? How many adverts is that ? That many, should be quite profitable.
But the physicist video that was two hours long, that beats thus for pure gum-beating.
He's in prison. But they got the wrong guy.txt
00:00:01 - 00:00:35 This call is from a federal prison. This call will be recorded and subject to monitoring at any time. This week, I had a call
with someone who is in a federal prison because a database flagged them.
He's one of a growing number of people who've been arrested, denied bail, or sentenced based on what a computer said about them. It's the age of automated computer generated law enforcement. But what about when machines get it wrong? who it just like hit both of us. They got the wrong guy. When someone has unfeted access to every
00:00:35 - 00:01:07 fragment of your life, they can piece these fragments together to form whatever narrative they want. They can easily take them
out of context and paint a picture of you that isn't true. They have put
him in a cage for something he didn't do. They've taken 12 and a half years
of his life away from him. This case is the canary in the coal mine for dystopian forensic technology. But this case also has a whole other side to
it because the man in federal prison that I spoke to is yet another victim
in the government's
00:01:07 - 00:01:43 war on privacy. How long have you been in jail for now?
It has now been more than 5 years for creating a privacy tool. They charged
me with creating a privacy tool. Right. The tool was called Bitcoin Fog, and
it was a way to try to make your Bitcoin transactions more private so that other people couldn't see how much money you have or where you spend it.
In the current war on privacy, there's a slew of developers who are being arrested. But what makes this case even crazier is that the man I spoke to, even after 5 years in jail, still says he's
00:01:43 - 00:02:23 innocent. The computer flagged the wrong guy. This case
to me is an amazing example of how your innocence won't protect you. So,
he's a victim not just of the war on privacy, but also of the new wave of computer automated law enforcement. Law enforcement used to need a witness,
a confession or physical evidence. Now, in a lot of cases, the evidence is
a database match. Basically, the computer told them so. In this video, I
want to share his story. This call is from Roman Sterlingov. You may begin speaking now. Hi, Roman.
00:02:23 - 00:03:02 Hello. Oh, is this Naomi? This is Naomi. Yeah. I'd like
to start at the very beginning if that's all right. Okay. Roman Sterling
was born in Russia. And when he was 14 years old, he and his mother left everything that they knew behind and moved to Sweden. My dad was not around. They split when I was around four or five. How old were you when you moved
to Sweden? When I was 14, I had a stepfather, of course, in Sweden. And uh
it was great. If you're expecting the origin story of a criminal mastermind, this is where it's supposed to begin. And indeed,
00:03:02 - 00:03:37 almost two decades later, a computer would take fragments of this exact period of Roman's life and assemble them into a story. I want
you to hear these fragments first in context from the person who actually
lived them. When you first moved to Sweden, what was that transition like? Yeah, I mean it was challenging. It was a completely different culture. Uh
was a different language. I was um struggling a little bit to find friends
and uh you know even to talk to friends because I didn't speak the language.
00:03:37 - 00:04:17 Roman had just lost his home, his language, and every friend he had. That kind of upheaval and loneliness would be hard on anyone.
I have struggled with depression for quite a while. It got worse when we
moved to Sweden and I was forced to kind of go through all the hardships
of just learning a new culture. That period planted a seed. I was always interested in psychology. So at that time he started reading about mental health tools to help strengthen his mind. These tools would shape the rest
of his life in ways he couldn't imagine at the time. But the other thing
00:04:17 - 00:04:57 he needed was the thing that a 14-year-old who can't
speak the language has the hardest time finding. He needed people. So he
went wherever people were gathering. And in his town that meant land parties.
