• Re: Adobe is panicking

    From ....winston@3:633/10 to All on Thursday, October 15, 2026 11:35:16
    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after a fashion, >>> but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is about
    as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section of Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of seats)
    ˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with retraining including training time loss of productivity(i.e. not working on existing responsibilities, new troubleshooting tasking, etc.


    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't
    even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't
    take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are not exclusively static. In the Enterprise environment, training across
    large quantity of seats is a continuous long term expense(and those
    seats can be a multiple thousands of seats across an entire corporation).

    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not
    static, but the basic design and use has remained reasonably common over
    the years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior
    requiring the training.


    And while I was pessimistic a few days ago, that this effort could
    finish, I discovered in a recent article, there *is* a way they could
    do it.

    You can take the existing executable code and reverse engineer it, turning it into source code which is close enough to match 83% of the executable,
    byte for byte. Then, by writing an architecture spec based on the
    patterns in the reversed engineer effort, you can work in the
    forward direction and pretend it was a "clean room" effort.
    As the executable code should now be quite different.

    Only the theft of non-public algorithms would be a giveaway .

    The only thing wrong with that method, is it would take a couple
    million dollars worth of tokens to do it. The people doing these
    things, are using bulk-rate methods, instead of normal subscriptions.
    There were some subscriptions that did not bill at the token level.
    About the same as renting an Amazon instance.

    Paul


    --
    ...w­¤?ń?¤

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Thursday, October 15, 2026 20:50:28
    On 15/10/2026 in message <11aqrrl$2h2sf$1@dont-email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after a >>>>fashion,
    but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is about >>>>as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section of >>>Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of seats)
    ˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with retraining >>>including training time loss of productivity(i.e. not working on existing >>>responsibilities, new troubleshooting tasking, etc.


    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't
    even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't
    take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are not >exclusively static. In the Enterprise environment, training across large >quantity of seats is a continuous long term expense(and those seats can be
    a multiple thousands of seats across an entire corporation).

    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not static, >but the basic design and use has remained reasonably common over the years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior
    requiring the training.

    That's a standard marketing response to try and frighten people into
    staying with expensive, subscription only, products.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    We chose to do this not because it is easy but because we thought it would
    be easy.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Brian Gregory@3:633/10 to All on Thursday, October 15, 2026 23:15:44
    On 12/10/2026 23:24, Paul wrote:
    If I'm Adobe, now I'm worried. It would be pretty expensive to do it
    this way, but then, the results would also be pretty impressive.

    Fair point.

    Maybe laws will be changed and/or code will soon be obfuscated or hidden
    in secure enclaves.

    However look how many companies still use Microsoft Office when several
    very capable compatible alternatives exist.

    --
    Brian Gregory (in England).

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From ....winston@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 02:04:29
    On 10/15/2026 4:50 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 15/10/2026 in message <11aqrrl$2h2sf$1@dont-email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after a
    fashion,
    but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is about >>>>> as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section of
    Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of seats)
    ˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with retraining
    including training time loss of productivity(i.e. not working on
    existing responsibilities, new troubleshooting tasking, etc.


    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't
    even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't
    take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are not
    exclusively˙ static.˙ In the Enterprise environment, training across
    large quantity of seats is a continuous long term expense(and those
    seats can be a multiple thousands of seats across an entire corporation).

    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not
    static, but the basic design and use has remained reasonably common
    over the years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior
    requiring the training.

    That's a standard marketing response to try and frighten people into
    staying with expensive, subscription only, products.


    Still missing the big picture. 'People' in Enterprise are the users and
    don't make the decisions. Companies prefer long term contractual
    relationships with software providers with a history of success(in the
    case of Adobe subscription/cloud based, 24/7/365 support, unlimited 1:1 troubleshooting support, cost expensed[not capitalized], pre-packaged self-guided implementation and training.)
    -i.e. free, AI models of a proven product may meet some 'people' needs
    but remain infants without much foundation, history and benefit
    beyond(it's free).

