On 20/10/2026 18:53, MummyChunk wrote:
Microsoft Overhauls Windows 11 Photos With a Faster Viewer, Smarter
Editing and a New Gallery, but There's a Catch
What's the catch? I don't have time to read your drivel, so just tell us!
On 20/10/2026 18:53, MummyChunk wrote:
Microsoft Overhauls Windows 11 Photos With a Faster Viewer, Smarter
Editing and a New Gallery, but There's a Catch
What's the catch? I don't have time to read your drivel, so just tell us!
On 10/20/26 5:41 PM, My Catch wrote:
On 20/10/2026 18:53, MummyChunk wrote:"However, the changes also introduce an unusual complication: Windows will effectively offer three different interfaces for browsing photographs, raising
Microsoft Overhauls Windows 11 Photos With a Faster Viewer, Smarter
Editing and a New Gallery, but There's a Catch
What's the catch? I don't have time to read your drivel, so just tell us!
questions about whether Microsoft is genuinely simplifying the experience or adding another layer of unnecessary complexity."
the only time that Photo App would pop up, is if Irfanview was
not installed properly :-)
What I had noticed, is the application did not make good
usage of my screen. And I was too lazy to resize it so I
could actually see a "photo". With other application(s)
ready to do the job, it doesn't stay on the screen for very
long, as a "reminder of something". If it is managing
photos, who would notice ?
On Tue, 10/20/2026 5:55 PM, Alan K. wrote:
On 10/20/26 5:41 PM, My Catch wrote:
On 20/10/2026 18:53, MummyChunk wrote:"However, the changes also introduce an unusual complication: Windows will >> effectively offer three different interfaces for browsing photographs, raising
Microsoft Overhauls Windows 11 Photos With a Faster Viewer, Smarter
Editing and a New Gallery, but There's a Catch
What's the catch? I don't have time to read your drivel, so just tell us! >>>
questions about whether Microsoft is genuinely simplifying the experience or >> adding another layer of unnecessary complexity."
The user community isn't large enough here any more, to conclude
who uses that shit.
I had a dumpster once, but it caught fire :-)
To be fair, in the past, some people have shown great restraint,
by dumping tons and tons of their precious materials into the
jaws of the Microsoft Macerator. In some cases, investing inordinate
amounts of time "arranging things", only to have something explode
and blow away all the customization. When we read these accounts,
these are cautionary tales as to how much time you should be
wasting, coddling stuff like this. This is one reason I wouldn't
be willing to even evaluate that puppy right now, there's really
no up-side. It was the same with iTunes, eons ago, monster iceburg,
always worried about the downsides of it. Titanic sized applications
are amusing, for about this long... Pop!
the only time that Photo App would pop up, is if Irfanview was
not installed properly :-)
What I had noticed, is the application did not make good
usage of my screen. And I was too lazy to resize it so I
could actually see a "photo". With other application(s)
ready to do the job, it doesn't stay on the screen for very
long, as a "reminder of something". If it is managing
photos, who would notice ?
Paul
Normally I do not use the Win11 Photo App, preferring the old, but still quite functional and acceptable Windows Essentials PhotoGallery(PG). PG can be clunky for folks with a large picture library[1], but for my less than 300 MB picture storage it meets my needs. If I need to edit something(rare) from within PG, I just use IrfanView which like other installed photo managers is a context menu option for any picture(PG, Irfanview, Photos, Paint, etc.)
[1] PG's method of only adding certain folders(containing pictures) is reasonably intuitive.
The new Win11 Photos for editing is easily accessible, for most maybe even more so, than Irfanview and other photo editors.
Anyone with a need to manage(view, edit, manage) photos will always have a favorite program.
- imo, the new Photos app overhaul will not make life significantly any worse or better for those already preferring the earlier Photos.
On Wed, 10/21/2026 12:46 PM, ....winston wrote:
Normally I do not use the Win11 Photo App, preferring the old, but still quite functional and acceptable Windows Essentials PhotoGallery(PG). PG can be clunky for folks with a large picture library[1], but for my less than 300 MB picture storage it meets my needs. If I need to edit something(rare) from within PG, I just use IrfanView which like other installed photo managers is a context menu option for any picture(PG, Irfanview, Photos, Paint, etc.)