I was already going to like gaming meetups that we had a really famous land party place in my town couple of times a year. And so I I was kind of already going there to meet people and to find friends. And then when Bitcoin came around, I started going to some of the Bitcoin meetups. It was 2010 and the world hadn't yet
00:04:57 - 00:05:30 become obsessed with it. It was nerd money relegated to small communities of digital enthusiasts. And what drew Roman in had very little to do with the money itself. These were rooms full of people who
would talk to him. If you ever been to a Bitcoin meetup, it really attracts like the coolest kind of people for some reason. And they're not all the same kind of people. You know, they would all be very open. They would usually be very educated, very knowledgeable about different issues. and I felt like I could find new
00:05:30 - 00:06:03 friends. Was a really special experience. I don't know
if there's anything like it. Between the mental health tools he was teaching himself and the people he was finally finding, Roman pulled himself up. He
kept going back to those meetups. I just felt like at home. Honestly, it
was very inclusive and that was kind of new to me. In those days, it was completely normal to buy Bitcoin from people in person, to hand out to strangers, and to treat the meetups as an excuse to spend time with people
who were interested in the cutting edge of
00:06:03 - 00:06:37 tech. Roman was a young guy making friends. Where those coins had been before they reached him, and where they went afterwards was the last thing on his mind. This is the part of the story where the protagonist
is supposed to dive deeper and deeper into Bitcoin, obsessively building
tools until he becomes the privacy mastermind that we've been promised. And that is exactly the story that would be told about these fragments of his
life. But the truth was Roman walked into those meetups with the same view
of privacy that most people
00:06:37 - 00:07:12 have. He had nothing to hide. So why would it matter?
When I think back to Bitcoin meetups, I was actually usually on the side of
a conversation that said that it doesn't really matter and not everything
has to be private. It was surprising to me at that time, but a lot of people there were really into privacy and they were trying to explain to me that
it's like that Noden's quote when he said not caring about piracy because
you have nothing to hide is like not caring about free speech because you
have nothing to say. They try to make me
00:07:12 - 00:07:49 look at the bigger picture and how privacy is important
not just because I personally don't want somebody somewhere look at all my naked pictures. It's like without privacy there are so many other aspects of society kind of break down. So it was a common theme that we should all care about privacy so that government overreach cannot happen. So that people who
do not do any bad things have reasonable privacy protections. The people in that room understood something that Roman hadn't worked out yet. That when
the most powerful
00:07:49 - 00:08:24 institutions in society can see everything about you,
they hold all the power. And privacy is what lets the ordinary person protect themselves from anyone who might one day decide to come after them. Roman
was the one arguing that it didn't matter. He left a trail through those
years. The way anyone who thinks that they have nothing to hide leaves a
trail and someone with unfettered access to that trail would one day piece
it together into a very different person. He was still curious though and
even started using some of
00:08:24 - 00:08:56 the privacy tools that his friends told him about. One
of them was an early Bitcoin mixer called Bitcoin Fog, which let Bitcoin
users transact without revealing the contents of their wallet to everyone
they paid. He never thought twice about it because it was just part of the exploring that everyone in those circles was doing. And for Roman, the whole scene was mostly a social outlet. Anyway, they would be talking about all of these tech topics, not just Bitcoin, but computers in general and all the new
00:08:56 - 00:09:31 technologies that was coming out and then all the other adjacent topics, including spirituality and psychology. It was kind of a melting pot of just interesting ideas. By now, Roman had come a long way
from the lonely kid who first arrived in Sweden, and he was finally doing
well. Talking through these ideas with all the new people in his life who shared his interests got him thinking about turning these interests into something more and he began to consider a career in mental health coaching. Realized that this is something that is really calling me. I found it
00:09:31 - 00:10:09 fascinating how you can improve your own life with just changing your mindset and changing what you sort of choose to focus on. You even had a YouTube channel that was trying to help people uh with their
mental health. Uh yes, it's true. It's uh it's a very small channel. Uh I
was just really starting doing that like a year before I got arrested. Often times I would have a lot of people gathering around and talking about these topics and I would have some good ideas to give them or some good ways to
deal with a problem that they have and I thought that I can
00:10:09 - 00:10:37 try to get the best parts of that and just put them on YouTube so that more people can have access to it. True happiness you can't really have it tomorrow. You can't have it in 2 years. You can't have it when you're like 70. And one of like ways to realizing this is just really thinking about like what you want. Really going inside and like asking yourself like what is it that I want? I've watched some of your videos. I really like them. You've got a lot of really great tips and advice for people.