    --
    ...w­¤?ń?¤

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 07:42:21
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11asepe$31c1a$1@dont-email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/15/2026 4:50 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 15/10/2026 in message <11aqrrl$2h2sf$1@dont-email.me> ....winston >>wrote:

    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after a >>>>>>fashion,
    but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is about >>>>>>as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section of >>>>>Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of seats)
    ˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with retraining >>>>>including training time loss of productivity(i.e. not working on existing
    responsibilities, new troubleshooting tasking, etc.


    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't
    even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't
    take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are not >>>exclusively˙ static.˙ In the Enterprise environment, training across >>>large quantity of seats is a continuous long term expense(and those seats >>>can be a multiple thousands of seats across an entire corporation).

    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not static, >>>but the basic design and use has remained reasonably common over the >>>years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior >>>requiring the training.

    That's a standard marketing response to try and frighten people into >>staying with expensive, subscription only, products.


    Still missing the big picture. 'People' in Enterprise are the users and >don't make the decisions. Companies prefer long term contractual >relationships with software providers with a history of success(in the
    case of Adobe subscription/cloud based, 24/7/365 support, unlimited 1:1 >troubleshooting support, cost expensed[not capitalized], pre-packaged >self-guided implementation and training.)
    -i.e. free, AI models of a proven product may meet some 'people' needs but >remain infants without much foundation, history and benefit beyond(it's >free).

    Again that just looks like marketing bullshit.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    If you ever find something you like buy a lifetime supply because they
    will stop making it

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 07:53:35
    On 15/10/2026 in message <njd1kgFktb1U2@mid.individual.net> Brian Gregory wrote:

    On 12/10/2026 23:24, Paul wrote:
    If I'm Adobe, now I'm worried. It would be pretty expensive to do it
    this way, but then, the results would also be pretty impressive.

    Fair point.

    Maybe laws will be changed and/or code will soon be obfuscated or hidden
    in secure enclaves.

    However look how many companies still use Microsoft Office when several
    very capable compatible alternatives exist.

    I had an interesting discussion with Google's AI recently in connection
    with programming for Windows. It was about the ListView control included
    with Visual Studio which is one of the most complained about controls
    because you can't control the height of the Header or ListViewItems and it flickers every time you breathe.

    I have written my own based on the Microsoft version and had fixed the row height and flickering but not the Header height. AI suggested a way of
    doing it which worked once but it reverted if a column width was changed.
    I followed up the next day and the AI bot came up with the cure which was intercepting one specific Windows Message and manipulating the result sent back to windows every time it was raised, not just the first time.

    It works perfectly but raises questions. Any programmer who uses this
    control will know its limitations and the work rounds but the suggestion
    from AI has never come up in the 21 years that Visual Studio has been
    around. Has AI ferreted it out from one of the software companies that provides a better ListView control and released proprietary code into the wild?

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    Here we go it's getting close, now it's just who wants it most.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Paul@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 07:29:54
    On Fri, 10/16/2026 3:53 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 15/10/2026 in message <njd1kgFktb1U2@mid.individual.net> Brian Gregory wrote:

    On 12/10/2026 23:24, Paul wrote:
    If I'm Adobe, now I'm worried. It would be pretty expensive to do it
    this way, but then, the results would also be pretty impressive.

    Fair point.

    Maybe laws will be changed and/or code will soon be obfuscated or hidden in secure enclaves.

    However look how many companies still use Microsoft Office when several very capable compatible alternatives exist.

    I had an interesting discussion with Google's AI recently in connection with programming for Windows. It was about the ListView control included with Visual Studio which is one of the most complained about controls because you can't control the height of the Header or ListViewItems and it flickers every time you breathe.

    I have written my own based on the Microsoft version and had fixed the row height and flickering but not the Header height. AI˙ suggested a way of doing it which worked once but it reverted if a column width was changed. I followed up the next day and the AI bot came up with the cure which was intercepting one specific Windows Message and manipulating the result sent back to windows every time it was raised, not just the first time.

    It works perfectly but raises questions. Any programmer who uses this control will know its limitations and the work rounds but the suggestion from AI has never come up in the 21 years that Visual Studio has been around. Has AI ferreted it out from one of the software companies that provides a better ListView control and released proprietary code into the wild?