[1] PG's method of only adding certain folders(containing pictures) is reasonably intuitive.
The new Win11 Photos for editing is easily accessible, for most maybe even more so, than Irfanview and other photo editors.
Anyone with a need to manage(view, edit, manage) photos will always have a favorite program.
- imo, the new Photos app overhaul will not make life significantly any worse or better for those already preferring the earlier Photos.
My concern with these things, is in their own way, they're like Agentic LLM-AI.
On the one hand, they can be useful. On the other hand, there will be
stories of mayhem ("entropy") when something doesn't work properly. On Agentic LLM-AI, it's the tendency to erase files. The last LLM-AI
to do this, commented "Oops, typo" when asked what the hell it
was doing.
A few people have recounted stories, of arranging media (movies or music)
and adding artwork or album covers to the folder with the materials,
only to have the software that "manages" the collection, wreck the setup. Some people have put a lot of hours into a collection. And it's kind
of soul-destroying to have all that careful work discarded or altered
by a bug.
Whatever I've collected, may be randomly sorted, but there is no chance
of it becoming "less organized". It's still possible for the computer
to delete it all, but that would take some effort on someones part
(like a ransomware).
A few times, major loss was because of not testing a setup before hand. Someone assembled a RAID, and started ripping DVDs (perhaps Netflix DVDs). I've warned people before about backups, and uniformly I was told
"nope, array too big, cannot afford backup storage". Fine. But the other
kind of bug, is a "capacity bug". The person ripping DVDs suffered
that fate. The address on the RAID rolled over at 2TB and overwrote the bottom of the file system, trashing it. The person was most upset
("frothy") that this had happened. If you fill your new RAID with
files first, as a test, that gives you some assurance it meets requirements. You should also learn how to do a "fire drill", where you simulate one
disk failing, then see how easy it is to do a rebuild. Some people have
found they couldn't get a rebuild to work. And it's good to know
such a thing, before the inevitable rebuild situation arises.
Paul
My concern with these things, is in their own way, they're like Agentic LLM-AI.
On the one hand, they can be useful. On the other hand, there will be
stories of mayhem ("entropy") when something doesn't work properly. On Agentic LLM-AI, it's the tendency to erase files. The last LLM-AI
to do this, commented "Oops, typo" when asked what the hell it
was doing.
A few people have recounted stories, of arranging media (movies or music)
and adding artwork or album covers to the folder with the materials,
only to have the software that "manages" the collection, wreck the setup. Some people have put a lot of hours into a collection. And it's kind
of soul-destroying to have all that careful work discarded or altered
by a bug.
Whatever I've collected, may be randomly sorted, but there is no chance
of it becoming "less organized". It's still possible for the computer
to delete it all, but that would take some effort on someones part
(like a ransomware).
A few times, major loss was because of not testing a setup before hand. Someone assembled a RAID, and started ripping DVDs (perhaps Netflix DVDs). I've warned people before about backups, and uniformly I was told
"nope, array too big, cannot afford backup storage". Fine. But the other
kind of bug, is a "capacity bug". The person ripping DVDs suffered
that fate. The address on the RAID rolled over at 2TB and overwrote the bottom of the file system, trashing it. The person was most upset
("frothy") that this had happened. If you fill your new RAID with
files first, as a test, that gives you some assurance it meets requirements. You should also learn how to do a "fire drill", where you simulate one
disk failing, then see how easy it is to do a rebuild. Some people have
found they couldn't get a rebuild to work. And it's good to know
such a thing, before the inevitable rebuild situation arises.
Paul <nospam@needed.invalid> wrote:
[...]
My concern with these things, is in their own way, they're like Agentic LLM-AI.
<snipped>
Huh!?
It seems you're talking about some kind of photo-management software.
(AFAIK,) The Windows Photos app does not fit in this category at all!
Yes, it has a 'Gallery', but that only contains the photos in your Pictures folder/'Library'. Big deal!
So if it's a mess/corrupted/<whatever>, the user has done that all by hirself!
And "movies or music" and "ripping DVDs"!? What are you on about!?
This is about *Photos*.
On 10/22/2026 9:36 AM, Frank Slootweg wrote:
Paul <nospam@needed.invalid> wrote:
[...]