00:10:37 - 00:11:07 Well, thank you. At that point, I kind of just realized
I have a chance to drastically change somebody's life just through showing
them uh certain techniques. How did it feel to know that your videos were helping people? It felt pretty great. Yeah, I mean that that's what excites
me really about coaching and about making videos in general to know that you can really change somebody's life. But the goal of helping as many people as possible was just one of the things that Roman was working towards. He had
a dream that he'd been carrying since
00:11:07 - 00:11:38 childhood to one day become a pilot. I had this dream
for a really long time if the sky was really calling me and for a long time
it was kind of on a shelf because it's quite expensive to get a license but around 2021 the Bitcoin savings that I had you know they increased so much
that I finally realized I can take some of those savings and finally realize
my dream. He found a place in the USA where he could enroll for lessons. They have a twoe course which is supposed to get you your first private
00:11:38 - 00:12:18 pilot license. I started learning all the theory and I started looking all the courses that I could get my hands on so that I would
be prepared. How long were you studying and and planning and and preparing
for your trip? I would say a year and a half. Why did you decide to come to
the US for that? Oh, US is probably the greatest country for private small plane aviation. The flying culture here is just amazing. Were you excited?
Yes, I was uh I was very excited. Um, it was uh, yeah, it it was just a
dream. I I felt like just flying in general seems really
00:12:18 - 00:12:53 really fun. I've never actually done it. Uh, it was like
my dream of finally, you know, getting real. 3 days away from his pilot's license, he boarded a flight from Sweden to the United States. the plane
lands. I'm already very tired from being jetlagged. And then I get two
border patrol agents that they just come up to me and they just say, "Oh,
look, there's it's a random patrol. You got to come with us." They take all
my bags and they they sit me in a room. They start
00:12:57 - 00:13:30 going through everything in my bags. They they don't
tell me anything. They just say that this is still a random patrol. They
asked me, you know, a lot of weird questions that have really nothing to
do with anything. They they picked out every like item from my baggage and
they just ask a lot of things about it. Did you have any idea about what was going on? No, it was it was very confusing and I always just thought that,
you know, this is this is how the American war agents are. You know, they
made derogatory comments to me.
00:13:30 - 00:14:03 Wow. And uh I didn't know what's going on. And only after like an hour of that, they took all my money. They took all my things. And
then they said, "Okay, now you're going to go talk to these other agents."
And then the other agents, they said, "Oh, we we're with the FBI." And they say, you know, you're under arrest. Obviously, when you know, when they they showed me to a jail, I you know, understood it wasn't just uh just a border patrol. Did you have any idea why they'd
00:14:03 - 00:14:50 arrested you? No, it it was really bizarre. And um back
and then they shipped me off to um to a jail. I was really tired. I'm really confused and scared. They didn't give me any papers or explanations. They
did say that it has something to do with Bitcoin fog. I thought that um some
of the transactions that I was mixing when I was using it, maybe it gone to like a wrong address or came from a wrong address or something like that.
But it was just really confusing and scary. I was in various jails for the
uh first three years just waiting for trial.
00:14:54 - 00:15:30 Hi, I'm Tor Ecklund and I am an attorney who for the last about 15 years has been representing people accused of computer crime u by
the United States government. Roman needed a lawyer and it kind of ended
up on our desk and then one day we looked at it and we were just like what? Like these transactions don't make any sense. We started picking apart like
we do any case and then we went down and met with him. We were talking to
him and then we're like, "Oh my god, you're innocent." It just like hit both
of us.