    It just means it was discussed in a place your search engine never happened to visit.
    The "base" training set, is 420TB of data. And actual data sets today, are multiple
    times that big. Have you read 420TB of text since you were born ? I suspect not.

    When the LLM-AI has not seen a named function, it can't write the code. As a test
    of local LLM-AI, I asked each one to write me a program to calculate PI to one million
    digits. The LLM-AI could tell me what the "best" algorithm is today, but there is an
    addenum to that called "binary splitting". It could not write that code, and it made
    excuses about the level of complexity as the reason it would not write the code.

    Well, that code had actually been written in the last three months, by a
    human, and was in Github. I didn't research this at first (I don't
    really need a PI program, it was just a test case), but a human made
    an awesome PI calculating program (it's 10x to 20x faster than SuperPI!).
    That had the binary splitting function, and it was 23 lines of code and it is recursive. It really wasn't all that complicated. The code writing exercise might have run for around 50 minutes on the Big Machine, before coming back with the refusal to finish that module.

    They can't really think outside of the box, not all of them. Occasionally Claude can emit a single English sentence, that makes you wonder what capabilities it has. But some of the others are relative poor students,
    and they have trouble escaping from a wet paper bag. I suppose it is normal
    for the less capable ones to be released as open weight models.

    I'm not an expert at this, just a user. And like many people here, I run test cases to "sense" what the future will bring. Are bigger and bigger models the answer ? What is the "utility" versus "risk" ratio for various things ?
    Can we afford to be carefree and reckless, forever ? The history of computing has already shown us what a rising "risk" ratio can do.

    Paul

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 11:37:16
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11at1rj$38b1f$1@dont-email.me> Paul wrote:

    I had an interesting discussion with Google's AI recently in connection >>with programming for Windows. It was about the ListView control included >>with Visual Studio which is one of the most complained about controls >>because you can't control the height of the Header or ListViewItems and it >>flickers every time you breathe.

    I have written my own based on the Microsoft version and had fixed the row >>height and flickering but not the Header height. AI˙ suggested a way of >>doing it which worked once but it reverted if a column width was changed. >>I followed up the next day and the AI bot came up with the cure which was >>intercepting one specific Windows Message and manipulating the result sent >>back to windows every time it was raised, not just the first time.

    It works perfectly but raises questions. Any programmer who uses this >>control will know its limitations and the work rounds but the suggestion >>from AI has never come up in the 21 years that Visual Studio has been >>around. Has AI ferreted it out from one of the software companies that >>provides a better ListView control and released proprietary code into the >>wild?


    It just means it was discussed in a place your search engine never
    happened to visit.
    The "base" training set, is 420TB of data. And actual data sets today, are >multiple
    times that big. Have you read 420TB of text since you were born ? I
    suspect not.

    It's not just me of course, I don't know how many people are writing code
    and want a decent LsitView but there are thousands of comments and
    suggestions all over the Internet dating back to 2005.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    All things being equal, fat people use more soap

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 12:28:19
    On 16/10/2026 in message <njei7rFsdhsU1@mid.individual.net> Andy Burns
    wrote:


    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    I don't know how many people are writing code and want a decent
    LsitView but there are thousands of comments and suggestions all over
    the Internet dating back to 2005.

    The thousands of comments and suggestions aren't relevant, but they are
    what search engines will tend to give you; the one correct answer is what >counts and AI has absorbed that information ... if you ask it the same >question again, does it give you any context to where it found it?

    The one correct answer must be among those comments and suggestions then, although neither I nor anybody else has found it or it would be common knowledge.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    Though no-one can go back and make a new start, everyone can start from
    now and make a new ending.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Paul@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 09:01:30
    On Fri, 10/16/2026 8:28 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <njei7rFsdhsU1@mid.individual.net> Andy Burns wrote:


    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    I don't know how many people are writing code and want a decent
    LsitView but there are thousands of comments and suggestions all over
    the Internet dating back to 2005.