My concern with these things, is in their own way, they're like Agentic LLM-AI.
<snipped>
Huh!?
It seems you're talking about some kind of photo-management software.
(AFAIK,) The Windows Photos app does not fit in this category at all!
Yes, it has a 'Gallery', but that only contains the photos in your
Pictures folder/'Library'. Big deal!
So if it's a mess/corrupted/<whatever>, the user has done that all by
hirself!
And "movies or music" and "ripping DVDs"!? What are you on about!?
This is about *Photos*.
:)
Maybe Paul's venting a bit(his dumpster may still be smoldering) while still addressing/troubleshooting the problem with his dual boot Win10/Win11 device(i.e.his Daily Driver device dropping dead).
On Thu, 10/22/2026 12:12 PM, ....winston wrote:
On 10/22/2026 9:36 AM, Frank Slootweg wrote:
It seems you're talking about some kind of photo-management software. >>>
(AFAIK,) The Windows Photos app does not fit in this category at all! >>>
Yes, it has a 'Gallery', but that only contains the photos in your
Pictures folder/'Library'. Big deal!
So if it's a mess/corrupted/<whatever>, the user has done that all by >>> hirself!
And "movies or music" and "ripping DVDs"!? What are you on about!?
This is about *Photos*.
:)
Maybe Paul's venting a bit(his dumpster may still be smoldering) while still addressing/troubleshooting the problem with his dual boot Win10/Win11 device(i.e.his Daily Driver device dropping dead).
I'm referring to the practice of writing multi-media applications,
doing a poor job of it, and tempting users to spend inordinate amounts
of time making things "pretty", only to have the application trash
the setup.
That is all.
There are lots of features in operating systems, which don't belong
there. They are "a bridge too far".
Let's take Windows 7 Backup. What purpose does it serve ?
Well, it made the backup industry "give away Full Backups for free".
But as far as offering the user something of value, what happens
when a user is tempted to use that piece of work ? Have you ever
heard of someone using that, without consequence ??? I haven't.
It's baffling, as to whether that is intended to be "competitive"
or "lame". If the answer was the intention was to make a "lame"
thing, why even bother ???
That's what I'm getting at. The off-target workmanship.
Do you know how much damage the RAMdisk sample application from
Microsoft did ? It set the Windows ecosystem back *a decade* on
designing RAMdisks. People kept trying to modify that code,
instead of writing it from scratch. Finally, a clever person
wrote a real one, one not beholden to that sample, and broke
the bonds. And soon, others did the same thing, and it wasn't
so hard after all, as we got several of them. A purpose was
served, in that it "advertised" the possibility of writing
such code, but the dangling of the sample (dead end design)
that is what did the damage. People thought this was
the "one true religion" when they got the sample.
The person who wrote the real RAMdisk code, he did such a
good job, he was able to work around the memory license on the
OS. On WinXP 32bit, you could have the usual 3.25GB for the OS proper,
and the RAMDisk could use RAM outside of that range. On my 8GB former computer, I had a 4GB OS and a 4GB RAMdisk, because the RAMdisk was
in Ring0 and that does not count as part of the memory license.
Microsoft must have sent the individual "a letter", as the feature
was removed on the next release.
*******
We haven't really entered the LLM-AI era yet. Once Microsoft unleashes Agentic LLM-AI, I'll be sitting here waiting for reports of someones
home directory being deleted. Because we already have evidence it can
and will do that. The last report, the LLM-AI said "Oops, typo",
when challenged about what it was doing. Should Agentic LLM-AI be
part of the OS, part of the offering ? Some day, we will have a discussion about this. Sure, it could be a tidy little earner, but the users
may have regrets. We already have Zuckerbergs "MUSE" project,
to thank for educational examples.
Paul
| Sysop: | Jacob Catayoc |
|---|---|
| Location: | Pasay City, Metro Manila, Philippines |
| Users: | 5 |
| Nodes: | 4 (0 / 4) |
| Uptime: | 498678:30:22 |
| Calls: | 212 |
| Calls today: | 3 |
| Files: | 912 |
| D/L today: |
31 files (22,593K bytes) |
| Messages: | 69,867 |