00:15:30 - 00:16:04 Like this guy is not. They got the wrong guy. To is one
of the most well-known lawyers in the computer crime space, and he's seen
his fair share of corruption in cases. But what he saw in Roman's case him. This case is out of a movie, man. Like there's it's it's insane. Right from
the start, Roman was severely handicapped from preparing for his case. Owned other cases with of similar nature. You know, people actually get bail. But Roman was denied bail for a year. We couldn't even get a books
00:16:04 - 00:16:40 in. No materials. You can maybe get like a 10-minute
call per day, which is very tough. 10 minutes a day. How are you even meant
to mount a defense in that time? It was really hard. My lawyer came in a few times. The jail was two or three hours away from where they were living. Uh yeah, that whole time was crazy. I mean, man, for sure. They wake you up at like 4:00 a.m. in the morning and you has to go like downstairs. is they
take you through various rooms and they prepare you and they like they put
you in shackles and they put you in another room and you
00:16:44 - 00:17:19 have to wait there for half an hour for another hour.
Uh you know they put you on a bus you have to wait on a bus for an hour
and it's just the whole situation is just so stressful that and like barely feel anything. You can barely faint. Uh, you know, when you come back, they
put you in a like a pod, uh, they call it. It's it's like a huge room where there's like 60 other people. Crazy things go on there. Like this this jail
was notorious for like stabbings and things. You know, I was attacked there
uh at
00:17:19 - 00:17:50 different times. Things were stolen from me during the trial. Like what? Like one day when I came back from trial, I come back to
this room where I was and like my things are gone. All my documents are like just thrown around. It's just they and there's nothing you can do about it because to complain you have to like file all these papers and you have to
wait with the officers and I have to prepare for the next day of trial.
So here's the question. If Roman is innocent then what evidence did the government actually bring to trial?
00:17:50 - 00:18:27 There's not a single piece of evidence that came out in trial like ever showing him operating Bitcoin fog. And they had had him under surveillance for years. They wiretapped his servers. They found nothing. And they get a warrant to uh wiretap his internet. Nothing. You know, the FBI arrests him. They get all his computers and they don't find anything on it about Bitcoin fog. And he has an Excel spreadsheet with all his passwords
on it. Right. look for any piece of evidence that actually shows um him operating Bitcoin fog because you won't
00:18:27 - 00:19:03 find it. The whole conviction was based on evidence
from a company called chain analysis which does something called blockchain analytics. The idea is to use software and computer algorithms to try to deanmize crypto transactions. This was one of the earliest cases that used
this software and chain analysis were really trying to make a name for themselves. It could open doors for them to more government contracts. Well, they used a blockchain tracing like surveillance software which obviously
is a brand new technology just cuz the blockchain is so
00:19:03 - 00:19:37 new and it used different types of uristics to analyze blockchain activity. But doing that is harder than it sounds because there's
no personally identifying information recorded in the block. Nobody's name is recorded on the blockchain. So the software has to rely on a lot of guesswork. It uses rules of thumb like assuming that addresses used together at the same transaction belong to the same person or making guesses about the timing of transactions. The software tries to follow the movement of
00:19:37 - 00:20:11 money to an exchange and tie it to real people whose
ID is on file there. It's part of a growing wave of software that hunts
for patterns in huge amounts of data and then flags people based on what it finds. That was close source. We were never allowed to examine the code to
it. We asked. We were barred from that. A man is being sent to jail based on this software. But the defense isn't even allowed to look at how it works.