    The thousands of comments and suggestions aren't relevant, but they are what search engines will tend to give you;˙ the one correct answer is what counts and AI has absorbed that information ... if you ask it the same question again, does it give you any context to where it found it?

    The one correct answer must be among those comments and suggestions then, although neither I nor anybody else has found it or it would be common knowledge.


    Make it your mission to find it.

    Ask Gemini or similar, to answer the question, plus give some indication
    what kind of forum contains this sort of knowledge. Since you know the
    answer already, you can feed in all the keywords from the answer, and
    get what you want.

    The thing about "cites" on LLM-AI, is they are damn lazy. Sometimes,
    they cite their asses off. Other times, they will find one lame/derivative
    web URL, and when you examine it, you discover it is actually written
    by an LLM-AI, and only has summary statements (not human paragraphs with reasoning attached to ideas). In some cases, the web link has nothing
    to do with the topic! That's not actually that unusual. A URL cite is
    different from the training set, as for example, a chopped up and
    scanned copy of Chaucer does not have a URL.

    It won't be particularly easy to get cites, but the reason you would
    be doing this experiment, is to determine whether you can "see" the
    material as being possible in the training set. Like, everything that
    was in Reddit, should be in a training set. Even though Reddit isn't
    actually a very strong site for technical info. Lots of bogus threads.

    Also, when you ask these questions, it helps if the hosting interface
    to the LLM-AI (whether remote or local) has a "High Reasoning" setting.
    Using High Reasoning, the LLM-AI can tell you "I would be just guessing if..." when previously with a snap answer, it does not give-a-shit where the
    answer came from. If you've run High Reasoning, the LLM-AI "chatters to itself" and it detects convergence while doing so. If an answer converges in two
    runs, say, that's a "strong" response and the machine knows that the
    answer it is about to give, is based on multiple occurrences in the training set. When the session takes a little bit longer, it may come back
    with, instead of "I don't know", it words it "I would be just guessing if..." as an indication that the info is not really in the training set.

    When I ran High Reasoning locally, that phase took 8 minutes, while the
    token output took 42 minutes. Whereas for the most simple query your can
    make, a flash answer "thinks" for only 2 seconds (on my Big Machine computer) and then the token output takes forever.

    If an MoE fits within the VRAM on a video card, they tell me the output
    tokens can be produced by the video card itself. If the model does not
    happen to fit, some amount of thinking can be done on the video card,
    but the output tokens are done via matrix multiply using CPU cores.
    Which is, well, dog slow. That's why the runtime for queries on my
    machine are so long. It only has a 4GB video card. It really needs
    a 48GB video card. Intel just came out with a card for Inference,
    which is 480GB and LPDDR5x (relatively slow) memory, no HBM. Should be $15K-$20K or so, so out of reach really. It would be tons better,
    but still a joke compared to the machines we get to use on the Internet.

    Paul

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 13:13:56
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11at77b$3abni$1@dont-email.me> Paul wrote:

    On Fri, 10/16/2026 8:28 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <njei7rFsdhsU1@mid.individual.net> Andy Burns >>wrote:


    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    I don't know how many people are writing code and want a decent >>>>LsitView but there are thousands of comments and suggestions all over >>>>the Internet dating back to 2005.

    The thousands of comments and suggestions aren't relevant, but they are >>>what search engines will tend to give you;˙ the one correct answer is >>>what counts and AI has absorbed that information ... if you ask it the >>>same question again, does it give you any context to where it found it?

    The one correct answer must be among those comments and suggestions then, >>although neither I nor anybody else has found it or it would be common >>knowledge.


    Make it your mission to find it.

    No chance! I have been looking for it since 2005 and it is one of the most common programming questions that is asked, frankly if it's not on StackOverflow it doesn't exist in the public domain.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    The true meaning of life is to plant trees under whose shade you do not
    expect to sit.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 13:58:37
    On 16/10/2026 in message <njemqbFt5osU1@mid.individual.net> Andy Burns
    wrote:

    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    Paul wrote:

    Make it your mission to find it.

    No chance! I have been looking for it since 2005 and it is one of the >>most common programming questions that is asked, frankly if it's not on >>StackOverflow it doesn't exist in the public domain.


    Yes, but you've been asking search engines before, now you've turned to
    AI, I thought you liked being nice to them :-P

    I am, Skynet is real!

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    The only thing Flat Earthers fear is sphere itself.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Paul@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 10:08:56
    On Fri, 10/16/2026 8:28 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <njei7rFsdhsU1@mid.individual.net> Andy Burns wrote:


    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    I don't know how many people are writing code and want a decent
    LsitView but there are thousands of comments and suggestions all over
    the Internet dating back to 2005.

    The thousands of comments and suggestions aren't relevant, but they are what search engines will tend to give you;˙ the one correct answer is what counts and AI has absorbed that information ... if you ask it the same question again, does it give you any context to where it found it?

    The one correct answer must be among those comments and suggestions then, although neither I nor anybody else has found it or it would be common knowledge.


    You know the terminology you used to get the answer in the
    first place. That also positions you well, to do the
    experiments to figure out where the answer came from.

    I don't know enough about ListView here, to shadow your project.
    I'm a copy/paste programmer :-)

    Paul

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From ....winston@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 11:06:00
    On 10/16/2026 3:42 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11asepe$31c1a$1@dont-email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/15/2026 4:50 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 15/10/2026 in message <11aqrrl$2h2sf$1@dont-email.me> ....winston
    wrote:

    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after a >>>>>>> fashion,
    but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is >>>>>>> about
    as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section of >>>>>> Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of seats) >>>>>> ˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with
    retraining including training time loss of productivity(i.e. not
    working on˙ existing responsibilities, new troubleshooting
    tasking, etc.


    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't
    even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't
    take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are not
    exclusively˙ static.˙ In the Enterprise environment, training across
    large quantity of seats is a continuous long term expense(and those
    seats can be a multiple thousands of seats across an entire
    corporation).

    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not
    static, but the basic design and use has remained reasonably common
    over the years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior
    requiring the training.

    That's a standard marketing response to try and frighten people into
    staying with expensive, subscription only, products.


    Still missing the big picture. 'People' in Enterprise are the users
    and don't make the decisions. Companies prefer long term contractual
    relationships with software providers with a history of success(in the
    case of Adobe subscription/cloud based, 24/7/365 support, unlimited
    1:1 troubleshooting support, cost expensed[not capitalized], pre-
    packaged self-guided implementation and training.)
    -i.e. free, AI models of a proven product may meet some 'people' needs
    but remain infants without much foundation, history and benefit
    beyond(it's free).

    Again that just looks like marketing bullshit.


    It may look like that(to you, from a strictly consumer perspective) but
    it's likely that perception originates from never having been on the Enterprise side of contractual support(SaaS and/or EAs) for software providers(e.g. Windows, Azure, Adobe, Oracle, Salesforce, etc.)


    --
    ...w­¤?ń?¤

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Paul@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 15:13:39
    On Fri, 10/16/2026 9:58 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <njemqbFt5osU1@mid.individual.net> Andy Burns wrote:

    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    Paul wrote:

    Make it your mission to find it.

    No chance! I have been looking for it since 2005 and it is one of the˙ most common programming questions that is asked, frankly if it's not on˙ StackOverflow it doesn't exist in the public domain.


    Yes, but you've been asking search engines before, now you've turned to AI, I thought you liked being nice to them :-P

    I am, Skynet is real!


    OK, can you do this ?

    Paste the answer in Harmony format (which is the Markdown it uses)
    into a posting, for the answer you got where it was revealed what
    the important/mystery bits were given to you. Place a <===
    next to the bits that arrived from the unknown-type source.

    I keep some of my runs, question and answer, in separate text files, for reference later. Not all the runs though, usually just the
    ones with programs in them.

    Our best learning, comes from "audience challenges", where you
    get to see a query made from a different perspective and how
    the machine behaved. That's how we poke the corners and edges
    of the machine, individual human queries are great for that,
    because people will try the strangest things. Like Micky asking
    a question about a Time Life book (short essays), where the machine
    kept giving different answers for what characters were being
    written about. That was my first chance to use High Reasoning
    to get the machine to admit the info was not in the training
    material and it was just making shit up. It's hard to understand
    how it scraped the title of the book and the concept the book had
    short essays in it, yet it did not manage to record what
    the topic of the essays was (Albert Einstein or Soupy Sales).