I said, "Well, how do we know it's not junk science?" We had this kind of
00:20:11 - 00:20:48 hearing you called a Dalbert hearing that lays out the factors that the court is supposed to consider in determining whether some
kind of expert evidence, in this case blockchain forensics, should come into court. They answered every one in the negative, right? Like, so can you tell
me the error rate of your software? No. Can you tell me it's false positives? No. Can you tell me it's rate of false negatives? No. Um, have you guys ever done any error rate analysis as to the accuracy of your software? No. Um,
and the court just let it in and the
00:20:48 - 00:21:19 appel court just upheld that. Wait, they can't even
tell you basic stats about how good the software is and the courts still
allow this software to determine the fate of a man's life? I don't think the courts understand this technology. They just basically said, um, well, we're going to let the software in, this really sophisticated tracing software
that nobody really knows anything about. Um, just based on the fact that
law enforcement says it works. Trust me, bro. That's what they said.
00:21:19 - 00:21:51 That's when you run, right? Trust me. Wow. There has
to be another way for them to see if this software actually works. So they
find someone who runs a competing blockchain analytics company. He gets his company called Cipher Trace, which at the time was a Mastercard company,
and they're like, "Oh my god, this is a mess, right? This is garbage." So
what did Cipher Trace find, you know, a lot of errors? We we get different results. It was definitely really strong evidence and and the questionability about it. It was
00:21:51 - 00:22:26 damaging from the government. This seems like good news.
A competing company says that their analysis doesn't lead to Roman at all.
They can present this testimony at trial and get the case thrown out. About
a week before trial, we get contacted by like Cipher Traces aka Mastercards attorneys saying, "Oh, yeah, sorry. Uh, you know, this witness won't testify. Uh, won't talk to you. If you want to say anything, say it to the attorneys." And it's like a week before trial. there's no way we're getting an
00:22:26 - 00:23:03 expert in. And so we had to do this whole trial without
um this forensic evidence. And you know, kudos to my adversary, whoever made that phone call to Mastercard. Wow. So, let me just summarize this. You have the government hiring a forensic like chain analysis company called Chain Analysis. And this company does a bunch of wizardry that you're not allowed
to actually investigate to see how they did it. They tell you they have no
idea of the error rate. They have no idea of the false positive rate. They
have no idea
00:23:03 - 00:23:38 if any of this works and no one's allowed to examine
it. Um but trust us. So you get one of their competitors to come in and run this analysis. They get completely different results and they can't find any evidence that Roman is guilty. And then a week before trial, this company
backs out because they're a Mastercard company and they say, "We can no
longer actually testify in this case." Is am I understanding this right?
100%. Well, well said. Yeah. Wow. Okay. So, the trial moves ahead
00:23:38 - 00:24:12 using this software. Now, remember how the software works. It follows the money until it reaches something like an exchange where a real person has their ID on file. So out of everyone who ever used Bitcoin fog,
how did the analysis end up landing on Roman? You can see actually this
guy's kind of a boy scout, right? Roman kyced, you know, know your customer
put his PII on his Mount Gox account in 2011 when there was absolutely no requirement to do Mount Gox was an early Bitcoin exchange and Roman KYC or
in other words, he
00:24:12 - 00:24:45 handed over his ID to the exchange without a second
thought at a time when none of these exchanges actually required you to do
so. It's what most of us would probably do if we figured we had nothing to hide. Right at there, I look and I say, "Well, this guy's some super, you
know, secrecy genius and he's KYCing everything." Like this KYC formed the basis of the government's whole analysis. Like they say he made one of the first deposits in the Bitcoin fog and there's like 30 hops, right?
00:24:45 - 00:25:21 What does this mean? Well, they know that this purchase
of Bitcoin is his because his name is on the account. But then the Bitcoin
gets sent to this address and then this one and then this one and it hops
from address to address and all the way down the line it eventually gets deposited into Bitcoin fog. They say that this must be him because he touched the money all the way back here. Imagine you paid whatever $14 for a latte
and you gave the, you know, barista a $20 bill, right? And then that
00:25:21 - 00:25:50 barista gives that $20 bill to somebody else as change for something and so on and so on and so on. And then like 20 transactions, 30 transactions down the line, somebody buys a murder weapon and kills somebody. And then they come back and they, you know, say you're the murderer. That's basically what they're saying here. You initially had this money. The money
was eventually used for this. Therefore, you're guilty. Then there's this transaction graph that they used as evidence. This is Roman right here on
00:25:50 - 00:26:19 his KYCed Mount Gox account. You have all these transactions
here. The money passes through all these hands and eventually is used to buy the Bitcoin fog domain name. The Bitcoin is going from one block, you know, where somebody else goes to another one, goes to another one, and so on and
so on and so on. And then it gets to Bitcoin fog and they say it's Roman.