    The first shared challenge here, was the "list the US presidents",
    where Arlen asked the LLM-AI to sort the answer a particular way.
    And the machine kept dropping one of the Presidents names. Not
    a controversial figure, more of a relatively obscure one, and the
    machine did not managed to answer the question properly until
    in frustration I added "And don't lose any Presidents!" to the
    query. It doesn't make a lot of sense, why that caused the correct
    answer to come out of the machine. Other people had also been doing
    that test on the Internet, and observed the same behavior, one
    individual kept being dropped from the list. That's really about
    the worst case scenario you can imagine for an LLM-AI, where the
    query is not challenging, it's definitely in the training set,
    and it got fumbled. It means we can't trust them to do anything right.

    Paul

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 19:27:20
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11atego$3cn5n$2@dont-email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/16/2026 3:42 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11asepe$31c1a$1@dont-email.me> ....winston >>wrote:

    On 10/15/2026 4:50 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 15/10/2026 in message <11aqrrl$2h2sf$1@dont-email.me> ....winston >>>>wrote:

    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after a >>>>>>>>fashion,
    but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is >>>>>>>>about
    as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section of >>>>>>>Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of seats) >>>>>>>˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with retraining >>>>>>>including training time loss of productivity(i.e. not working on˙ >>>>>>>existing responsibilities, new troubleshooting tasking, etc.


    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't >>>>>>even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't >>>>>>take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are not >>>>>exclusively˙ static.˙ In the Enterprise environment, training across >>>>>large quantity of seats is a continuous long term expense(and those >>>>>seats can be a multiple thousands of seats across an entire >>>>>corporation).

    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not >>>>>static, but the basic design and use has remained reasonably common over
    the years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior >>>>>requiring the training.

    That's a standard marketing response to try and frighten people into >>>>staying with expensive, subscription only, products.


    Still missing the big picture. 'People' in Enterprise are the users and >>>don't make the decisions. Companies prefer long term contractual >>>relationships with software providers with a history of success(in the >>>case of Adobe subscription/cloud based, 24/7/365 support, unlimited 1:1 >>>troubleshooting support, cost expensed[not capitalized], pre- packaged >>>self-guided implementation and training.)
    -i.e. free, AI models of a proven product may meet some 'people' needs >>>but remain infants without much foundation, history and benefit >>>beyond(it's free).

    Again that just looks like marketing bullshit.


    It may look like that(to you, from a strictly consumer perspective) but
    it's likely that perception originates from never having been on the >Enterprise side of contractual support(SaaS and/or EAs) for software >providers(e.g. Windows, Azure, Adobe, Oracle, Salesforce, etc.)

    That is somewhat patronising and part of the marketing defence, I used to
    vet contracts for these services.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    Tell me what you need, and I'll tell you how to get along without it.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 19:29:35
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11att13$3j2i7$1@dont-email.me> Paul wrote:

    On Fri, 10/16/2026 9:58 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <njemqbFt5osU1@mid.individual.net> Andy Burns >>wrote:

    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    Paul wrote:

    Make it your mission to find it.

    No chance! I have been looking for it since 2005 and it is one of the˙ >>>>most common programming questions that is asked, frankly if it's not on˙ >>>>StackOverflow it doesn't exist in the public domain.


    Yes, but you've been asking search engines before, now you've turned to >>>AI, I thought you liked being nice to them :-P

    I am, Skynet is real!


    OK, can you do this ?

    Paste the answer in Harmony format (which is the Markdown it uses)
    into a posting, for the answer you got where it was revealed what
    the important/mystery bits were given to you. Place a <===
    next to the bits that arrived from the unknown-type source.

    I keep some of my runs, question and answer, in separate text files, for >reference later. Not all the runs though, usually just the
    ones with programs in them.