The reason he's in jail right now is because he gave up his information and
he gave up his identity, right? Because when they did all these traces, the only
00:26:19 - 00:26:52 name that they could find was his. No one was KYCing
their accounts back then, but Roman was. There's not a single piece of
evidence in this case that you don't have to take some speculative leap
from to make an attribution, and it's usually quite a few leaves. They're talking with scientific certainty using pseudocience, unscientific methods
that haven't been verified, haven't been peer-reviewed, uh, no known error rates, um, and they're using it to take people's liberty away.
00:26:52 - 00:27:28 That's to me is very dangerous. But it gets so much worse in this case. It seems like the prosecution outright fabricated evidence for real. Towards the end of the trial, my god, this trial is full of stuff like this. All of a sudden, they show this text we've never seen before and it's
a text from Roman and it's Roman talking about moneyaundering. And we're
like, what? Right? They brought it up and they started saying that it's my
chat and there was no indication that it was my chat and there
00:27:28 - 00:27:59 was no names there and they didn't even show us at
first where it came from. Well, the defense has a really great forensics
guy. So, he takes a closer look at this file. He notices that the file that
the government's saying is the text message is like an old Palm OS file,
right? And he's like, that's not right. And then he realizes, oh, that's
a actually file for an ebook. This wasn't a screenshot of Roman's message history at all. The government has taken a screenshot of a text
00:27:59 - 00:28:31 exchange from some random ebook and then told everyone
it was a screenshot of Roman's message history. They had cropped it in a way
so that it looked like it was a text message from him. And if you just had
just done the full crop, it would have been obvious it was from an ebook.
But we didn't even know it was from ebook. It took us a while to figure that out. By that time, it was too late. The crazy thing to me is that nobody
even listened to our objections and you just bring this chat that has no identified markings in it.
00:28:31 - 00:29:07 It's just a picture and the jury is allowed to see it.
That was just kind of crazy to me. So we called them out on that. The agent apologized and the jury bought the apology. But that that So they outright lied. Wait. So, so if someone wanted to throw me in jail for something, they could just go to an ebook that I'm reading and crop some paragraph in an
ebook and then they could lie about it and say, "This was a text message."
It is what they did here. I mean, they made up a story about, "Oh, I got it from the lab and it was cropped when I
00:29:07 - 00:29:38 got it from the lab." It was just one of the craziest moments. So, what other evidence was there? Well, the rest of the case was basically them saying he used privacy tools, therefore he must have something to hide. There are dozens and dozen examples. They took out a Raspberry Pi
and they showed it up as if it was some sort of a deceased dangerous thing. Anything that, you know, a regular person will not know about and will not understand. They try to bring it up. It's just very easy to make anybody
who has like any technical
00:29:38 - 00:30:15 hobbies. It's just so weird to make them look guilty. anyone who uses privacy tools, that's now a mark of shame and a mark of
guilt um in the government's eyes. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, just even VPNs, like they probably spent several hours talking about VPNs. They were trying to
say him networking into his apartment was him operating Bitcoin fog when it
was him like operating his, you know, remote, you know, plant water. What
is so striking and so scary about this case is there's no corabing evidence
for the attribution made here.