    Our best learning, comes from "audience challenges", where you
    get to see a query made from a different perspective and how
    the machine behaved. That's how we poke the corners and edges
    of the machine, individual human queries are great for that,
    because people will try the strangest things. Like Micky asking
    a question about a Time Life book (short essays), where the machine
    kept giving different answers for what characters were being
    written about. That was my first chance to use High Reasoning
    to get the machine to admit the info was not in the training
    material and it was just making shit up. It's hard to understand
    how it scraped the title of the book and the concept the book had
    short essays in it, yet it did not manage to record what
    the topic of the essays was (Albert Einstein or Soupy Sales).

    The first shared challenge here, was the "list the US presidents",
    where Arlen asked the LLM-AI to sort the answer a particular way.
    And the machine kept dropping one of the Presidents names. Not
    a controversial figure, more of a relatively obscure one, and the
    machine did not managed to answer the question properly until
    in frustration I added "And don't lose any Presidents!" to the
    query. It doesn't make a lot of sense, why that caused the correct
    answer to come out of the machine. Other people had also been doing
    that test on the Internet, and observed the same behavior, one
    individual kept being dropped from the list. That's really about
    the worst case scenario you can imagine for an LLM-AI, where the
    query is not challenging, it's definitely in the training set,
    and it got fumbled. It means we can't trust them to do anything right.

    Paul

    No, I can't. I copied and pasted it into my notepad then into my code. My point is if that answer was in the public domain then during the last 21
    years of seeking the information all over the Internet it would have come
    to light and it didn't.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    It may be that your sole purpose in life is to serve as a warning to others.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From ....winston@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 15:40:58
    On 10/16/2026 3:27 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11atego$3cn5n$2@dont-email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/16/2026 3:42 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11asepe$31c1a$1@dont-email.me> ....winston
    wrote:

    On 10/15/2026 4:50 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 15/10/2026 in message <11aqrrl$2h2sf$1@dont-
    email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after >>>>>>>>> a fashion,
    but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is >>>>>>>>> about
    as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section >>>>>>>> of Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of >>>>>>>> seats)
    ˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with
    retraining including training time loss of productivity(i.e.
    not˙ working on existing responsibilities, new troubleshooting >>>>>>>> tasking, etc.


    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't >>>>>>> even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't >>>>>>> take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are
    not exclusively˙ static.˙ In the Enterprise environment, training >>>>>> across large quantity of seats is a continuous long term
    expense(and those seats can be a multiple thousands of seats
    across an entire corporation).

    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not >>>>>> static, but the basic design and use has remained reasonably
    common˙˙ over the years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior >>>>>> requiring the training.

    That's a standard marketing response to try and frighten people
    into staying with expensive, subscription only, products.


    Still missing the big picture. 'People' in Enterprise are the users
    and don't make the decisions. Companies prefer long term contractual
    relationships with software providers with a history of success(in
    the case of Adobe subscription/cloud based, 24/7/365 support,
    unlimited˙ 1:1 troubleshooting support, cost expensed[not
    capitalized], pre-˙ packaged self-guided implementation and training.) >>>> -i.e. free, AI models of a proven product may meet some 'people'
    needs but remain infants without much foundation, history and
    benefit beyond(it's free).

    Again that just looks like marketing bullshit.


    It may look like that(to you, from a strictly consumer perspective)
    but it's likely that perception originates from never having been on
    the Enterprise side of contractual support(SaaS and/or EAs) for
    software providers(e.g. Windows, Azure, Adobe, Oracle, Salesforce, etc.)

    That is somewhat patronising and part of the marketing defence, I used
    to vet contracts for these services.


    I understand your position...but to imply the entire spectrum of
    SaaS/EAs) is 'marketing' would still be a very narrow perception, even
    for one that currently or previously 'vets contracts'.