00:30:15 - 00:30:50 After they arrested him, they surely expected to find
the smoking gun on one of his laptops, something that proved definitively
that he ran Bitcoin Fog. But they went through every device he owned, and
they found nothing. They probably thought now I've got this multi-year investigation that I've spent all this money on and I don't have um you
know a big headline. But by this stage they were probably already so far
down the rabbit hole that they felt like they just had to keep going. You're watching all of this information
00:30:50 - 00:31:32 get taken out of context and used to paint this really
bad picture of you. How did that make you feel? Honestly, probably just terrified when I think back. There's really not a lot of time to even feel anything. So, the verdict came down and Roman was to be sent to jail because software did a bunch of compute on a bunch of data and flagged him as guilty
of something. And the jury said, "Well, he must be guilty then." And it's software from a private contractor. The incentive that the private contractor with the private
00:31:32 - 00:32:03 forensic software has with their software is to show
guilt, right? Because the prosecutors that don't get convictions don't get promotions in DOJ. This case is the canary in the cold mine for uh dystopian sort of forensic technology. What's scary about this case is when I realized this guy was innocent. This case to me is an amazing example of how your innocence won't protect you. They've taken 12 and a half years of his life
away from him. They have put him in a cage for something he didn't do.
00:32:03 - 00:32:38 It's really tough to lose a case where you know the
guy's innocent, right? This is the part of the story where right before
the credits you get this blurb on screen of where are they now? Well, we
know where Roman is. You've been in jail for 5 years. Yeah. Uh it's it's
very crazy to think about, but yeah, it's been 5 years already. The worst
thing is being away from everybody I love, away from my life, and really not being able to do anything useful or productive or, you know, barely being
able to learn
00:32:42 - 00:33:16 anything. And while he's been in prison, his stepfather passed away. He passed away about a year into my uh being locked out here. I just miss him, you know. He he was my father figure essentially the you know the only one I had. I would feel like I let him down in this whole situation. When something bad like that happens you know you start thinking about like
all the things you might have done wrong in the past. I could have gone back home and spent more time with him. You know I could have
00:33:16 - 00:33:48 called more. All all the countless nights you uh you you have a lot of time to think here. And I was just starting to think back on,
you know, all the times I have not spent with my loved one cuz now I didn't have any opportunity to do that anymore. So, uh, sad about that. Roman's lawyers have almost exhausted all of his options. They're going to file for what's called an unbank appeal, which is in front of the full court instead
of the three judge panel that headed the appeal the first time. But
00:33:48 - 00:34:23 those appeals rarely get granted. They'll also apply to Scotas where the odds are even worse. They grant appeals less than 1% of the time. But he's desperately hoping that maybe if people pay attention to his case, it will make being granted an appeal more likely or maybe even lead
to a presidential pardon. He's not even halfway through his sentence. And
what happened to chain analysis? It's now a standard compliance software for blockchain and they have multi-million dollar contracts with the government. They start at Treasury and
00:34:23 - 00:34:56 then they've got them with DOJ. This is a an investigation that chain analysis uses among other things to sort of like grow into this government compliance [ÿ__ÿ] it is now. And as they're going along, they're just hiring government people from the the the places that they're interacting with. They hired one of the prosecutors off the case. You know, I battle with the Department of Justice all over the country, a computer crime. What I see
in all these places is that they will enforce the interests of the people
that are going to hire them
00:34:56 - 00:35:32 later. There's this whole like ecosystem of money. I
think it perverts the system because it creates incentives to find people guilty and incentives for government to trust software with no known error rates and keep using this software in government prosecutions anyway. I
mean, who wouldn't want a magic box that spits out any evidence you want
when no one is allowed to examine the code that came up with that evidence
and where the company can't even tell you how accurate the box is? It seems like a real convenient tool
00:35:32 - 00:36:04 to help you get convictions, but it's just one of the
all powerful tools governments all over the world have access to. Now, the surveillance state is their most powerful tool. When the government has
unfeted access to your life, they can take whatever fragments of your life
they have access to and piece together any narrative they want because you
can always take something out of context. They're masters at taking some
little fragment of your life that they've got in surveillance or that they found in some
00:36:04 - 00:36:39 corner here and blowing you up into the antichrist.