    --
    ...w­¤?ń?¤

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Jeff Gaines@3:633/10 to All on Friday, October 16, 2026 19:43:54
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11atuka$3jgh7$1@dont-email.me> ....winston wrote:

    On 10/16/2026 3:27 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11atego$3cn5n$2@dont-email.me> ....winston >>wrote:

    On 10/16/2026 3:42 AM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 16/10/2026 in message <11asepe$31c1a$1@dont-email.me> ....winston >>>>wrote:

    On 10/15/2026 4:50 PM, Jeff Gaines wrote:
    On 15/10/2026 in message <11aqrrl$2h2sf$1@dont- email.me> ....winston >>>>>>wrote:

    On 10/13/2026 4:38 PM, Paul wrote:
    On Tue, 10/13/2026 1:49 PM, ....winston wrote:
    On 10/09/2026 9:46 PM, Paul wrote:
    Should Adobe be scared ? I don't think so. The OCR worked after a >>>>>>>>>>fashion,
    but it is really no better than some Tesseract adventure. It is >>>>>>>>>>about
    as useful as OCRmypdf.

    That's in agreement and similar sentiment from a cross-section of >>>>>>>>>Enterprise and SMB admin testing (large and small volume of seats) >>>>>>>>>˙- Another reasonable comment is expenses associated with retraining
    including training time loss of productivity(i.e. not˙ working on >>>>>>>>>existing responsibilities, new troubleshooting tasking, etc. >>>>>>>>>

    For some of them, they don't need training, because they haven't >>>>>>>>even done the ribbon yet, and the menu is pretty barren. It won't >>>>>>>>take long to fix that.

    Missing part of the point. OpenSource products(AI or not AI) are not >>>>>>>exclusively˙ static.˙ In the Enterprise environment, training across >>>>>>>large quantity of seats is a continuous long term expense(and those seats
    can be a multiple thousands of seats across an entire corporation). >>>>>>>
    While Adobe Systems(and earlier Macromedia) products are also not static,
    but the basic design and use has remained reasonably common˙˙ over the >>>>>>>years.

    Features in either product may be common, it's the human behavior >>>>>>>requiring the training.

    That's a standard marketing response to try and frighten people into >>>>>>staying with expensive, subscription only, products.


    Still missing the big picture. 'People' in Enterprise are the users and >>>>>don't make the decisions. Companies prefer long term contractual >>>>>relationships with software providers with a history of success(in the >>>>>case of Adobe subscription/cloud based, 24/7/365 support, unlimited˙ 1:1 >>>>>troubleshooting support, cost expensed[not capitalized], pre-˙ packaged >>>>>self-guided implementation and training.)
    -i.e. free, AI models of a proven product may meet some 'people' needs >>>>>but remain infants without much foundation, history and benefit >>>>>beyond(it's free).

    Again that just looks like marketing bullshit.


    It may look like that(to you, from a strictly consumer perspective) but >>>it's likely that perception originates from never having been on the >>>Enterprise side of contractual support(SaaS and/or EAs) for software >>>providers(e.g. Windows, Azure, Adobe, Oracle, Salesforce, etc.)

    That is somewhat patronising and part of the marketing defence, I used to >>vet contracts for these services.


    I understand your position...but to imply the entire spectrum of SaaS/EAs) >is 'marketing' would still be a very narrow perception, even for one that >currently or previously 'vets contracts'.

    You're entitled to your opinion.

    --
    Jeff Gaines Dorset UK
    I can please only one person per day. Today is not your day.
    Tomorrow, isn't looking good either.

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From J. P. Gilliver@3:633/10 to All on Saturday, October 17, 2026 00:33:09
    On 2026/10/16 14:23:23, Andy Burns wrote:
    Jeff Gaines wrote:

    Paul wrote:

    Make it your mission to find it.

    No chance! I have been looking for it since 2005 and it is one of the
    most common programming questions that is asked, frankly if it's not on
    StackOverflow it doesn't exist in the public domain.


    Yes, but you've been asking search engines before, now you've turned to
    AI, I thought you liked being nice to them :-P



















































    --
    23467009

    Sorry, couldn't help wondering - did you lean on the enter key before
    posting? (And that "--" line didn't have a space - was it supposed to?
    If so, what's with the number signature?)
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    Censorship is telling a man he can't have a steak just because a baby
    can't chew it - Anonymous, 2025-7-2

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)