A prosecutor can prosecute anyone, any one of us. And people think, "Oh,
I don't have anything to hide." But you're wrong in thinking that your innocence will protect you. That's a naive, childish notion. It's just
going to be really scary because it's sometimes it's so arbitrary. Like
you're they want to make an example out of you. They'll do it. It it doesn't matter if if you've done something or not. So, how does Roman feel about privacy
00:36:39 - 00:37:17 now? Well, sometimes it takes losing something to realize its importance. I do think it's a fundamental right. There just have to be a counterweight to a corruption that ultimately sets in in in every government. We just need a system of checks and balances for that. I think this case is just another one of those cases that's a part of the war on privacy. I think privacy is a constitutional right. I think that's, you know, what you see in the fourth amendment. What's happening now, I think, is a unique moment in
our history
00:37:17 - 00:37:59 and our right to privacy. And that's where you're
seeing this explosion of surveillance technology that is in every crevice
of our lives. And you have to ask the fundamental question, do you trust
the government with that level of information about you? And for me, the
answer is no. Um because I've seen the government take that information
and prosecute innocent people. Your innocence will not protect you here.
That your innocence is irrelevant when they take that machine data, that
pseudo scientific computer
00:37:59 - 00:38:42 print out, and they wave it around with their badge.
And that's why, you know, we need to protect our privacy both legally as
a a fundamental right and through using technology that the government has
no business in regulating because it's our constitutional right to use it. That's one reason I I w certain types of hackers is because I think future they're the resistance. Privacy is kind of that last bastion of protection.
I couldn't agree with you more. I'm so sorry, Roman. I'm so sorry that all
of this happened to you.
00:38:45 - 00:39:27 Well, thank you. Um, you know, thank you for your support. I it it means a lot. Is there anything else that that you wanted to to mention in the limited time we have? And you know, I actually do want to take a chance and just share something with anybody who's listening. Um, I would like to
say, you know, to anybody who is in a difficult situation right now because
I do realize that, you know, while I'm in here, you know, I'm in a pretty
tough spot. I'm away from my family. I have people that are actively trying
to ruin my life for some reason.
00:39:27 - 00:40:02 But I do also understand that that there's a lot of
other people out there and there's a lot of people struggling. People feel depressed. People feel meaningless or just stuck in in circumstances with
no way out. I mean, there's literally wars going on. But to anybody who's
in a difficult situation, I think you need to remember that like all of us,
you are on a personal journey that is made specifically for you. It's tuned
for you and all these experiences are meant to work for you personally and
for what you
00:40:02 - 00:40:37 are trying to learn and where you are trying to go. But
you have to try and take every situation and try to see what it can teach
you. Try to see how the lessons are meant for you personally and to teach
you something very specific that you need to become the real you. Try to
see how your particular circumstances can help you become a better, higher version of yourself. That connection to life is more important than anything and no one can take it from you. Sometimes the uniqueness of these struggles that we go through can feel
00:40:37 - 00:41:12 very cold and impersonal. And if you feel lonely, if you feel like you don't have the connection right now, if you don't feel it, if
you start questioning your sanity, I want you to remember that there are
good ways for you to find it again or to find it in general if you've never felt it. We have found a lot of great ways to do it. There are also people
out there that are willing to help, people with similar struggles. And if you're in a very dark space, in the darkest possible spot, don't despair because sometimes that's exactly at that
00:41:12 - 00:41:49 time that these people and this help appears. Thank you guys for listening. If you'd like to support Roman, visit free roman.org. There's information there about how you can donate. He needs money in order
to continue down the appeals process. Or maybe you can send him a letter and tell him that you're sending strength. And importantly, please make noise
about this case. Perhaps someone who's in a position to help will hear about it. I've also put his YouTube channel in the video description.
Paul
--- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
* Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)